[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: 10970.jpg (102 KB, 268x315)
102 KB
102 KB JPG
hey /a/, is this animu worth a try?
or should i skip it hands down?
>>
Its's shit.
>>
I thought some episodes were pretty funny, but I did end up dropping it.
>>
Cute girls doing cute things in cute ways should work for something other then Ichigo Marshmallow right? HAHAHAHA no
>>
Watch it for the girls
>>
SKIP! Holy shit skip it ffs! Please get it the fuck away! waaaaah!

however, the manga was well drawn and did have some good moments.
>>
File: 1205409094006.gif (842 KB, 400x300)
842 KB
842 KB GIF
>>10206353
I don't think you've seen this show at all if that's what you think it's about.
>>
is the character design at least something nice?
what about fanservice ?
>>
>>10206385
Character design isn't too bad, there is some fanservice, not as much as some people might like, but there is some.
>>
The anime is bad even for and adaption. Read the manga.
>>
The anime is bad even for an adaption. Read the manga.
>>
>>10206385
yeah heaps of fanservice. But FUCKIN QUALITEE animation though. And the sound track consists of shit you'd expect to hear in a clown show (who the fuck's idea was it to sample fart noises and integrate them consistently as major punctuation points in the musical tracks?)
>>
This anime is good, but not "worth the effort to download" good.

and it's really easy to download.
>>
ok so, i'll trust /a/ comments and say: fuck this shit
>>
It's pretty shit. Regardless, I liked it. I found it entertaining and addictive. Though every episode I wandered why I was still watching that shit, and when it ended I wandered about why the fuck was I sad about it ending.

I think it's more entertaining than Lucky Star if that gives you any references.
>>
the manga is pretty good. worth a look IMO.
>>
>>10206453
Stop fucking trolling.
>>
>>10206438
I think you should watch the first two episodes and judge for yourself if you have nothing else to watch. If you're busy, well, yeah, you're not missing much.
>>
>>10206344
Watched it all, it's shit.
>>
>>10206475
No, really. I think they were pretty even. Both had shitty BGM and both recycled jokes. One had better animation because it had better budget, the other didn't. One focused on retarded moe the other one focused on panties. One actually tried to make original content, the other one was mostly references. One was unnecessarily long, the other one wasn't. One had Mamiko Noto the other one had Aya Hirano.

Overall they're both shitty but enjoyable.
>>
>>10206344
Nothing special, but occasionally funny. Watching it won't hurt you, but there's plenty of better stuff out there. Way funnier than Lucky Star, though.
>>
>>10206503
>shitty but enjoyable
That doesn't make any fucking sense, anime is for your enjoyment, if you enjoyed it... how can you say it's shitty?

Stop trying to please everyone, either you think it's shitty or you don't.
>>
>>10206559
It's shit
>>
>>10206559
in a far distant world you have never heard of, borders aren't as defined and there is an infinite number of shades of gray between the color white and the color black.

We hail from that world.

I see we are the only ones.
>>
>>10206569
Wow, you are dumb.

Read this and try to follow.

Shitty anime - bad
Enjoyable anime - good
The only thing an anime needs in order to be good is to be enjoyable since that's what the fuck they are for.
An anime cannot be enjoyable AND shitty.


It's the same for popular anime, you may not like them, but by default they are good because a large number of people enjoy them.
>>
>>10206344
It's not great, but it's pretty funny after the initial fanservice overload episode.
>>
>>10206599An anime cannot be enjoyable AND shitty

Sure it can.

Enjoyable doesn't necessarily equate to good. Other factors must be taken into account. Is the animation decent? Are the characters likable? Is the plot okay?

Something can be utter tripe, but still be enjoyable. Like soap operas.
>>
ITT people have obviously never heard of either guilty pleasures, or "so bad it's good".

Come on, we all have a series or two that we can recognize is complete and utter dogshit, but we still enjoy anyways for all sorts of reasons.
>>
>>10206634
I make a pie, said pie tastes great but looks like shit.

Is the pie a good pie?
>>
>>10206642
I've never thought a show was utter dogshit, yet enjoyed it.
What the fuck are you talking about?
>>
>>10206652
Yes. I know of many desserts that look absolutely terrible but taste great.
>>
ITT people don't define detail in their opinions.

Shit is more of a end result defining term.
An anime can have no substance, but be entertaining for whatever reason, and thus good.
An anime can be serious as hell, intricate and realistic as hell, but lack in entertainment, it can still be good for it's positive points.

Nanoha got example, substanceless, drilled morales and friendship speeches, huge pink death beams of glory = entertaining, thus it was good.
Even if you yourself were dissatisfied, that is simply opinion and not a way to overall judge a series on it's pitfalls and merits.
>>
i thought it was pretty enjoyable
>>
I quite liked HSG. Worth pointing out to OP that 90% of the fanservice is in the first couple of episodes for good or ill and that the first episode is kinda shit.

Also giving a vote for the manga, since I just finished reading it up to date.



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.