[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: Asuka_tuff.gif (51.27 KB, 400x282)
51.27 KB
51.27 KB GIF
so /a/..
Which do you like better?
NGE + EOE or REBUILD?

[/spoiler:lit]:^)
>>
I like Evangelion.
>>
I liked it when it wasn't all shit. so like until 1996
>>
File: Why.jpg (1.14 MB, 3844x2992)
1.14 MB
1.14 MB JPG
>>101624512

Is this even up for debate?
>>
NGE+EOE is the only true answer
>>
I like Rebuild over EoE, but the original series is really the foundation, flawed as it is at parts.
>>
the movies lack the comedy aspect.
>>
File: 1387219777999.gif (1.45 MB, 233x291)
1.45 MB
1.45 MB GIF
>>101624757
>I like Rebuild over EoE

Why? What part of Rebuild is in any way better then EoE
>>
>>101624512

Original, although there were a few scenes in Rebuild that i enjoyed.
>>
>>101624810
the presentation, and the animation quality?
>>
>>101624887
>the presentation, and the animation quality?

So you are blind then? Because nothing in Rebuild can compare to the animation found in EoE
>>
>>101624810
I like the ost.
>>
>>101624983

None of it can compare to "Komm, susser Tod"
>>
File: 1386762069441.gif (1018.79 KB, 400x225)
1018.79 KB
1018.79 KB GIF
>>101624927
>>
>>101625084

>CGI geometric shape
>comparable to the MP-Eva fight

Humor me, how old are you?
>>
>>101625134

22
>>
>>101625084
>cgi (albeit it was fucking great looking and it fits) and remade animation of nge
>>
File: 9a4.jpg (14.38 KB, 294x273)
14.38 KB
14.38 KB JPG
>>101625134
>any giant monsters fight
>comparable to the MP-Evas fight
That's not fair, anon
>>
NGE + 3.33
>>
>>101625318
>the top and the bottom
top leliel
>>
>>101625019
Opinions. I prefer the instrumental songs with chorus
>>
File: 1326634457702.jpg (121.52 KB, 750x900)
121.52 KB
121.52 KB JPG
>>101624665
>>
File: 1326579821165.gif (454.54 KB, 310x178)
454.54 KB
454.54 KB GIF
>>101625370
>tfw "The Final Decision We All Must Take"
>>
File: 1383759928632.gif (834.73 KB, 280x189)
834.73 KB
834.73 KB GIF
>>101625385
>Mari is the reincarnation of the MP-Eva

So that's why the 02 berserk looked the way it did and why she smells people
>>
>>101625019
If you count the song/scene fitting maybe.
But as for music in itself, nothing can top the Rebuild.
Based Sagisu is literally the only reason why I'm still watching the movies
>>
File: 1318706360733.png (9.76 KB, 544x233)
9.76 KB
9.76 KB PNG
>>101624512
>[/spoiler:lit]:^)
>>
>>101624512
Rebuild brought people like you here.
So NGE.
>>
>>101625451
This guy gets it.
>>
dat character trauma

I'm still not sure how I feel about EOE, but I don't really have any problem with it.

I consider the first two rebuilds just pretty tributes.
>>
>>101625283
Well that's why you don't try to put NGE on the same low level as Rebuild.

>>101625318
Bait
>>
File: Asuka is not amused.jpg (97.43 KB, 599x780)
97.43 KB
97.43 KB JPG
>>101625461
Shit, I haven't realized that either despite posting that image right now.
>>
>>101625451
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sf28xBOwuIM
>>
File: here.gif (1011.41 KB, 500x275)
1011.41 KB
1011.41 KB GIF
>>101625084
>pic related
This is how you animation
>>
File: Eva1-Mari.jpg (67.04 KB, 847x465)
67.04 KB
67.04 KB JPG
>>101625461
Mass Produced Maris
>>
>>101625557
Give it a rest. Rebuild fights still look pretty. Comparing anything to EoE fight is just going to make it look miserable
>>
>>101625629

Debris is entry-level and a waste of animation. Weighty movement and perspective shifts are great.
>>
>>101625629

If you are going to do a comparison at least post the same fight to compare.
>>
File: 1313085717091.gif (1.71 MB, 587x417)
1.71 MB
1.71 MB GIF
>>101625668
>>
File: wat.jpg (140.77 KB, 1920x1080)
140.77 KB
140.77 KB JPG
>>101625688

Ok
>>
>>101625668
>Weighty movement and perspective shifts are great
That's the point. I'll agree that the debris is just occluding the view on better animation, but it sometimes may help in rendering the weigth and force, if done correctly.
For example when they clash blades and the recoil make them stomp hills and bullshit
>>
When did people start gracing OP with replies despite his obvious need for more lurking before posting?
>>
File: 1338541787601.gif (886.81 KB, 238x124)
886.81 KB
886.81 KB GIF
>>101625629
longer
>>
File: mariasu.jpg (105.30 KB, 1063x752)
105.30 KB
105.30 KB JPG
>>101625461
>She arrives in the series by falling from the sky.

Well all those chibi Mari biting chibi Asuka are not cute anymore.
>>
File: 14236423.jpg (20.79 KB, 224x190)
20.79 KB
20.79 KB JPG
>>101625735
You caught me off guard m8
>>
>>101625735
What i meant by that was comparing it to the Ramiel fight in the original series.
>>
>>101625570
I would be impressively okay with Asuka getting gang raped by a bunch of Maris in 4.0
>>
>>101625668
>Debris is entry-level and a waste of animation.
Is that how you explain awful debris animation in 2.22 during beast Eva-02 fight?
>>
>>101625822

would like

I really like how Anno went into 2.0 wanting to throw away the old depressing eva and mix it up with Mari, who was made to break the mold, but ended up jumping back into the deep end with 3.0.
>>
File: 1374712178253.png (953.78 KB, 1280x544)
953.78 KB
953.78 KB PNG
>>101625666
>Rebuild fights still look pretty
If you like shitty CG, lasers and terrible eva designs.
>>
>>101625744
>no one notices the longer gif showing superior EoE animation

Or are you just so buttrustled, Rebuildfags?
>>
>>101625629
I think this is the stuff of legends during animation classes. I bet beginners are forced to study these frames billions of times until they're carved in their minds
>>
>>101625742
>implying the eva fanbase is not newfags
>>
>>101625896

They could have all the terrible debris animation they want and I wouldn't really care. I'd rather they CG it and divert resources towards more character animation. Writing some shaders to make it more traditional-looking wouldn't be too hard.
>>
>>101625939
No, if you simply turn your brain off and go for a Michael Bay movie that isn't Michael Bay's. I know I've enjoyed the Wunder sequence. Eva-13 vs 02 was cancer though
>>
>>101625946

The first gif proved the point, the second wasn't really needed.
>>
>>101625735
EVA is dead
God it's so fucking dead, RIP
>>
>>101625735
>You posted a pic
>He asked for animation
>>
>>101626073
Because it looks better in stills. The animation in that preview is fucking terrible.
>>
>>101626073

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_olQbTKWfI

Better?
>>
>>101625742
>implying anyone in here gives two shits about OP
>implying this isn't just an excuse for us to start another Eva thread
>implying it hasn't been like this for years
According to my findings you should be the new here
>>
Okay.
Guys.
Matryoshka universes inside of the tang worldminds.
>>
>>101626117

You do know they were asking you to compare the original Ramiel fight to the rebuild one, right?
>>
>>101624512

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58xDrWvNDSw

The best soundtrack piece ever was in REBUILD, so I'll go with that.

Also, there's a little bit less existential crisis involved (I absolutely LOATHED the part where asuka becomes fucking catatonic. For someone with her fighting spirit, it was incredibly lame.
>>
>>101626223

Yeah, I know.

You know the original argument was that EoE has better animation then Rebuild? That aside I find it hilarious to compare the two MP-Eva scenes because the Rebuild one looks like dogshit
>>
>>101624665
>4th picture on the right, dat Asuka stance
I should like catalog every time she does this in NGE or something
>>
>>101625461
Goddammit EVA, how do you manage to make me feel like an idiot so many times
>>
>>101626273

Her "fighting spirit" was so rooted in her self-image, which crumbled completely when she was forced to realise that she can't do everything on her own.

She knows that she needs help this time around, but she's pretty mad about it.
>>
>>101626353
...er, 4th picture on the left. Herp derp I can't tell left from right better commit sudoku.
>>
>>101626490
It's natural for girls to confuse directions sometimes. You are a little girl, right, anon?
>>
File: 1-90524616.png (168.49 KB, 609x437)
168.49 KB
168.49 KB PNG
>>101626490
I heard you've been stirring up shit yesterday posting Kawoshin in another thread, Tang
>>
>>101626273
rebuild's soundtrack is the only thing thus far that trumps the nge+eoe for me
>>
File: yummy.jpg (40.41 KB, 639x358)
40.41 KB
40.41 KB JPG
>>101625461
It's not like I'm requesting anything from the drawfags or anything.
>>
>>101624512
NGE - EOE
>>
NGE+EoE of course

Rebuild is still fun to watch. I a trainwreck kind of way.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7g-wnGDksk

>This is what has taken priority at Studio Khara over FINAL.
>>
>>101626987
>implying it is not a sequel
>>
>>101626987
>implying they aren't one in the same
>>
>>101625939
CG composited onto regular animation never looks good unless you're really really careful about it.
Also, cat eva a shit.
>>
>>101626742
You're going to have to link me to the archive, because I don't recall that. Then again I don't recall many things.

>>101626987
Yeah, don't think I'll be watching this but holy crap was that the Gunbuster black hole bomb at 40 secs?
>>
>>101625735
>>101625772
>>101626066
>>101626109
>>101626117
>>101626286
Just so you you're comparing an unfinished piece of animation from the PV to the next film which may or may not be in the next movie judging by the other PVs to the film series. Not really much of a point.
>>
>>101624665
So the Rebuild is less pretentious schlock? Sounds good.
>>
>>101626987
The main reason Rebuild exists is to provide extra funding for Studio Khara.

That is to say, they care more about working on new and original products and Eva is just their cash cow to fund such projects.

Too bad the CGI still looks kinda shitty in that.
>>
File: 1391538768154.jpg (59.82 KB, 536x528)
59.82 KB
59.82 KB JPG
>>101624512
EoE + 2.0
>>
>>101627490
At least it looks consistent which is more than can be said for Rebuild.
>>
>>101626987
>Khara money
>barely any better than how Arpeggio looked

So is this the full extent of full CGI shows/movies trying to copy the 2D style? Will it get better or do you think this is all it will ever be?
>>
>>101627548
Like I said, Rebuild is just their cash cow; their Hollywood blockbuster to churn in the yen for projects they actually care about.

>At least it looks consistent which is more than can be said for Rebuild.

Shame, it looks like a Madoka ripoff.

And I thought they were taking top priority over some Ghibli project, not this.
>>
>>101627590
It will get better, because the west has already done it better.

Nips behind in their tech once again and can't into 3D-CGI as always.
>>
>>101627834
If I wanted good CG I'd watch Pixar or something, not anime.
>>
I love NGE

I have mixed feelings about EoE

manga has some kickass art in the latest chapters

Haven't even watched the Rebuilds, I don't want them to soil the source material for me the same way the Star Wars prequels did
>>
>>101627971
Nobody cares you retard
>>
File: 1387398146470.gif (1009.69 KB, 233x226)
1009.69 KB
1009.69 KB GIF
>>101627971
I don't think you have to worry about it ruining the source material since Rebuild isn't a sequel and therefore doesn't have to follow NGE mechanics.
>>
>>101627971
I never understood the whole Star Wars things, Rebuild is more like Star Trek movies in relation to the series.
>>
>>101628256
Have you seen the prequels? They're pretty terrible.
>>
>>101627971
Rebuild is more like an alternate universe sort of thing than a direct sequel despite all of the hints but for all we know that's just Anno trolling his fans again. I guess the best answer you could give is saying it could be the Violence Jack to Devilman.
>>
>>101628345
And unrelated to Rebuild. Go be butthurt somewhere else Reifag
>>
>>101626987
Didn't you watch 3.0?
It's dead anon.
>>
>>101630414
Dead from a quality standpoint. Only one movie left, might as well finish it.
>>
>>101626851
>Order revoltech 118, MP eva with wings
>Get revo 026, without wings
>>
File: 1368684558913.gif (2.87 MB, 352x198)
2.87 MB
2.87 MB GIF
>>101626117
Oh shit that looks like something from fucking Power Rangers.

>>101626273
>For someone with her fighting spirit, it was incredibly lame.
That's the point anon; the Eva is all she has, and when it doesn't respond to her, she has nothing left. By cutting off the thing that keeps her alive, you essentially kill her.
Goddammit.



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.