[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


Why is Nisekoi adaptation so shit? Who the hell though it was good idea to give it to Shinbo?
>>
fuck your opinion doe
>>
fasdadqeeqefuckyouopdasddasda
>>
>>101737285
she wins the claude, right?
>>
I am pretty sure by now SHAFT shows are randomly generated by computer program.
>>
Shit direction. Shit visuals. It just does not feel right. Music is at times ok, at times horrible.

Any other studio could have adapted it better. Just look at JC Staff this season with glorious WCW.
>>
>SHAFT anime
>bad
How about no.
>>
>>101737428
You forgot shit vomit inducing colors and cheap backgrounds, flat perspective and WinAmp visualization special effects.
>>
>>101737495
So new it hurts.
>>
Who thought it was a good idea to give a good studio a shitty story?
>>
its not worse than the already shitty source material
>>
If anything, it's more watchable than the original is readable.

But Nisekoi has always been crap though.
>>
Because Nisekoi is a shit manga.
>>
You make it sound like Nisekoi is a masterpiece. A shit manga deserves to get adapted by a shit studio.
>>
I like it.
>>
>>101737471
>>101737507
It looks absolutely, completely fine in every possible way. What the actual fuck are you people on about?
>>
You mean
Why is Nisekoi so shit?
>>
Why does the MC carry a necklace half the size of his face? What on earth could it beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee?
>>
>>101737558
But it is. Any decent studio with expirience of adapting such stuff - JC Staff, A-1, Sunrise., Would have made a decent anime. Shaft on other hand? Its Negima?! all over again.

>>101737552
>Shaft
>good studio
Shaft was by far one of the worst studios until Bake/Madoka made it famouse. Their current "style" mostly originated simply because they could not do stuff on time and had no people to draw decent backgrounds and art. Most talented people length left it. Sakura Trick and Nourin are both better "shaft" shows this season than Nisekoi
>>
The adaption is very accurate.
You can't blame the source material on Shaft.

They managed to make it more interesting and fun than the manga, that's enough.
>>
It's no wonder it's shit. How many adaptions can you think of that surpass their original?
>>
The only reason I watch this is because I actually like SHAFT and seeing SHAFT animate Onodera. Nisekoi just isn't really that great in the first place, nothing about it stands out.
>>
>>101737608
It must feel good to have such shit taste and be so ignorant. I see new generation of Shaft-newfags has arrived. Post-gatari generation is already desilusioned, so you must be a post-madoka fag.
>>
>>101737471
>Just look at JC Staff this season with glorious WCW
Lel
Just read the manga you fucking dweeb.
>>
>>101737691
So let me get this straight, either you've only seen Bake/Madoka or you have shit taste. Please watch more before you begin to post, newfriend.
>>
>>101737721
Gintama
>>
>>101737768
I did. The anime adaptation is glorious, fun and better than anything one could hope for so far. Cant wait for Weekend. JC Staff did a very good job.
>>
>>101737793
Nice try, noob.
>>
>>101737691
You're the spitting example of these people who haven't seen or heard anything from or about Shaft before Madoka/Bake.
So obvious from your comment.
>>
>>101737691
>Shaft was by far one of the worst studios until Bake/Madoka made it famous
Sounds like someone never watched SZS
>>
>>101737608

It's called shitposting anon. Shaft + Jump adaptation makes it an easy target for the witless fucks who are trying to fit in.
>>
god damnit I hate it when a series does this

just give him the key so he can put it in the damn locking to unlock his D
>>
>>101737793
Maximum irony and projecting. Anyone who watched all shaft shows, would know that the people that actually made interesting things, including Bake, left. And shinbo did not develop his own style since fucking Soul taker. Bakemonogatari is pretty much Moonphase rehash visually, and now Nisekoi is same overused shit for the 100ths time. Except in this case the direction sucks and visual style is unfitting, unoriginal and boring.
>>
>>101737883
If you want to talk about the show go to the real thread.
This here is shitposting and trolling till a mod stops being lazy.
>>
I don't get this anime. It's so incredibly cliche that you'd expect JC staff to handle it, but instead it gets the Shinbo 2deep4u treatment, but you'd expect some sort of fanservice to go about yet no Chitoge feet no Onodera armpit to be shown yet. What the fuck is going on
>>
>>101737868
Sounds like ignorant newfag that only watched SZS, Hidamari, Bake and Madoka and even so does not know anything about them,

SZS was shit cheap show at first cour, which shaft was unable to deliver at time, with shinbo resorting to cheap tricks to make it look somewhat decent. It barely had any animation, OP was weeks late, and while became somewhat a cult show - mostly because of source material.

JC Staff did a fucking better job adapting Kumeta with Joshiraku, so did PA Works with his designs in Eccentric Family
>>
>>101737691
Every single Shaft thread there is somebody who comes in with this same exact opinion, and gets up on their high horse and insult anybody who disagrees with them. And every time, they make sure they make sure they mention Bake/Madoka as many times as possible, and pint out that we are all "post-gatari newfags" and that nobody liked shaft before those shows and that they were "considered to be shit" before them. Then they try and say that the opinions of anybody of these "post-gatari fags" is automatically worthless and that they are all idiots who don't have any say about anything, and that there is no way they ever watched anything "pre-Bake/Madoka) even though they probably haven't either. Hell, you probably haven't even seen Bake/Madoka yourself. You stupid piece of shit.
>>
>>101737925
Shinbo already increased amout of fanservice compared to manga - the source is pretty tame.

The actual adaptation is bad, it feels nothing like it should be, disjointed, jarring, empty and barely fan at all. Just read manga.
>>
Because Shaft currently cannot into series without dialog excess.

>>101737691
>until Bake/Madoka made it famouse
SZS, MariaHolic, and ef were the harbingers of 'current' Shaft, aka "Shinobu directing". Madoka and the Monogatari bunch continued what was established.
>>
>>101738087
Post-gatari fag, please go back to /mal/, /v/, gaya or whatever you came from.

As for your "arguments" - ignorance is a crime.
>>
>>101738122
Wrong. It's better than the manga. Sorry you are too biased to realize it. But the anime is actually fun to watch, while the manga was not fun to read. Shaft took a bad manga, and made a mediocre anime, even if it is different from the manga it is an adaption after all.
>>
The anime is great. Only gayfags be hating.
Didnt read the manga
>>
File: 1357835709405.jpg (127.48 KB, 1440x810)
127.48 KB
127.48 KB JPG
There are people who really don't like SHAFT's style of animation?
>>
>>101738293
>Shaft
>animation
Choose one.
>>
>>101738293
Nah, only shitposters and redditfags.
>>
>>101738293
I don't like it when a studio makes cheap stuff that manages to sell 80K while my favorite studio can only sell around 10K.
>>
>Why is Nisekoi adaptation so shit?
Fits the source material.
>>
>>101738158
Once again, ignorant post.

Bakemonogatari is pretty much rehash of Moonphase, one of earliest Shaft shows in all aspects. Litterally nothing new in terms of art/direction there.

Maria Holic is horrible failure thats just shit taste to mention. SZS is what made shaft have somewhat of fanbase on /a/, along with Hidamari.

Shinbo "directing" is actually only actively seen in Vampire Bund which was very near to Soul Taker style. He oversights pretty much everything, but is barely involved and never directs any episodes. Even Bake is not actually "his". Nisekoi is first "his" show in a while, and it let itself be seen.

There were a lot of variety in shaft works - EF, REC, Natsu no Arashi, Soredomo, Hidamari, Arakawa - but most of people that contributed to that length left. Bakemonogatari was Moonphase 2.0 which became popular because of popular novel, Madoka successful hit designed by Inu Curry and Aniplex.

Every fucking time when shaft does anything half decent, hords of new fans appear just to be disappointed by following works. Just look what masterpieces Shaft did post Monogatari until Madoka..
>>
>>101738371
Please tell me which show you are referring to.
>>
File: 1358039432961.gif (522.37 KB, 480x270)
522.37 KB
522.37 KB GIF
>>101738328
That joke was fun in 2009.
>>
>>101738293
Must be good being this new. Young, naive and easily influencable.
>>
>>101738427
>in b4 shitty anime.
>>
>>101737691
Are you the faggot that's trying to force SHAFT vs JC Staff and comparing Golden Time to Nisekoi?
>>
>>101738466
Can you explain yourself?
>>
>>101738506
Sakura Trick and Norin are better shaft shows this season than actually Shinbo show.
>>
>>101738436
And every year since then.
>>
>>101738494
Golden Time adaptation is shit because of this scene.
>>
>>101737691
>Any decent studio
>such stuff - JC Staff
>>
So, did the new Mekaku City Actors CM air?
>>
Wow, this thread.
Elitists vs elitists.

And both don't even try to explain or justify their argument.
Just throw your usual memes and newfag at each other instead of having a reasonable argument.

Never change /a/.
>>
File: 1377194775314.png (47.69 KB, 233x266)
47.69 KB
47.69 KB PNG
Studio X is better than Studio Y threads are equivalent to console wars.

Don't respond to people trying to push that shit.
>>
>>101738579
What the hell are you even talking about
>>
>>101738593
JC Staff this season makes great adaptation of WCW, which is among the most fun and popular shows this season - as opposed by the poor work SHAFT did on Nisekoi.

Hell, even cheap Golden Time is still times better, and no, its not because how Shaft fags claim "shit source". Nisekoi had all potential to be big mainstream hit, as its popular Jump manga - and Shaft ruined all its chances for it.
>>
>>101738427
Bakeshit sold 80K being a poerwpiont slideshow.
>>
>>101738644
Thank you for exposing yourself as ignorant newfag.
>>
>>101738579
Nourin is pretty funny but it isn't anything special and neither is Nisekoi I guess. But Sakura Trick is fucking terrible and only panders to /u/faggots, has no substance and you should feel ashamed watching that garbage you lesbian-loving retard
>>
The manga sucks, that's why the adaption sucks. I've read all of the manga currently out for some reason and I've never actually enjoyed it...well other than the filler chapters. I'm just bored and a masochist I guess.
>>
If it wasn't for Monogatari, Shaft would be dead like Gainax, Better make a fucking statue of Nision in Shaft's headquarters
>>
File: 1359670064334.jpg (49.97 KB, 311x300)
49.97 KB
49.97 KB JPG
>>101738705
>>
>>101738579
>Norin
>better anything than anything
Shows how bad Nisekoi is.
>>
File: 1390831530091.png (419.41 KB, 667x670)
419.41 KB
419.41 KB PNG
>>101737285
Nisekoi is complete shit anyway.

Shit adaptation for a shit manga.
>>
>>101738722
also, you know, maybe this franchise that sort of sold well called, Madoka
>>
>>101738623
The complaint is very clear. Shaft ruined Nisekoi adaptation by bad direction and horrible misfitting the source material art style. Any other studio could have adapted it better. The only people protecting Nisekoi anime are delusional Shaft-newfags watching it for "shaft style" and even they understand its shit, but blame it on shitty manga.

What other arguments you need?
>>
SHAFT did not even get into the business of making its own shows seriously before the early/mid 2000s.
>>
File: QUALITY Time.jpg (152.06 KB, 1280x720)
152.06 KB
152.06 KB JPG
>>101738663
>even cheap Golden Time is still times better

Yea... no. Golden Time looks like total shit, and WCW is a miracle that it didn't get a typical shitty JC Staff adaptation.
>>
>>101738805
But Nisekoi isn't badly adapted or boring. I wouldn't even care if it was adapted by KyoAni if need be. I like the jokes in it.
>>
File: image.jpg (137.38 KB, 1154x720)
137.38 KB
137.38 KB JPG
>>101738805
>Shaft ruined Nisekoi
>Implying there was anything to ruin
>Implying any other studio would have done better
>>
Nisekoi anime is bad because Shaft isn't matching the source's style. It's a lighthearted romcom with plenty of slapstick and frank characters, not a wispy philosophical affair. All these tight facial shots, wide-angle shots, and other symbolically loaded angles just don't fit. It's like Fincher directing Up.
>>
>>101738835
where is the quality? I see people dancing.
>>
>>101738805
Yep, I'm pretty much only watching this show despite how terribly generic it is because of SHAFT-directing. I mean this is just a pseudo-harem/love-triangle rom-com with very generic characters so I wouldn't normally watch this but man, dat SHAFT.

Considering the manga, I wouldn't even watch this show if any other studio undertook it either
>>
>>101738805
I have read the source and have seen the first 5 episodes.
The adaption is accurate, and the art is okay.

Your whole argument is the same as theirs, they like Shaft, and you don't.

And there goes the word newfag again.
And the source isn't good.

Thanks for proving what I just wrote.
>>
>>101738922
I see robots dancing.
>>
>>101738916
Maybe its just me, but I see it as mocking the source material, which I find really funny.
>>
>>101738712
Thar she blows, cap'n!
>>
>>101738922
The kids are copy pasted.
>>
File: 1391134265955.jpg (6.03 KB, 84x163)
6.03 KB
6.03 KB JPG
>>101738922
>>
>>101738916
I was just going to post this.
The style is really ill fitting and frankly annoying for Nisekoi.

I don't need to see a clever, stylish, overly animated scene of Ichijo buying and drinking green tea from a vending machine.
>>
>>101738712
Regardless of what you think about the substance of the shows in questions (and in both cases you have shit taste and are an idiot, but thats beside the point), what was refered to is visual style and direction approach - which is "SHAFTsque" since... its made by people that created "shaft style": in shaft in first place and then moved on.

Sakura Trick is pretty much Hidamari, while Nourin is by Shin Oonume - aka EF, Hidamari, Natsu no Arashi, Pani Pani Dash etc. Though he developed his style even further after he left, so No-Rin is more like BakaTest now. Neverless, its genuine, "shaft".

Another example of "shaft" show recently would be Da Capo III (the man now does Sakura Trick)
>>
>>101738922
Those dancing students in the back? You know what they are?

CG. It looked like complete shit too in that it doesn't blend at all in motion.

It shouldn't be called quality but it still looks like trash.

The people on the sides are probably CG too, can't remember.
>>
>>101738966
Not a great way to get other manga artists eager to have Shaft adapt.
>>
Golden Time is best time.
>>
>>101739052
Who cares? They're rolling in bakebux
>>
>>101738426
the Second Season is actually better directoring-wise than a lot of their past good works. Shinbo was not particularly involved in that, iirc it was some new guy that pulled most of it through. So? Is it the same situation as Gainax, or is Shinbo actually managing to produce good directors?
>>
>>101738835
Golden Time is full of quality, since obviously less resources pumped than WCW - but its a very good show neverless. Toradora level in terms of direction, story and characters. Wish the animation would be at that level as well.. Its very good adaptation. The initial complaint was people were expecting manga designs and got new ones instead - but its length faded and most love them.
>>
>>101739057
That was on purpose.
>>
>>101739078
Something something golden egg.
>>
File: SHAFT does it again.png (122.89 KB, 172x271)
122.89 KB
122.89 KB PNG
>>101739057
That's neat.
>>
>>101739020
Sakura Trick is trying so hard to be Hidamri is is ridiculous - and it is failing miserably. If you honestly think the direction and art style of Skaura Trick is anything but a hollow, poorly done, caricature of what Hidamari is than I have nothing else to say to you. I dropped Nourin, because it was just another generic LN adaption I will forget about in a month, and it's art style, and direction didn't stand out to me. As for De Capo III, is there a single person who honestly thinks that series is even a little bit good? I hope not.
>>
Why are elitist SHAFT fans such intolerable cunts?
I like monogatari and madoka too, but I'm not going to scoff and say I'm just watching Nisekoi for 'dat SHAFT style'.
>>
>>101739151
>Toradora level in terms of direction, story and characters.

Holy shit, no.

This has nothing to do with the studio by the way, I just want to let you know you are completely fucking wrong.
>>
>>101739020
Wait, are you saying Hidamari's style = SHAFT's style? You're trolling right? Sakura Trick is not even a faithful copy of Hidamari.
>>
>>101739167
They've still got 2 more golden eggs in the basket and more probably in the works.

>>101739176
Those characters from Golden time are main characters, not background.
>>
>>101739201
Every studio fan is an elitist cunt.
It doesn't have to be Shaft.

You can clearly see that both parties in here are forcing a studio vs studio war.
>>
>>101738038
Sounds like somebody who has not seen Pani Poni Dash.

Also, who gave you the idea that Shaft's best point is not exactly their cost-saving techniques?
>>
>>101739020
Sakura Trick is even terrible for SoL/comedy standards, its only purpose is to pander the yuri fanbase (and it's being succesful I believe) and being fap fuel.
>>
File: 1390258104036.png (173.63 KB, 385x920)
173.63 KB
173.63 KB PNG
>>101739020
>Sakura Trick is pretty much Hidamari

You seriously can't be this retarded
>>
>>101738937
I like Shaft. I dont like SHAFT adapting Nisekoi. I could name plenty of other manga i would like SHAFT to adapt, but Nisekoi is not among them.

Shaft already failed hard with Negima, Natsu no Arashi adaptation - and now is a turn for Nisekoi.

Anyone protecting it cant be anything but shaft-newfag that is simply in denial protecting Shaft, not seeing it can fail (and does quite often so) and this is the case. Hell. Sakurasou and Oreshura source material is ten times worse than Nisekoi, and yet both anime were done better.
>>
File: 1362466754181.gif (375.40 KB, 174x138)
375.40 KB
375.40 KB GIF
>>101739232
>>
>>101738212
this
>>
>>101739312
I thought we were comparing Golden Time and Nisekoi. I'm not a shaft fanboy, I just wanted to explain how Golden Time looks like shit.
>>
>>101739057
WHY DO THEY HAVE HOOVES?
>>
>>101739232
And what happens when people get bored of Madoka, Hidamari, and Nisio? Or if they run out of source material? Their inflexibility isn't making them any new friends.
>>
>>101739202
Buthurt Linda fag, please go.
>>
>>101738426
Truly, the time and effort you have put into hating Shaft is incredible. I can not even imagine how bitter, and hollow of a human being you are. It really is quite admirable. In fact, from now on, whenever I am feeling down, I will remind myself, "At least I am not so bitter and angry that I dedicate myself to becoming an expert on something I deeply, deeply despise so I can tell people they are idiots for liking it on the internet". Thank you anon, thank you so mudh. Don't ever let anybody tell you to try and enjoy things or have fun, and certainly keep on telling people they are stupid for doing it themselves. Godspeed.
>>
>>101737285
It was utter shit to begin with. Now it's (barely) animated shit with a lot of straight lines in the background. Shafted shit, so to speak.
>>
>>101739288
>Sakurasou
>anime were done better
Thanks for the laugh
>>
>>101739402
They adapt Kagepro and set a new record for sales once again.
>>
>>101739402
I meant Kizu and Hana, but I suppose they do have Madoka and Hidimari too.

>Otaku
>Get bored of X
>>
File: m-muh dick.jpg (447.41 KB, 1056x1500)
447.41 KB
447.41 KB JPG
>>101739355
Golden Time is shit. I think that JC Staff fucked it to hell. They fucked up so many chances to have some great scenes. I don't know who would have done it better.

I'm actually a SHAFT fanboy.
>>
>>101739288
You fail again to give an example or anything to provide your argument.
Not even a single time have you said why the adaption is bad.

It is accurate and the art is also good, like I already mentioned.

The only thing you do is say "it could have been better," and that goes for every fucking adaption in history.
And then you come out with your newfag-shit yet again.
>>
I can think of much worse studios to adapt your manga.
>>
>>101738038
>so did PA Works with his designs in Eccentric Family

HOLY FUCK, is it possible for someone to have such shit taste?

PA butchered Kumeta's fuckng designs byond redemption. It ruined the show for me and brought my respect of PA down to shit-tier.
>>
>>101739463
I can think of much better studios. Your point?
>>
>>101739432
It's shit, though.
Slightly better shit than Nisekoi, but popular shit is still shit. And the fanbase is toxic, RIP /a/.
>>
>>101739202
Its toradora author that wrote Golden Time, you retard. In fact, i consider GT a better novel.

You just hate shit taste and root for worst girl. Pity you.
>>
>>101739288
It couldn't have been better.

The manga is shit, either you need to make an unfaithful adaptation, or you need to spice it up with directoring and art, just like Shaft are doing.

You'd be angry if they made it unfaithful, too, so I guess Shaft is the best possible choice for this shit series.

I am kind of sad they are actually adapting it, instead of making something better, but oh well.

You are the same guy who was speaking how adapting a Shonen Jump manga could be Shaft's Big Break?
>>
>>101739524
>i consider GT a better novel.

Well you're wrong. Luckily the nips know better.
>>
>>101739508
Name them.
>>
I love that piano, flute music. I need the full song
>>
>>101739002
Obviously you need to see a shit adaptation of a shit manga.

We are getting a funny but mediocre adaptation of a shit manga.

I am not complaining.
>>
Does anyone have a good version of this episodes end card?
>>
>>101739659
Download the episode, numbnuts.
>>
File: shot0001.png (1.16 MB, 1280x720)
1.16 MB
1.16 MB PNG
>>101739659
You could have just downloaded the episode.
>>
The adaptation is fine and this is just fanboi OP going nuts, crying and whining to /a/.
>>
>>101739774
I stream all my anime :^)
Thanks for this though.
>>
I'm totally enjoying nisekoi. You guys don't know how to have fun anymore.
>>
>>101739632
What is pupa
>>
File: 1360417407985.jpg (1.70 MB, 960x3780)
1.70 MB
1.70 MB JPG
>>101739193
Hidamari S1 was pretty poor, very unfinished, very poorly looking. There was like 1-2 decently looking episode. People name Bakemonogatari PPT presentation - Hidamari was worse. You have no idea what you talk about. It somewhat improved later as it slowly became more popular and Shaft approached it more responsively.

Sakura Trick does not "emulate" Hidamari, more than Titanic emulates Cameron movie.

Nourin - once again, substce and plot of the show is irrelevant to this discutsion. We discussion style and direction.

As for DC III - it was very good in fact, shame very little people on /a/ watched it as opposed to japan.
>>
>>101739604
AIC, A1, JC Staff, Bones, Sunrise 6/7/8, PA, etc.
>>
>>101739201
>elitist
You mean, "newfag post madoka fans"?

"Elitist' fans watched everything by Shaft and Shinbo, know people involved and know that Shaft is certainly not an golden egg studio and produced a lot of crap, let alone recognize when said "style" is nothing original but reusal of things used thousand times before in other shows.
>>
>>101739257
Pani Poni Dash creator is making No-rin this season.

Seems someone who has no idea what he speaks of. "Shaft" novadays is associated with Shinbo. Tbh best things to see his "actual" style, is to see his works not restricted by low budget/time schedule - aka not done by Shaft: Soul Taker and Nanoha
>>
That is...

A very deep pool.
>>
I like Nisekoi BECAUSE it is generic, cliche, predictable, and dumb. It has its place in my manga reading life, which is just a fun thing to read for a couple minutes every week. I don't take offense to anyone calling it a shit manga.

It's fast food of harems.

Honestly when an adaptation was announced I wasn't hyped or anything. Episodes come out, I watch them, have a good time, move on.

Not the kind of show/manga anyone should ever
discuss on 4chan because the only things to talk are waifu wars and studio wars.
>>
>>101739859
>Sakura Trick does not "emulate" Hidamari, more than Titanic emulates Cameron movie.
Are you fucking serious right now? Did you actually just type that with a straight face? Holy fucking shit I actually can't even believe it. I'm actually mas right now. I don't even feel like pointing out how fucking ludicrous that statement was because I am so fucking mad. Fuck you. I'm fucking leaving.
>>
>>101740026
Thanks for admitting Nourin is not even comparable to SHAFT's style.
>>
>>101739402
Nisekoi shows exactly what happens in that case. Its litterally Monogatari in terms of art and direction, nothing new, nothing different.

Except instead of cult LN by Nishio Ishi, its generic Jump Manga. And experiment shows, that obviously - Shaft "style" is not waht made the shows good.

Also, past 1st season of Gatari, Shaft got some money and went full out on Vampire Bund and Denpa Onna - we know how it ended...
>>
The fault lies with the manga.
Its shit
>>
>>101740072
2deep4u?
>>
File: 1385316918842.jpg (51.99 KB, 1280x720)
51.99 KB
51.99 KB JPG
>>101739859
>Sakura Trick does not "emulate" Hidamari, more than Titanic emulates Cameron movie.

Oh yeah, Sakura Trick's art style is totally unique and original, the director is not trying to do what he did in Hoshimittsu.
>>
>>101740167
>Also, past 1st season of Gatari, Shaft got some money and went full out on Vampire Bund and Denpa Onna - we know how it ended...
Denpa Onna was pretty good.
Vampire Bund was garbage for reasons that were not necessarily tied to the direction but rather to the fuck-awful script and storyline.
>>
>>101739428
Your argument? It was very well animated, and good directed. The problem was absolute shit source LN, that made everyone ragedrop it. In terms of production it outdoes Nisekoi easily.

I could also bring Hentai-Prince as example, but in that case LN/Manga were decent, so its unfair comparison, thats why i used Sakurasou.
>>
>>101739859
>Hidamari S1 was pretty poor, very unfinished, very poorly looking.
Yet we loved it.

This is what people like about Shaft: the very unfinished very poorly looking animation is actually pretty nice.

>>101740026
And? What is your point? Pani Poni Dash was before all these, and is better than all these.

Shinbo's "actual" style is really good too. What is done under his supervision in Shaft is not his "actual" style, but you can't possibly deny he has a leading role in creating the "Shaft-esque" as a style. We would never be calling all these different directors "Shaft-esque", if it was not for Shinbo.
>>
>>101740167
>Shaft "style" is not waht made the shows good.
Obviously.

Shaft "style" is simply what makes the shows BETTER THAN THEIR SOURCE MATERIAL.
>>
>>101740262
I still don't get why they butchered HenNeko so much. Animation-wise that's the JC Staff production I've liked the most ever since Excel Saga, but so much shit was cut out of the story that what was left was terrible.

But no, if I am still watching Nisekoi, but quit Sakurasou 3-4 episodes in, I'd say Shaft are still doing better than JC Staff. I don't really consider Sakurasou's LN's level of shit different than Nisekoi's manga's level of shit.
>>
>>101739449
It could have been better. What exactly do you expect to me, frame by frame analyzis of the episode and edited version of script highlighting you every issue?

I gave you the proper argument of "how it could have been better" - Witch Craft Works, airing the same season.

Thats how it SHOULD have looked like:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_lTA57N3kI&hd=1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vtY_R7GSG8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcD-IYVkchA&hd=1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-R_gIRpVyXU&hd=1

Thats how it looks:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6C1DIwZgsDo&hd=1

Hell, this as stated - this season Sakura Trick and norin look better than what Shinbo did.

Utilizing litterally same style he is already inferior to people that left shaft. Nisekoi looks like poor Monogatari. Here is example of not stale rehash of old style, but actually taking it creatively.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZ-pG5BUGnQ&hd=1
>>
>>101739465
>HOLY FUCK, is it possible for someone to have such shit taste?
You just proven by your exaple that indeed, this is possible. There are people that did not watch Eccentric Family and those who believe it to be great. You are the only one in whole planet that happens to hate it.
>>
What a cute shitposter we got here.
>>
>>101740917
>It could have been better. What exactly do you expect to me, frame by frame analyzis of the episode and edited version of script highlighting you every issue?

Actually... yes, let's go with that. Put your money where your mouth is if you're going to put this much effort into shitposting.
>>
File: 1380738503836.gif (469.87 KB, 173x271)
469.87 KB
469.87 KB GIF
>>101740207
>>
>>101739852
You
a) either have low demand taste, thus enjoying whatever you download
b) did not read a manga, thus somewhat enjoying characters andjokes
c) shaft newfags in awe with "glorious shinbo direction and style" blind to fact its mismatching and just reusal of everything we seen hundred times before to a point it looks cheap and lazy
>>
>>101741175
>either have low demand taste, thus enjoying whatever you download
>implying than that is a bad thing
>>
>>101741175
or maybe
d) they just like it and think it's fun?
>>
>>101741175
I'm a mix of all 3.

I watch tons of shows every season, haven't read the manga because its a generic harem, and am only watching because the style is fun to look at.

I don't see why I would want Nisekoi to be adapted properly. I wouldn't even watch it if it looked like Yamada and the 7 Witches.
>>
>>101740387
Katanagatari > Bakemongatari, while Katanagatari LN < Bakemonogatari LN. I read Bake LNs after the 1st season, and no - Shaft adaptation is ok, but it is not "better" than LNs. In fact, its not even a good adaptation because it misses so many nuances (even if you pause everything and read all stop frames, you still get a small portion of what made LN good, it just hints on stuff in it -not includes it). Its ok anime though. Just dont claim it is better than original. Original story is the only thing that makes it good.
>>
>>101740992
His original designs don't look like monkeys.
>>
>>101737285
We're missing you in the livestreams!
>>
Anime is doing badly. Its another typical SHAFT flop that devote newfags defent for a reason its "shaft"
>>
>>101741570
Katanagatari < Bakemonogatari, while Katanagatari LNs > Bakemonogatari LNs

This is my personal view on this. I don't know how you reached the conclusions you did, but... you know what? I neither want to know.
>>
>>101742000
You know, your spelling mistakes really are consistent throughout the thread.
>>
>>101741570
>the only thing

Really? I mean I like the original novel a lot, but at the very least you'd have to appreciate Inu Curry.

I'm with this guy
>>101742319
>>
>>101741175
Manga went to shit like, 80 chapters ago(yes, I read it because I'm a masochist). Anime is actually pretty fun and refreshing, I didn't expect Shaft to work with such a title but it's actually enjoyable.
>>
>>101741175
Not that anon, but I have read the manga (and dropped it), and I am somewhat enjoying the direction and how everything is better than the manga. I also have 50+ watched series made by Shaft. I'd guess you don't have 50 anime series altogether?

Oh, but I haven't seen Moon Phase yet. Funny how this works.
>>
>source material is trash
>"lel why is the show trash too, fucking shinbo ;^)"
>>
>>101742644
The people who are complaining are the cocksuckers that think the source material is actually good.
>>
>>101742776
>The people who are complaining are the cocksuckers that think the source material is actually good.
Nah, it's just shit posters. They're just using it as an excuse to shit post.
>>
File: 1292584430053.jpg (92.97 KB, 331x424)
92.97 KB
92.97 KB JPG
>>101742615
>I also have 50+ watched series made by Shaft.
>>
>>101742615
>I also have 50+ watched series made by Shaft
They haven't even made half that.
>>
>>101742776
People calling source material shit is a lone samefag trying to promote idea that manga is bad while he did not even read it.

ITT: You
>>
File: img_dvd.png (703.03 KB, 980x1335)
703.03 KB
703.03 KB PNG
>poorly shitposting

Are you even trying?
>>
>>101742876
>>101742955
Counted by MAL. Who am I to argue that there are near 10 Hidamari anime series?
>>
>>101743840
Please go back to MAL and stay there.
>>
>>101743840

>use MAL

Fucking cancer.
>>
File: 1336931765858.jpg (25.05 KB, 201x310)
25.05 KB
25.05 KB JPG
>>101742615
>I also have 50+ watched series made by Shaft
I didn't know there were future visitors in /a/.

>>101743840
Pro tip: you count series, not titles.
>>
>>101743984
Protip: I am too lazy to actually count series. However, there are scripts that count titles for me. However, I am too lazy to rewrite them to count series.
>>
Shaft is pretty good though guys.
>>
>>101744230
>google SHAFT
>open wikipedia disambiguation
>search for right entry
>read works
So fucking difficult, which is literally what I did.
>>
What's the appeal of harems?
>>
>>101744367
The girls
>>
>>101744367
Self insert.
>>
>>101744460
Why is there a male MC then? Why not all girls.
>>
>>101744460

But it's not as if you can actually fuck them.
>>
>>101744510
Because faggots need someone to self insert
>>
File: 135770514046.jpg (27.70 KB, 250x250)
27.70 KB
27.70 KB JPG
>>101744529
>>
>>101744539
How do you even self-insert as 16 year old japanese bishounens?
>>
>>101744510
Because some of like cocks also.
>>
>>101744632

Like this.
>>
>>101744632
I don't know.
>>
>>101744632
You self insert as the girls and fight for MCs cock. You new to harems?
>>
File: 1337009952522.jpg (391.84 KB, 800x800)
391.84 KB
391.84 KB JPG
>>101744632
>16 year old japanese bishounens?
>harem
You're thinking of shoujo, or otomeshit. Unless I haven't watched enough harem in which there is an actual bishounen as MC, to which I must apologize.
>>
Sukumizu or Bikini, /a/?

Protip: if you choose bikini, you're probably the kind of guy who takes it up the ass.

>>101744803
I'd call Ichijou a bishounen.
>>
>>101744803
Eh? Nandatte? was pretty bishie, truth be told. I'd suck his cock.
>>
>>101744799
>>101744877
So haremfans are just closet homos?
>>
>>101744350
It requires more effort than reading a simple number. I've seen every possible series ever since PPD, tho. If you want, you can count yourself how many are these.

>>101744945
No, just closet homos are known to like a certain category of harem shows, more often known simply as "good harems".



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.