It wasn't a good ending,
It wasn't a bad ending.
It was a shit ending.
It's called a true otaku ending. Nobody dies
what do you expect honestly, the series is at least 50% ecchi comedy.
why would it go total grimdark in the end, that wouldnt make sense.
Tomoki is the God of the status quo.
Wait, didn't everybody died?
Is Ikaros really the strongest Angeloid? I thought Chaos was already more powerful by then and Astraea evolved later.
It was retconed by the power of plot device.
man that sucks
Reset endings are always shitty.
Suu blew it big time.
I'm having flashbacks to the My-HiMe ending. And that's never a good thing.
>All the girls except Sohara and Daedalus gets shafted
>True girl turns out to be Sohara, the worst girl
Why don't mangaka have the guts to kill their characters?
Pretty everyone knew a reset ending was coming considering the final arc was about using the reset machine. Though I expected shit to get fucked up into his next series.
Of the people who hated the ending, how many of you are Nymphfags?
You know all the girls won, right?
Some people seem to be unhappy about that. Some people are bitching because everybody lived. I want to know how many of them are Nymphfags.
Not sure why that matters at all.
The hate comes from the fact it was a reset ending. When spoilers came out, most people didn't like what they saw and read. Reset ends are normally terrible writing and makes a lot of things pointless. Not having the courage to kill off characters after building up the drama and emotions is really lame.
There are better ways to write a better climax and deliver a happy ending, one that doesn't resort to reset.
You're not showing any courage by dodging the question.
The only people who say this probably haven't read Messiah.
Woah, it ended?
How am I dodging?
I think some people were hoping Suu would do things....differently.
>Everyone dies except Ikaros
>Happy ending with Ikaros
This would be the best and most emotional ending possible. Search your feelings, you know this to be true.
Since you're being this evasive then one can safely assume that you are.
And create another Lilu by the permanent death of BWAKA?
TL note: Lilu means dead best girl
Alpha, Beta, and Delta are my favorite girls.
You haven't answered question. I think you are dodging instead, buddy.
Chaos was Lilu
>Literally the first time I'm begging for a deus ex machina reset ending
>Actually get it
I got a happy ending when everything pointed otherwise, that's all that matters to me. Thank you Suu.
You didn't ask a question.
>How am I dodging?
That is a question.
Good job, you used up your one free wish in life, how do you feel?
Personally, I didn't mind it. Well, my girls are happy and they "won", so I'm not too bothered about the reset ending. The ending leaves a bad taste but also a good taste.
Much better and happier than the jaded "baaaaaaaaw why didn't you give me a everyone dies ending when the day before i was begging for a happy ending and crying because everyone was dead suu baaaaaaaaaaaaaw" faggots in this thread.
Are you fucking serious?
Why, Japan? Why?
You didn't answer the premise and only gave an opinion on why you wanted everyone to stay dead.
Are you trolling me?
>Some people seem to be unhappy about that. Some people are bitching because everybody lived
My "opinion" explained a good reason why people wouldn't be happy about the ending.
That wasn't even the topic though: "How many people who liked Nymph wanted everyone to stay dead?"
You're kidding, right?
That can't be the topic when the topic became how some people are unhappy about all the girls winning and how some people are bitching because everyone lived. That topic was open to arguments, and I argued why people weren't happy and are bitching.
Don't forget Rozen Maiden's ending.
>best doll dies
What's the count for shit endings over the last two years?
>Negima, Rosario x Vampire, Rozen Maiden, SnO
Anything else? Feeling inclined to add Beelzebub preemptively.
Beelzebub? Really? Man, sounds like I should catch up on Beelzebub.
The topic question was at the start of what you replied to here >>101486342 and it didn't change. If you can't answer a simple question then don't reply.
Holy shit, dude. The topic changed the moment you set a new premise. I figured you were trying to imply Nymphfags didn't like the ending, that's why I replied refuting that by saying all girls won, so that can't be it. But then you made a new topic that was open to arguments, and I then replied again to argue why.
Well, Kimi no Iru Machi is going to have a generic happy ending.
Rozen Maiden's ending wasn't that bad as long as you weren't a Shinku fan. If you were, it was the epitome of rage.
>For at least two/three years
>THE RIDE NEVER ENDS
>BAWWW MY FAVORITE CHARACTER
>NO WHY SUU WHY
>Fuck this shitty reset end
I sometimes really wonder about you guys, sometimes.
>mfw I gave up on Rozen Maiden ages ago
Could barely bring myself to follow the new adventures at all. Shit seems pointless, now.
>There are people who would be more happy if all except Tomoki and Sugata died
/a/ will be /a/.
>The topic changed the moment you set a new premise.
>But then you made a new topic
Neither of these things happened. In fact the topic was reasserted with
>I want to know how many of them are Nymphfags.
>Reset endings suck because reasons
>I liked Nymph, I hated the ending
>The ending sucks, Nymph is best gril
or even a proud patriotic
>I loved Nymph and I wanted everyone to stay dead!
are all honest replies. There's no reason to be shy.
>Neither of these things happened.
Dude. Look at your own posts. It isn't a compound question. All the girls won, Period. You stated that some people are unhappy about that and are bitching because everyone lived. I argued the hate is because resent ending. But you wanted to know many who hated it are Nymphfags, but asking that kind of question doesn't make sense hence my statement:
>Not sure why that matters at all.
Seriously, if you can't get this then you're hopeless. Or really are just trying to troll me.
The BDs will be during October / November right?
Epilogue chapter left, and worst girl is gone. i don't see the issue
I am butt mad, but the movie is soon
Is it going to follow the manga ending?
Many complaints about the writing/NTR. Even if you dislike Pink Moka, what her mom did was pretty messed up to her own daughter.
>Look at your own posts.
They all query for the same thing, the accounting of nymphfags who hated the ending. Replying with "All the girls won" is a non sequitur.
>Or really are just trying to troll me.
That is quite the victim complex there. All of my posts simply reaffirm the original question to this thread:
Out of the people who hated the ending where everyone lived happily, how many of you preferred Nymph?
Don't mind me, just posting the best Sora no Otoshimono.
Actually I don't have a clue
The advertisement picture for the movie shows Ikaros with her wings on fire.
Best girl won, it was a good ending.
How can the best girl won if all the girls won?
All girls are best girls?
Everyone except Nymph.
I was hoping for replies like these. You guys didn't disappoint me.
>all the girls won?
We won't know until the epilogue.
SnO is getting a epilogue?
Nymph has always been one of the best. Especially Nymph when abused.
The irony is rich. No need to go further in your game so we're done here.
Science is no game and science is never done. The questions are ceaseless. Are you a nymphfag who hated the ending? Who among the thread fit this description?