[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: koikaze.jpg (44.09 KB, 712x476)
44.09 KB
44.09 KB JPG
What are /a/'s thoughts on incest as a key plot element?

>Koi Kaze - Long drawn out drama with semi-realistic depiction
>Kissxsis - lewd fuel, non-related total fantasy depiction
>Yosuga no Sora - lewd fuel, most erotic scenes, semi-realistic depiction
>Oreimo - lol
>>
File: 1365155237377.gif (575.52 KB, 460x256)
575.52 KB
575.52 KB GIF
wow I should have really put the kirino image first so people would actually look at the thread
>>
Oniai was somewhat interesting because it was over the top.
Oreimo was poop.
>>
>>101405311
What about Salami-san?
>>
File: shopping.jpg (96.23 KB, 505x475)
96.23 KB
96.23 KB JPG
>>
>>101405311
I can't really think of a series other than Koi Kaze that really intended to be a serious treatment of the subject.

As you say, pretty much all of the others are either comedy or fap fodder, and most of them take the "they're really just step-siblings" cop-out.
>>
File: Usagi Drop - Vol 1.png (1.55 MB, 1920x1080)
1.55 MB
1.55 MB PNG
>>101406888
I remember hearing that in the manga of Usagi drop she eventually becomes the guys lover or something but the anime doesn't go that far

its been on my back list for a long time though.


It's sort of weird that the most you usually get are bro-cons considering all the mangas and doujins out there which take the step over the line repeatedly.

Then again I guess its kinda hard to pitch these sort of things for funding
>>
>>101407158
>I remember hearing that in the manga of Usagi drop she eventually becomes the guys lover or something but the anime doesn't go that far
But that would just be so wrong. Sometimes the anime version really is better.

>It's sort of weird that the most you usually get are bro-cons considering all the mangas and doujins out there which take the step over the line repeatedly.
>
>Then again I guess its kinda hard to pitch these sort of things for funding

Well, Shaft did give us the toothbrush scene.
>>
>>101407403
yeah, but you couldn't pitch a show about that toothbrush scene, it was just sorta written in

theres lots of stuff you can 'leave out' when applying for the funding of course

remember human centipede? investers were pretty surprised to find out it was about ass to mouth
>>
>>101407892
um, may I just interject to ask: which toothbrush scene?
>>
>>101408052
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1jY7BLQVMc
>>
>>101408052
Nisemonogatari. Tsukihi Poenix, Part One.
>>
File: kissxsis-4099553.jpg (83.29 KB, 745x785)
83.29 KB
83.29 KB JPG
its not entirely unrealistic, just unlikely
>>
>>101408156
>>101408218
Thank you, kind sirs. Been really meaning to catch up with that series; reckoned I'd start from the beginning again, seeing as it's been so long...

But, about incest more generally..yeah, it's inherent interestingness (not a word, but wtv) is kind of obscured by its use as a bog-standard ecchi standard. We don't get to explore all the meaty angst and stress which would result from it in real life. But meh. Suppose we can't expect that, from an entertainment medium primarily aimed at young adults...
>>
>Arion - I'll wage war on gods so I can marry my sister
>>
>>101405311
15 years later, I still like the OP song.

And the suicide contemplation in the end...
>>
There needs to be more. The more there is, the more Japan will start to accept incest, and the more likely they'll let siblings marry.
>>
>>101411205
And then what? Invite your to a trip there? She still wouldn't marry you.
>>
>>101406170
nothing but pure fucking LOYALTY
>>
>>101411279
yours
>>
>>101411279
I changed their diapers when they were babies, and quite frankly a dirty baby diaper is probably a level of hell. I deserve every right to be married with one or both of them.
>>
>>101411743
did you wipe up or down
>>
>>101411743

Spoken like a true older brother.
>>
>>101411743
Deserving it has nothing to do with it. They still wouldn't marry you.
>>
>>101411902

He deserves to be able to, if he manages to get married or not is another issue.
>>
I would pay for a remake of Koi Kaze with good art/animation.
>>
>>101411802
Don't force me to remember repressed memories. Both.

>>101411902
>one doesn't want to date boys and doesn't have any booys that are friends, yet she is in 7th grade
>the other is too violent, a bit selfish, and doesn't wash herself regularly. Probably won't get a boyfriend
>they still wouldn't marry you
I don't know who else they would marry. They even are decently fond of me. Signs are looking good.
>>
>>101412556
Go and ask them, post results.
>>
>>101412556
you wiped poop into their vaginas

you are a bad onii-chan
>>
I never finished Koi Kaze. I should try to get back into it.

Yosuga no Sora was amazing (only the Sora arc though)
>>
>>101405311
the thing I found interesting about Koi Kaze was it was more focused as an incest story and not a pedophilia story despite the massive age difference. Everyone in the manga was like "you're fucking your sister!" and not "you're fucking a highschool girl!".
>>
>>101412842
Koi Kaze is really an interesting watch even though the art is pretty sub-par

>>101413103
Yeah for sure
except during the sandbox scene
>>
>>101412729
You must have never changed a diaper before. Its all over the inside of the diaper. The ass cheeks, the taint, the vag. It can't be helped.

>>101412691
Sadly
>1400 miles away
I do remember some childhood promise, when we were playing house, that we would marry each other. I more or less just went along with it at the time as to not make them sad.
>>
>>101413201
what the fuck were you feeding them
I have two kids
>>
>>101413201
So you got hung up on what they said during a phase that every little girl goes through despite the fact that you don't even have close interactions with them anymore.
>>
>>101406170

best brother ever

I can't believe it's a year ago already
>>
>>101405874
watching oniai right now, starting episode 3

its pretty meh so far, kinda generic but still over the top
>>
>>101413103
I think its because that sort of age gap isn't as uncommon as the whole incest thing.

It's really a well written story, if only it had a bigger budget
>>
>>101413103
I think that's attributed to Japanese culture in general.
>>
File: 1336891933868.png (225 KB, 775x583)
225 KB
225 KB PNG
>>101405311
>Oreimo - lol
>lol

Maybe if you where watching it as a harem, yeah its pretty silly, but if you actually pay attention to the siblings relationshit it makes perfect sense, it's realistic enough without becoming a heavy drama.

Incest /= depressive drama
>>
>>101413608
lol
>>
>>101405311
>total fantasy depiction
>doesn't have twin step-sisters that lust for your cock
Get a load of this guy.
>>
>>101413608
lol
>>
File: 1365382090073.gif (1.41 MB, 480x270)
1.41 MB
1.41 MB GIF
>>101413608
>oreimo being realistic
>>
File: photo.jpg (26.59 KB, 109x179)
26.59 KB
26.59 KB JPG
>>101405311
Absolutely disgusting, especially if worst girl (usually the sister) wins. Has there ever been a yuri/yaoi incest animu, or one where the MC is in love with his Christmas Cake onee-chan?
>>
>>101413608
lol
>>
>>101413872
Waiting for the arguments...
>>
>>101413897
>yaoi
>onee-chan
How would that even work?
>>
>>101413608
lol
>>
>>101413830
the parents being all for their kids fucking is the fantasy part
I had a friend who cock blocked me because he wanted to get with his stepsister
his jacked as fuck step brother beat the shit out of him so at least I got that out of it

>>101413897
isnt that the storyline of boku no pico and its various spinoffs
I've never actually watched it

>>101413988
girls with dicks
>>
>>101414066
>girls with dicks
That'd be Futa on male, not yaoi.
>>
>>101405311
>YnS
>Semi-realistic
lol
>>
File: absolute kirino territory.jpg (418.62 KB, 1159x1600)
418.62 KB
418.62 KB JPG
>>101405311
Terrible if half assed. Like Oreimo. Only the porn was good.
>>
>>101414206
>implying that hormone filled teenagers living on their own who find each other attractive aren't going to get carried away and fuck in every place imaginable

did you even go to highschool
>>
>>101405311
>how to make an anime about incest that is not a joke full of fanservice.jpg
Nice story.
>>
>>101414366
>Defending retarded 'so taboo' fap material
lol
>>
Its been almost 10 years since Koi Kaze. I don't think we'll get another incest show that isn't hentai/ecchi/harem. There probably isn't even a studio willing to take a chance on one.
>>
>>101414474
its not like it even matters that they were brother and sister since they sure as shit don't act like it
>>
>>101414366
>oh hey a cute boy let's fuck in the first date
>realistic

lol
>>
>>101414556
>implying anyone here watched any of YnS aside from the Sora arc
>>
>>101413148
>the art is sub par
Fuck you, the art is very good.
>>
>>101414613
>oh hey our parents are dead, wanna fuck?
>realistic

lol
>>
>>101413608
>there are people on this board who think Oreimo is a realistic depiction of siblings relationships
>>
>>101414613
My favourite is Akira-chan.
Pleb.
>>
>>101414734
I liked the art but it doesn't make it not subpar
>>
>>101415083
Maybe you mean the animation and the QUALITY but the art itself was good.
>>
>>101415310
yeah you got me
>>
>>101414937
I never said that, i just said their relationship makes sense, but i'm still waiting for your arguments.
>>
File: 1367788448411.jpg (49.35 KB, 960x910)
49.35 KB
49.35 KB JPG
>>101415444
theres nothing to argue you're just an idiot
>>
>>101413988
I meant that as 2 different things, but yeah it can work.
>Onee-chan gets ftm sex change
>MC more attracted to his Onee-chan now that she's a man
>>
>>101414613
>implying implications

Kazusa's arc was my favorite, eat shit.
>>
>>101415444
>if you actually pay attention to the siblings relationshit it makes perfect sense, it's realistic enough
Seems like you really said that to me.
>>
File: 1386561908837.jpg (275.79 KB, 1089x1080)
275.79 KB
275.79 KB JPG
>>101415592
Oh well...
>>
>>101415898
>Oreimo is a realistic depiction of siblings relationships

I never said that.
>>
>>101413608
lol
>>
>Koi Kaze

I don't know what it was, but I just couldn't listen to Koshiro's voice. It was painful, it sounded like what my best attempt at an impression of someone that has been smoking 2 packs a day for 40 years would sound like.
>>
File: 1363355558367.jpg (238.23 KB, 827x625)
238.23 KB
238.23 KB JPG
Incest plot elements are fucking dumb and disgusting, stop this bullshit.
>>
>>101416425
Isn't that the brother's friend?
>>
File: Capture.png (152.99 KB, 606x301)
152.99 KB
152.99 KB PNG
>>101416521
Yup. That entire manga was absolutely retarded.
>>
>>101417204
I don't even know how I remembered that when I haven't even read it. I just recognized the pic.
>>
>>101413330
Like I said, they were babies, their digestive systems are still developing. Go google baby poopy diapers on google images.

>>101413373
>don't even have close interactions with them anymore
I now see them for for at least 3 months every year. I lived with them and grew up with them for 8 years before I moved out.

>hung up
More like I'm just waiting for things to take their course. I'd never marry/date a 3dpd anyway, but if it is what makes my sisters happy, I'm more than willing to walk the extra mile.
>>
>>101416425
>>101417204
What would you guys do if you were the brother?

Shes underage, she is(was) your pure sister that you love, your friend not only defiled her/took advantage of her, he could have killed her in the process.
>>
all greatest love stories ever told
>>
File: 1363893796876.jpg (15.86 KB, 320x240)
15.86 KB
15.86 KB JPG
>>101417874
>willingly discussing Mon Seul

captcha: eepbudy standards
>>
>>101416425
And this is why I don't have friends.
>>
>>101418343
Ok, sure.
>>
File: noitsnotyoubitch.jpg (24.57 KB, 640x480)
24.57 KB
24.57 KB JPG
Kana little sister genuinely made me feel sick in some of the scenes. I only ever managed to finish the Yumi route then I uninstalled it.
>>
>>101416425
>>101417204
>>101418119
wow just starting to read this and ohgod
>>
>>101419094
Is she an elf or just a really ugly eleven?
>>
File: crybitch.jpg (36.23 KB, 640x480)
36.23 KB
36.23 KB JPG
>>101419337
The art is just QUALITY
>>
>>101407158
Yep.

He, an already fully grown man, raised her since she was a baby.
Now they're fucking like rabbits.
>>
>>101419967
>since she was a baby
No. More like since she was 6 or 7.
>>
>>101405311
>Oreimo - lol

What's that supposed to mean?
>>
File: aniki.png (723.35 KB, 800x450)
723.35 KB
723.35 KB PNG
>>101413608
I agree with you but I'm sorry that your post has fallen on deaf ears. It's to be expected. Sometimes I think Oreimo is just too deep for /a/.
>>
>>101421893
It's pretty self explanatory.
>>
>>101422120
lol
>>
>>101422151
Exactly.
>>
File: 1367167282155.jpg (61.46 KB, 421x354)
61.46 KB
61.46 KB JPG
>>101422056
how can you seriously consider oreimo to be deep

the deepest thing I remember is about people knocking things before trying it, pic related

I only saw the first season, seconds still on backlog though, but I know enough spoilers from /a/ that I haven't exactly bothered moving it up in my watchlist.
>>
>>101422304
>watching the anime

You fucked up.

>commenting on it when you haven't even finished it

You fucked up again.
>>
File: 2deep4U.png (53.14 KB, 895x126)
53.14 KB
53.14 KB PNG
>>101422056
For posterity.
>>
>>101422056
The deepest thing in that show was the vagoos.
>>
>>101422304
This is exactly how I feel about it. The studio switch the fucking character resets (I watched the first few eps) and generally fuckshittery is not very encouraging
>>
>>101422377
Go use that on the other Oreimo thread right the hell now.
>>
>>101421893
>lol = lots of love
So there is lots of love in oreimo hence the harem whereas the others weren't a harem. So Oreimo has lots of love compared to the others.
>>
>>101405311
has plenty of drama-fuel and life-ruining potential as long as the stereotypical "we're not blood related lol" bullshit doesn't show up

it also (the serious ones) tends to approach the relationship from a more realistic angle, which is a nice change of pace

Koi Kaze had a great OST.
>>
>>101422479
It's already near the bump limit, I'll leave it for another time.
>>
File: developments.jpg (1.57 MB, 3084x2140)
1.57 MB
1.57 MB JPG
>>101422386
I'm sorry to see the plot went over your head.

Oreimo really isn't all that deep. There's just more to it than people think so it gets a bad rap because it's interpreted as a harem seriest with incest. So they rarely go into it with an open mind and don't even bother taking a peek under the surface. This is mostly due to the botched anime adaptation unfortunately. But that's fine if people don't like it, it doesn't upset me. I just wanted to post this image to maybe give you the idea that there could be some themes and development hidden inside that story.
>>
>criticise oreimo to any degree
>don't even mention girl preferences
>savage kirinofags come in spouting the aame shit about "reading the novels" and "manami/kuronekofag tears are le delicious" etc.

I hate this damn show and any fucking discussion to do with it. Why is it so bad? Because the tame incest attracted a bunch of faggotcunts that can't think straight (probably due to being a product of incest)? Or is it just inherently fucking awful? I certainly hated the shitty character development that's for sure
>>
>>101422913
This.
I fucking hate that incest threads are now polluted by oreimofags.
>>
>>101422913
I like you
>>
>>101422829
I dont understand. Am I supposed to be reading this right to left or left to right?
>>
>>101422913
>I hate this thing because I'm not willing to give it a chance or listen to any arguments

Willful ignorance is hilarious to see on /a/, it's so common. You hate things so you complain about them, but it doesn't matter because if someone gave you a reason to like it you wouldn't care, because you don't want to like it in the first place. Such narrow-mindedness.
>>
>>101422913
op here, all girls are worst girl.

he's better off moving and meeting someone at college
>>
>>101407158
Usagi Drop is vile, it makes Koi Kaze look so nice in comparison.
>>
>>101422913
Conversations evolve.

It just so happens that oreimo is a love it or hate it thing and thus generates the most discussion.
>>
>>101423132
I'm not a lolicon, but I kind of liked the meruru idol and the loli track star. You were right in saying the other girls were bad though.
>>
>>101423215
>oreimo is a love it or hate it thing

Spot on. There are a few on the fence people that get opinions from both sides and then default to one or another based on their state of mind, but there are always those 2 types.
>>
>>101423107
Yet nothing in my post has hinted that I will not/have not listened. The show's been done for what 6 months or so now? I think it is fucking shit, it's not ignorance cunt nugget it's an opinion that has yet to be budged by all the discussions I've had on it. I had no idea what this show would be like when I picked it up at the start of the 2010 fall season and I've gone through 2 seasons withba bad taste in my mouth.

Oh and let's just crush the last point in your post by saying that I liked MC at times.
>>
>>101423178
but, koi kaze -was- nice.
>>
>>101423107
Yet nothing in my post has hinted that I will not/have not listened. The show's been done for what 6 months or so now? I think it is fucking shit, it's not ignorance cunt nugget it's an opinion that has yet to be budged by all the discussions I've had on it. I had no idea what this show would be like when I picked it up at the start of the 2010 fall season and I've gone through 2 seasons with a bad taste in my mouth.

Oh and let's just crush the last point in your post by saying that I liked MC at times despite being the typical beta nippon protag.
>>
>>101423430
lol
>>
>>101423107
Yet nothing in my post has hinted that I will not/have not listened. The show's been done for what 6 months or so now? I think it is fucking shit, it's not ignorance cunt nugget it's an opinion that has yet to be budged by all the discussions I've had on it. I had no idea what this show would be like when I picked it up at the start of the 2010 fall season and I've gone through 2 seasons with a bad taste in my mouth.

Oh and let's just crush the last point in your post by saying that I liked MC at times despite being the typical beta nippon protag.
>>
>>101423430
>>101423501
>>101423562
I think your russka intranet is exploding sir
>>
File: 1387616098741.gif (165.20 KB, 500x454)
165.20 KB
165.20 KB GIF
>>101423562
>>101423501
>>101423430



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.