[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: clannad_tomo.jpg (77 KB, 800x600)
77 KB
77 KB JPG
Clannad vs Air vs Kanon (anime adaptations)

Discuss.

(in b4 gaijin 4koma)
>>
Kanon 2006 > Air > Clannad
>>
File: 1204986115486.jpg (174 KB, 368x509)
174 KB
174 KB JPG
I liked Kanon, mostly for Mai's arc.
>>
KEYS, on my /a/?
>>
>>10101240
/thread
>>
>>10101240
I will have to agree.
>>
I liked Kanon 2006 the best probably, but I still really like the other two. I don't see how they're going to resolve Clannad in just three episodes.
>>
I only watched Clannad so far so I'm biased.
>>
Clannad>Kanon 06>Air
imo
>>
Air.

Kanon was comedic early on, but when it got serious later, it didn't pull off tragedy as well as Air did. Never seen Clannad, maybe I ought to get on that.
>>
None, they were all ruined by KyoAni, the only good one was the 2002 Kanon adaptation that had nothing to do with KyoAni.
>>
Air and Kanon.

Probably because after Air and Kanon, KEY's GET READY TO BAAAAW tactic doesn't work on me anymore.
>>
Clannad is good, but suffers from being Pure, Undiluted Key. Like, after Kanon, which was good, but in part trainwreck (WAY TOO YOUNG CHARACTERS!!!) it's hard to take a show/vn with the same concepts at face value and expect an equal reaction.

Had Kanon never been, and Clannad landed at some 35-40 episodes, fully fleshing out several of the butchered arcs, with a fulfilling end of choice, then shit would have been Awesome.

I have watched AIR over eleven times now, and it's still just as good. AIR is quite possibly one of my favourite shows, EVER.
>>
File: 1204986612765.jpg (167 KB, 1024x768)
167 KB
167 KB JPG
>>10101334

Are you sure?
>>
File: 1204986666781.jpg (34 KB, 639x481)
34 KB
34 KB JPG
;_;
>>
orz
>>
File: 1204986706662.jpg (47 KB, 640x480)
47 KB
47 KB JPG
>>10101353
Why did filename make me lol?
>>
>>10101353

This some Akagi?
>>
File: 1204986723024.jpg (332 KB, 1176x1200)
332 KB
332 KB JPG
>>10101361
>>10101353
>>
File: 1204986747421.jpg (169 KB, 1453x561)
169 KB
169 KB JPG
>>10101235
>>
>>10101353
>>10101378

Very sure.
>>
Clannad > Air > Kanon

Kanon and Air have too much nonsensical magical bullshit to keep me on them.
>>
>>10101401

And the imaginary world isn't.
>>
File: 1204987019513.jpg (91 KB, 458x1339)
91 KB
91 KB JPG
>>
>>10101401
Fuko arc was all MAGIC
>>
Eternal Fighter Zero needs an update with teh Clannads.
>>
>>10101408
It's far from being as important as all the magical bullshit in Kanon or Air though.
>>
>>10101408
It really didn't affects the storyline at all until After Story. They could have just made it a purgatory where the alternate Tomoya could have gathered up the orbs.

What I don't get is that you can bring back a ghost with one but can only avoid death with all of them.
>>
Good things from KEY:
AIR-Last episode of second arc
AIR-Episode 11&12
Kanon-Wedding scene
Kanon-TheReveal (since I watched it unspoilered)
Clannad-The Wedding Scene
Clannad-If you find this suitcase

Character-wise:
Misuzu (AIR TV-version, platonic or bust)
Haruka (AIR, fantastic character development)
Nayuki (Kanon. Normal, yet lovely.)
Tomoyo (Clannad, the strongest girl.)
Kotomi (Clannad, perhaps fanboyism from my side, but I can't resist her.)
the Sunoharas (Clannad, fuck yeah Sunoharas).
>>
>>10101461
Fuuko's route didn't really focus on the magic unlike the routes in Kanon or Air.
>>
>>10101475

Wait till the After Story.

That's when the magik stuff happens. Being Kyoto Animation, I can assure you this will happen.
>>
File: 1204987322276.jpg (153 KB, 600x630)
153 KB
153 KB JPG
Fun fact: 403 Forbiddena made a Kanon medley, and it's awesome.
>>
>>10101496

Agreed.

Especially Sunohara. He's the best friend ever.
>>
>>10101499
No it's not a focus in the After Story either, only a plot device to bring the True ending. The After Story is actually really grounded in reality and that's what one of the thing that makes it far more touching that anything in Kanon.
>>
File: 1204987760191.jpg (125 KB, 600x550)
125 KB
125 KB JPG
AIR

AIR was just perfect - maybe a bit rushed in some places and the plot was at first a bit hard to understand, but the end gave me a gigantic BAAAAWWning, which will get even more tragic when you finnaly understand the whole TIME PARADOX and LOL CROW shit...
>>
Air TV was a failure. Even the movie did a better job.
>>
File: 1204987860537.jpg (42 KB, 640x480)
42 KB
42 KB JPG
>>10101469
;_;

I don't see why they have Moon, but no CLANNAD.
>>
File: 1204988213200.jpg (53 KB, 640x480)
53 KB
53 KB JPG
Clannad is the better of the three.

Pic related.
>>
AIR did a good job in the fact that it was only twelve episodes, and effectively wrapped up all the girls' arc. I personally see Yukito as the better protagonist Yuuchi and Tomoya.

Clannad is pretty much failing it right now since they rushed through half the arcs and completely took out others. Outside of Nayuki's arc, Kanon was good in following the routes.
>>
File: 1204988303580.gif (6 MB, 480x360)
6 MB
6 MB GIF
With episode 20 I have to give it to Clannad, finally a Key heroine I like.
>>
>>10101661
Not like they could have done anything else with Clannad, Kyou and Tomoyo routes simply can't be adapted.
>>
File: 1204989240474.jpg (41 KB, 640x480)
41 KB
41 KB JPG
>>
>>Outside of Nayuki's arc, Kanon was good in following the routes.

And that is why Kanon failed.
>>
>>10101676
Well, I'm happy that I dropped this shit.
>>
>>10101676
delicious is delicious
>>
The best thing about Clannad isnt the story, its about the interaction between the main girls(Kotomi route for example). Which Kanon and Air both lacked.
>>
Air fucking sucked.

Kanon 2006 was a better anime adaption, as it actually adapted all the arcs somewhat faithfully.

Clannad anime has been half awesome and half shit. For awesome see kotomi arc and the last few episodes. For shit see fuko arc and the first few after kotomi.
>>
File: 1204989728372.jpg (185 KB, 597x1680)
185 KB
185 KB JPG
WHERE IS USHIO? She barely appeared in the movie dammit. Ushio arc>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Anything in Kanon or Air.
>>
>>10101916
Fuuko arc is shit? Were you raised in a concentration camp or something? Goddamn!
>>
>>10102007

FUKO'S ARC WAS THE RETARD ARC EVER.
>>
File: 1204990300619.jpg (29 KB, 640x480)
29 KB
29 KB JPG
>>10102027

But Fuuko is number 1 in Japan ;_;
>>
>>10102007
It was dumb because I cannot sympathise with kids with downs syndrome.
>>
>>10102063
She was just masking the horrible pain...
>>
>>10102063
You must have had a really hard time watching Kanon and Air then, I sympathize.
>>
File: 1204990620171.png (436 KB, 448x598)
436 KB
436 KB PNG
>>10101496
>Most of the rest, plot and characters, is made of crap, moƩ and forced emotion
Fuck you, Akio and Sanae are win.
>>
>>10102087

Nah, Fuuko's really quite retarded. Even more than her Air and Kanon counterparts. Heck, she was still quite retarded in the After Story, Ninja Fuuko's existance is a proof that.
>>
>>10102097
I did. But I got through them. It's kind of annoying when Clannad has non-retarded other characters, but the first (WAY TOO LONG) arc focuses on the retardblob.
>>
>>10102107
Makoto and Ayu are as retarded as her, don't delude yourself. Misuzu too and Mai is borderline.
>>
File: 1204990757547.jpg (88 KB, 960x1285)
88 KB
88 KB JPG
Clannad will be the best if it'll have gay end.
>>
File: 1204990778203.jpg (44 KB, 200x296)
44 KB
44 KB JPG
> Mai is borderline.
>>
>FUKO'S ARC WAS THE RETARD ARC EVER.
>WAS THE RETARD ARC EVER.
No Anonymous, you are the retard arc.
>>
>>10102007
Fuuko's lasted too long. They could have cut 2 episodes from it and life would have been swell.
>>
>>10102140

Think of it as an introductory chapter for most characters.
>>
>>10102140
Fuuko had 5 episodes, same thing for Kotomi. Compare it to Makoto in Kanon who had 7 episodes.
>>
HITODE
HITODE
HITODE
HITODE
HITODE
DAIKAIZOKU
>>
Clannad > Air > Kanon
>>
File: 1204991496216.jpg (40 KB, 634x477)
40 KB
40 KB JPG
>>10102222
>>
>>10102140
If you'll say that Fuuko's arc lasted 9 eps, I'm gonna laugh. It lasted 5 eps, like Kotomi's
>>
>>10102288
well, it took 9 eps to finally move on to the other characters.
>>
>>10102262
Here. But I have to agree that the best BGMs were in Air.
>>
>>10102280
What?
>>
>>10102291
The first four or five episodes were pretty much a mixed bag of every route. Even Yukine got in there.
>>
>>10102297
The whole dango vs starfish talk was imaginated by Tomoya in the VN. And that was the song he tought for the starfish.



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.