[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: 8h1qi2rjuo.jpg (53.76 KB, 438x524)
53.76 KB
53.76 KB JPG
What if, hypothetically, Madoka Magica had roughly two male magical male characters? (As in males could contract with Kyubey too)

Series ruined? Improvement?
>>
Animated by SHAFT.
>>
Ruined.
>>
As long as one of them gets their ass kicked by Kyouko I would be happy and my femdom fetish would be happy.
>>
File: 1390164875770.jpg (131.50 KB, 1280x720)
131.50 KB
131.50 KB JPG
It could be an interesting dynamic. The series lacked a pure caster. Also nobody used an axe.
>>
If there wasn't any forced OTP shit I think it would have improved character development, which I thought was lacking quite a bit in PMMM.

>inb4 drama CDs and sidestory mangas.
>>
>>100811683
one of them would have to be the brother of one of the other girls.

Something like the girl made a wish to cure the brother from an incurable disease, the brother made a wish so that he could be with his sister.


Brutal killing or turning of one right in front of the other. possibly the turning of one causes the other to also turn immediately

mitebcool.
>>
I've never finished an episode of madoka. But I'd say the only reason it works is because theyre girls.
>>
/u/ would throw faggot fit about it and we'd never hear the end of it.
>>
You know, about a year ago I'd hate this concept to death, but now I probably wouldn't mind it, as long as it was written cohesively that is.
>>
>>100812430
Good.
>>
>>100812519
Not good. I'm tired of seeing them shit things up.
>>
>>100812545
Oh god me too, they are like reverse fujoshis they see homosexuality everywhere, i wish they fucking die.
>>
I don't know. Madoka had a lot of potential with its world-building premise but left way too much open ended. It was a good series, but could have benefited from a few more episodes, and possibly more characters, male or not.
>>
>>100812670
I wouldn't go that far, it's just irritating to be talking about something and suddenly GUYS YOU KNOW THEY'RE ALL GAY RIGHT THEY'RE TOTALLY GAY STOP DISAGREEING WITH ME THEY'RE GAY BECAUSE I SAY SO.

I just want them to keep their shit on their own board.
>>
File: 13901648757713.jpg (27.46 KB, 640x360)
27.46 KB
27.46 KB JPG
>>100811683
It could work, but with the right kind of male characters, not just your average boring ones.

If there was a character like Gino from Code Geass as a magical person in Madoka it would be pretty good. He'd be talented, friendly, but also kind of cocky and carefree. He'd also keep Kyouko's tsun-tsun-ness in check.
>>
/u/ would hate
i wouldnt care either way
>>
Congratulations you've made that shit show a little more bearable.
>>
There is only one option.
>>
Would not watch at all.
>magical males
I flipped my shit when there was a male magician in Nanoha.
>>
>>100812734
They are all gay.
>>
File: 1372252322415.jpg (18.31 KB, 300x265)
18.31 KB
18.31 KB JPG
>>100812545
>>100812670
>>
>>100813691
>>100813730
/u/ is here.
Everybody go home.
>>
File: 1373242489681.png (140.31 KB, 489x443)
140.31 KB
140.31 KB PNG
>>100813788
>thinking that they arent gay
lel, stupid hetero faggot
>>
>>100813788
>magical girls
>males in a MAGICAL GIRL ANIME
Males should at least be background characters. If I wanted males, I would look for sports anime.
>>
>>100813889
It's weird that I can't tell whether or not this is an ironic shitpost or just a regular /u/ post.
>>
>>100813923
>if I wanted males, I would look for sports anime.
The dumbest shit I've heard all week. Pat yourself on the back.
>>
>>100813923
>Males in a subversion of the magical girl genre
>A problem
Only for faggots like /u/
>>
Would be shit. There's enough people trying to insert romantic themes that didn't exist with an all girl cast. Putting males in the cast would make it so all threads were nothing but constant shipping.
>>
File: 1376666035829.jpg (52.69 KB, 498x500)
52.69 KB
52.69 KB JPG
>>100813954
do you suck dicks?
>>
>>100813954
Well, /(^|[^a-z]|top( ){0,1})(l|k)(o|e|y|q)(l|k)($|[^a-z])/i tends to be the realm of pure shitposters.
>>
>>100814044
As if that's not the current reality.
>>
It would be more of a parody rather than a deconstruction at that point.
>>
>>100814044
Isn't that more of an issue with faggots on this board rather than the show itself. I mean just because there are male characters doesn't mean there has to be a romance. Besides, there already was at least one straight romance (as one sided and fucked up as it was) AND most Madoka threads devolve into shipping threads already anyway!
>>
File: u1vJDXo1qb7hnro.jpg (122.43 KB, 500x328)
122.43 KB
122.43 KB JPG
>How to piss off /u/, the picture.
>>
>>100811683
Fine but they can't have anything to do with each other or else it'll attract the Yaoi faggots.

Also one of them has to fight Homura for Madoka's love and break her by claiming he can give her the babies Madoka always wanted.

Honestly, yeah I'd be fine with male characters. I mean hell part of the power that comes from magical girls is karmic power from importance in life. Considering most important figures are male...
>>
>>100813954
I like yuri myself but I honestly don't understand the majority of /u/ posters. It just seems ridiculous to start deluding yourself into thinking that literally every character is a lesbian, and it ruins discussions of stuff sometimes. "Hetfag" might just be one of the most retarded things I've seen come from this site.
>>
>>100814186
Not if it were done in a realistic way for example:
>Magical boys exist but still get girl clothes when they transform is a parody
>Magical boys exist and have normal, realistic clothes in their transformations is a deconstruction/subversion of the magical girl trope that only girls get magic in a magical girl anime.
>>
>>100814290
"Hetfag" is about as stupid as someone saying "CIS" or "CISgendered".
>>
File: 1383434071019.jpg (167.52 KB, 1600x1500)
167.52 KB
167.52 KB JPG
M-muh yuri...
>>
>magic is associated with females historically because women tend to be more superstitious
>magical boys are completely delusional and hysterical wrecks
Magical murder shotas mite b cool.
>>
File: 1390203392501.jpg (8.54 KB, 225x225)
8.54 KB
8.54 KB JPG
Instead of shoving males in a magical girl show, how about making a magical boy show where the combat is reminiscent of Metal Gear Rising?
>>
>>100814966
THE TIME
HAS COME TO AN END
>>
File: ikXTROfAvSwtR.gif (2.02 MB, 190x150)
2.02 MB
2.02 MB GIF
>>100814966
>lobbing 2 story tall demons across the street like a rag doll

Oh god take my fucking money.
>>
>>100811683
>What if x show had more penis?
Are you a homosexual?
>>
>>100814966
Fucking this.
>>
>>100814966
Holy shit.
>>
File: no_goggles_required.jpg (116.90 KB, 1280x720)
116.90 KB
116.90 KB JPG
>>100812430
Because the presence of guys has always stopped /u/ before, right?
>>
File: 1377489188837.gif (986.27 KB, 438x305)
986.27 KB
986.27 KB GIF
>>100814966
>the combat is reminiscent of Metal Gear Rising
>>
File: 1390257897707.gif (974.23 KB, 240x149)
974.23 KB
974.23 KB GIF
>>100814966
I... would watch it actually
>>
>>100814966
>magical boys performing zandatsu

pls
>>
File: 1369071290012.gif (2.98 MB, 220x242)
2.98 MB
2.98 MB GIF
>>100814966
Shut up and take my RULES OF NATURE
>>
>>100815176
YEAAAAAAAAAHHHHH
THIS IS WHAT NATURE PLANNNNNNNED
>>
>>100815230
Isn't that just a generic battle anime?
>>
>>100814966
heh
>>
>>100815572
Animated by SHAFT
Written by Gen Urobuchi
>>
>>100815539
BEING TRACKED BY A STARVING BEAST
LOOKING FOR ITS DAILY FEAST
>>
>>100815626
Just watch Fate/zero. It's just got fewer headtilts.
>>
>>100815572
It will be a deconstruction of the battle anime genre and have some convoluted, pretentious deep and meaningful ending like EoE.
>>
File: 1380917923591.png (211.47 KB, 300x377)
211.47 KB
211.47 KB PNG
>>100814966
Not bad asshole, not bad.
>>
>>100815679
A PREDATOR ON THE VERGE OF DEATH
CLOSE TO IT'S LAST BREATH
>>
>>100814290
>>100814523
I believe the term has a proper use.

It works perfectly for obnoxious faggots who believe there's no such thing as lesbianism even in 2D world and "corrective rape" isn't an absolute shit fetish.
>>
>>100815882
>I believe the term has a proper use.

Everything has a "proper use". It's when the vast majority of shitheads that use the word use it incorrectly, that's when a buzzword is born.
>>
>>100815874
GETTING CLOSE TO ITS LAST BREATH

RULES OF NATURE
>>
>>100815981
AND THEY RUN WHEN THE SUN COMES UP
>>
>>100814290
>>100814523
How new are you people? That's just how things are named here. x for the fandom with a fag at the end.
Hetfag - faggot who likes heteroshit
yurifag - faggot who likes yurishit

The key point is you're all faggots. I am too. It comes with posting here.
>>
>>100816060
ALIVE
>>
>>100816077
Yeah man, I forgot all about the robust heterosexual fandom. Everyone knows about them and how huge they are.

Might as well go in a chinese shop and call everyone else chinafags.
>>
>>100816077
That's not the point. Literally anyone that dares give the idea that every character isn't a lesbian is a hetfag, and that's why people think the term is retarded.
>>
>>100816077
>I don't know how "hetfag" is used
>I cannot stop sucking on dicks

Two quotes from you.
>>
This thread is making me want to play through Rising again.

Thanks shitheads.
>>
>>100816196
I still can't get believe they cast fucking Quinton Flynn for Raiden.

How are you not supposed to end up with a passionate man crush on Axel by the end?
>>
>>100816138
>I forgot all about the robust heterosexual fandom.
Do you seriously think there isn't? That's why het romance never sells, right?
>>100816152
Funny, I see more people insisting characters are never lesbians. I mean you have people who come into threads about a series with yuri, then complain about yurifags shitting up their threads.
>>
>>100816316
He voiced Raiden since MGS2, I don't see why they wouldn't.
>>
File: 1314497004899.gif (2.90 MB, 290x189)
2.90 MB
2.90 MB GIF
>half the thread is people karaokeing RULES OF NATURE
>Other half is arguing about the meaning of "hetfag"

I love you /a/. Never change.
>>
>>100816362
Can we just agree that both extremes are faggots and be done with it?
>>
>>100816426
Nope.
>>
>>100816078
FOR AWHIIIILLLLLLEEEE
>>
>>100816472
NO CHOICE
>>
>>100816426
I'll agree to that, faggot.
>>
>>100816505
GOTTA FOLLOW THE LAWS OF THE WIIIIIIILLLLLD
>>
>>100816617
ALIVE
>>
>theme songs
armstrong > sam > monsoon > mistral > bladewolf > sundowner
>>
>>100816663
Armstrong = Rex > Sam > Monsoon > Sundowner > Mistral
>>
>>100816638
WITH THEIR LIVES ON THE LINE
>>
>>100816795
NO CHOICE
>>
STANDING HERE
>>
>>100816818
OUUUT HERE ONLY THE STRONG SURRRVIIIIIIIVE
>>
>>100816888
WHAT'S DONE IS DONE
SURVIVED TO SEE ANOTHER DAY
>>
"Sayaka has always been such a good friend to me...I wish I could help her somehow..."
"'Wish?' Did somebody say 'wish?'"
>>
>>100816734
>>100816734
RAY = Mistral > Sundowner > Sam > Armstrong > Bladewolf > Monsoon

But I respect your opinions
>>
>>100816077
Hetfag is only properly used when you're dealing with a narrow minded idiot who believes the cock is absolutely supreme and every lily needs a "good dicking" to fix them.
>>
Madoka Magica is bad and you should all feel bad. HURR DURR CUTE GIRLS DOING CUTE THINGS BEST ANIMU EVAR LOL XD
>>
>>100817023
>Armstrong that low with Mistral that high

I will respect your opinions though I disagree with them.
>>
File: 1384991338706.jpg (29.28 KB, 528x543)
29.28 KB
29.28 KB JPG
>>100814966
Oh good fucking lord, yes.
>>
>>100816990
THE DANCE OF LIFE
THE HUNTER AND THE AGILE PREY
>>
>>100816998
>implying the violinfag cares about anything besides his violin.
>>
>>100817094
Take a hike chum that shit got old in 2011.
>>
>>100817135
NO GUARANTEE
WHICH OF THEM WILL SUCCEED
>>
>>100817038
>a narrow minded idiot who believes the cock is absolutely supreme and every lily needs a "good dicking" to fix them
You mean a good 30-40% of /a/?
>>
>>100817101
It was tough to sort, I like them all a lot, but Mistral's song was what pushed me into getting the whole soundtrack, so she definitely goes top. Different tastes I guess.
>>
>>100817175
I'm not your chum m8, also if you like moe shit then you represent the cancer that is killing the anime industry.
>>
>>100817259
I would tell you to go back to /v/, but you're already here.
>>
>>100817233
STRONG OR WEEEEAAAAAAKKK
>>
>>100817306
RULES OF NATURE
>>
>>100817235
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1j2Duy_xzEA
>>
>>100817235
I forgot to add this, so I'll do it real quick before I get my ass hounded over a misunderstanding.

The difference in sorting out who really are the faggots are the ones who won't stop shitposting just because they know it's working.
>>
File: 1335968580887.jpg (171.77 KB, 1280x720)
171.77 KB
171.77 KB JPG
>>100817333
RULES OF NATUURRRRRRRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEE

That was fun.
>>
>>100817366
>the ones who won't stop shitposting just because they know it's working.
So 99.9999% of /a/?
>>
>>100817294
>implying I go on /v/ at all
No I just don't like watching this board get destroyed by little girl plotless bullshit.
>>
>>100817503
Fuck.
>>
File: STANDING HERE.gif (2.40 MB, 350x197)
2.40 MB
2.40 MB GIF
>>100817486
Yeah, I'm glad we got to have this experience.

Have a cool night, /a/non.
>>
>>100811683
Probably about the same as far as I'm concerned
>>
>>100817504
>anime
>plot
Wrong entertainment medium.
>>
>>100817732
I can name tons of anime that have decent plot so don't give me that shit. Stop defending your little fetish with ''moe kawaii desu uguu'' garbage.
>>
That would have made the show go from good to great.

It would have been a masterpiece of Homura was a male; just a true pure love. A man fighting against all odds for his waifu. 10/10.

It's a shame /u/ has to ruin a lot of things.
>>
>>100817953
>It would have been a masterpiece of Homura was a male
Homura is already a creepy, obsessive stalker. Making her male just adds a lot of cultural baggage making everything worse. It'd literally be twilight.
>>
>>100817953
Close but no.
Make Madoka male.
>>
>>100818281
Then it would be a harem.
>>
>>100818376
DANTE MUST DIE MODE:
Madoka and Kyouko are male.
>>
>>100818439
It's then by Kyouko's harem. Hell, it already is.
>>
what if homura had been male
>>
File: 1329534361957.png (269.82 KB, 720x1000)
269.82 KB
269.82 KB PNG
>>100818639
madoka would be better
>>
>>100818639
It would have been a Steins;Gate ripoff.
>>
>>100818721
Absolutely disgusting.
>>
what do magical boys even look like
>>
>>100818808
You have your own board, fagbait.
>>
Sayaka wouldn't have to go through any suffering if she could've just redirected the opportunity for a wish to Kamijou.
>>
File: raiden.jpg (250.16 KB, 1280x800)
250.16 KB
250.16 KB JPG
>>100818816
>>
File: Naruto_newshot.png (1.18 MB, 1388x1055)
1.18 MB
1.18 MB PNG
>>100818816
Like this.
>>
>>100818924
I like it.
>>
>>100818893
>Sayaka wouldn't have to go through any suffering
What's the point if there's no suffering?
>>
>>100818281
>Beta guy being saved by his yandere waifu

I think I've seen enough of that shit.


>>100818217
If Homura was a guy, it would be less creepy, and I don't really think it would be a thing like Twilight. But maybe you're right, I'd have to ponder about it for a while.
>>
File: 1349409185459.jpg (276.46 KB, 712x819)
276.46 KB
276.46 KB JPG
>>100817038
That's true though.
>>
File: greenmugiatdusk.jpg (81.98 KB, 1280x720)
81.98 KB
81.98 KB JPG
>>100818893
>Sayaka wouldn't have to go through any suffering
Not on my watch!
>>
>>100817038
But girls are dikes by choice, and dikes are only around because they either hate men or have never experienced a good dicking.

Only gays that aren't gay by choice are gay men. I have nothing against them either.
>>
>>100819140
Fuck off bitch! You are the worst character to ever exist in any anime ever you empty headed skank!
>>
File: 1328670490829.jpg (41.58 KB, 730x247)
41.58 KB
41.58 KB JPG
>>100819120
Rance is a classy fucker.
>>
>>100819217
Calm down that isn't pink shit.

She singlehandedly made nurutu even worse and that's not an exaggeration.
>>
>>100819205
And what evidence could you possibly have?

Sounds like old fashioned bullshit double standards and unfounded at that.
>>
>>100819515
I have lesbian friends and gay friends.

The lesbian ones say they've been attracted to guys before while the gay ones say they've never been attracted to girls before.

This isn't just some baseless claim, I've done my research.

Now fuck off back to /u/.
>>
>>100819584
So you automatically assume I'm from that shithole just because I think you're full of it?

And then you use your friends as an argument?
>>
>>100819584
I've never been attracted to guys even when I tried desperately to be in high school.
>>
>>100819708
Because you're not gay, you faggot.

>>100819680
Yes, you piece of shit.
>>
>>100813923
Males were in the best magical girl anime of all time, Card Captor Sakura.
Hell, Sakura was even canon straight.
>>
>>100819745
I could honestly give less of a fuck about 3D if, but if you're literally applying that logic to 2D world you at without a doubt a goddamn idiot.
>>
>>100819847
She was bi. So was Syaoron.
>>
>>100819850
>S-shit, he knows what he's talking about! Better tell him this is an argument only about 2D!

Let me tell you what, my logic can be applied to 2D, because any logic can.
>>
>>100819902
Or maybe, now this is wild, they just had close friends of their own gender they DIDN'T want to fuck.
>>
>>100819954
Did you even watch it? Syaoran was crushing hard on Yukito and Sakura was crushing hard on the female teacher. They're bi. Either that or magicsexual.
>>
>>100819954
>had close friends of their own gender they DIDN'T want to fuck
Then I guess they weren't that close.

Or they did in fact want to bang. Kids like to hide the pickle, too.
>>
>>100819947
>Better tell him this is an argument only about 2D!

But it fucking is.

And yes you are being stupid because you literally just told me you based an entire demographic off a small circle of people you know.

And now you have the nerve to claim it absolutely applies to fantasy.
>>
>>100820301
It does apply to fantasy in any case where the one writing the story calls for it.

At least I have something to base my claims off of.
>>
>>100811683
remember Sailor Stars?

the series was pretty great with the male/female dinamic between the characters, made for some very nice moments when not fighting evil
>>
>>100819745
I am. In fact, I'd be a lesbillion.
>>
>>100820410
W-what?
>>
>>100820343
My fucking problem with what you're spouting is that you're basically claiming it's impossible for females to not be attracted to males and the fact actual asexual people exist instantly proves it as bullshit.
>>
>>100820493
Well, I think, you're wrong.
>>
>>100820543
You're not serious.
>>
>>100820585
Gay women feel pleasure from being fucked with a dildo, therefore they feel pleasure from being fucked with a cock. It's simple really, any woman can be made to love the cock if she's dicked well enough.
>>
>>100820647
Most lesbians don't actually use dildos frequently.
>>
>>100820772
Good joke.

That would mean they don't have sex, they just have foreplay.
>>
>>100820647
That could just as easily only apply to "lesbians" who actually use toys, you don't believe in asexuality? I don't believe any slut who uses those things is truly a lesbian since a they really are basically the same.

Your move.
>>
>>100820854
As stated above, lesbians who don't use toys aren't lesbians because they don't have sex. They just have foreplay.

Checkmate.
>>
>>100820804
>kissing, cuddling, and oral

I fail to see the problem anon.
>>
>ITT: We /lgbt/ now
Shut the fuck up and go watch some animu. Or for fucks sake use sage.
>>
>>100820804
>>100820911
I suppose you're the expert on not having sex.
>>
>>100820971
I'm trying to fucking keep the argument in 2D realm.

And yes I am pointing fingers.
>>
>>100820955
It's cute, but not gay. I'd suck a guys dick, but I'm not gay, and sure as fuck wouldn't let him stick it in my ass. Maybe.

>>100820985
I suppose you're just swimming in pussy, right?
>>
>>100821015
Sadly it's devolved past that point, anon. It went south around the time of "people I know do this so that makes it fact" conjecture.
>>
Technically aren't the "Magical Guy" shows Kamen Rider and Super Sentai. They're practically the same thing if its not a decontruction of the genre

>They see trouble
>They transform
>They fight the minions
>They fight the boss of the week
>They go back to Slice of Life shenanigans until it starts all over again.
>>
>>100821038
I thought so, but apparently I was wrong. Thankfully your infinite wisdom has taught be the truth, that I'm still a virgin.
>>
>>100821278
I'm glad you see the errors of your way.
>>
>>100821164
I believe girls can love girls, that they don't need dick period especially with full creative liberties in mind for fantasy, my opponent apparently believe otherwise and I keep being forced to use 3D logic as well to try to beat him at his own game.
>>
>>100821255
if you saw Sailor Stars, the boys and girls did plenty shenaningans when not fighting enemies, which made the show pretty cool
>>
Let's just get this thread back on track, both of us have clearly hit a stalemate.
>>
>>100811683
Just adding or subbing in male characters won't save the story.
>>
>>100814044
I hate this I really do.
>>
>>100822164
Exactly, all those delusiona shippers out there need to accept that their OTP is not and will never be canon. There's only one canon pairing in Madoka, Sayaka and murdering guys on trains..
>>
>>100814071
Wel, does she?
>>
>>100822408
No it's not even that.

Not everything needs pairings period. Not everyone needs a fucking love interest.
>>
>>100822679
yes



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.