[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


What a fucking cop-out bullshit ending,

If you're going to bother with some kind of anti-war message, put some fucking effort. Moeblobs stopped the fucking war. Seriously fuck you. Yes I'm mad.
>>
Faggot, it's about the power of music.

Everyone knows war is fine.
>>
>>100802051
>power of music

Oh fuck off. As if a soldier will stop complying to his orders because he somehow heard a song he recognised through all that noise while he's marching forward to the battle.

A shitty attempt to put some meaning into a brainless moe show.
>>
>>100801951
You're right
The bad guy's reasons were also shit
But the rest of the show was great
>>
>>100802270
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aQzRxGuBn0k
>>
File: 2070.jpg (62.79 KB, 1280x720)
62.79 KB
62.79 KB JPG
>Talking shit about SnW
Fuck you guy, The ending was pretty obvious but still a very good ending, This show had no flaws at all it was fucking great.
>>
I thought whats-her-name stopped it when she gave a declaration.
>>
>>100802341
A single sniper alone in the middle of fucking nowhere != An entire army that hasn't even started fighting
>>
>>100802342
I'm not your guy, friend.
>>
>>100802414
Prove it faggot, you won't.
>>
It was pretty rushed because of the episode count
>>
>>100802342
>No flaws
>Entire episode dedicated to the main character needing to piss
>>
>>100802341
>implying it stopped the war
>>
What a fucking fagot you are OP.
>>
>>100802457
There's nothing to prove, it's a fact.
>>
>>100802503
His trumpet wasn't big enough.
>>
>>100802494
>Entire episode dedicated to the main character needing to piss
>Flaw
It does have flaws though
>>
>>100802555
You don't know that for sure.
>>
>>100802494
That was the best episode you fucking tasteless kike.

Fight me irl. I'll kick your ass as your mom farts amazing grace with my dick in her mouth.
>>
>>100802648
You can't prove if what he's saying 100% true either so shut your fucking mouth.
>>
Only piss fetishists like Sora no Woto.
>>
>>100802692
You can't prove that I'll shut my mouth.
>>
>>100802735
Then I'll shut it up myself you faggot.
>>
>>100802648
>>100802801
>>
>>100802818
Alright, go ahead
>>
>>100802842
most likely != yes
>>
The war wasn't stopped by the music, only halted for a brief second.

Chihaya clone fucked the prince and made some kind of peace treaty to stop the war.
>>
>>100802950
Unless the army is literally one sniper in the middle of nowhere, it's a yes
>>
>>100802889
I'm going to bed now but I'll totally do it next day.
>>
>>100803079
I'm sure that's been the case in multiple instances.
>>
None of them wanted to fight. It was all a bunch of stupid brinksmanship and they just latched on to any excuse to not start shooting.
>>
>>100802968
>halted for a brief second

They stopped for like a fucking minute, it was complete bullshit. By the second they went forward, they would have started shooting since they were in god damn tanks anyway. Utter fucking bullshit.
>>
I didn't even like the first 10 episodes but the ending was great. Stop looking at it so superficially.
>>
>>100803165
>None of them

You don't know that. Even in WWII there were a bunch of psychos on all sides who simply enjoyed killing. Someone would have fired first.
>>
I loved it, fuck you OP. Piss episode was the best.
>>
>>100803278
The fucking music man.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4A0uCYDxE0

Right there it turned from something average to something really special. Even if it was just one episode.
>>
Fuck this show really I enjoyed SOME parts of it but it was pretty damn shit overall.

>pee episode just after shit started getting real
Give me a fucking break
>>
>>100803308
Why are you trying to interpret anime realistically?

Anime dude.
>>
>>100803308
These guys were all conscripts who grew up after mankind was almost completely wiped out. The psycho who would have fired first was the cockmongler from the previous episode
>>
>>100803278
Are you kidding me? Imagine if at the end of K-ON, the band starts doing coke and other drugs and then overcomes it. Just for the sake of some moral message. Fucking stupid.
>>
>>100803399
>>100802666
>>
Well, think of it like the cease fire during the Christmas of WWI. Also watch Joyeux Noel.
>>
>>100803577
>Here's an event that's nothing like what happened in the series

Yeah thanks.
>>
SnW is overrated shluick, we know this already.
>>
>>100803516
If there had been sufficient buildup to them having a drug problem it wouldn't have been something inherently bad. They were foreshadowing the war since episode one, it wasn't like a total asspull.
>>
>>100803700
you a shluick
>>
>>100803683
What I am saying is that things that are special to the soldiers heart can play a role in war, much like the music or Christmas. So, stopping an army that has yet to make casualty in battle with music is not unlikely.
>>
>>100801951
Are you really going to be this much of a faggot and disparage one of the few great endings in anime? Really?

What's the matter, too beautiful for you?
>>
>starting a SnW thread just to shitpost
just make a KLK or Dandy one
>>
>>100803942
SnK would be better tho
>>
Go be mad back in /v/.
>>
>>100803724
It was pre-established setting. The whole premise was about a post-apocalyptic world with a tense situation between two sides. My point is that they should have made some generic ending where it implies that their days continued to be like this and called it a day.

>>100803800
I already covered this. Completely different scenarios. Christmas is the biggest holiday in the West. Here, both sides were seconds away from killing each other.

>>100803845
There's plenty of series out there which either be one or another. Plenty of great SoL stuff and plenty of war related series that handle the subject in a more mature way. It's best not to mix things that don't belong to each other.

>>100803942
>>100804101
Constructive criticism is not shitposting. Take your low effort replies somewhere else.
>>
File: ji~.png (25.42 KB, 604x453)
25.42 KB
25.42 KB PNG
10/10 show
20/10 ending
op is either faggot or master troll
>>
It was okay. I just think it's funny there are people who genuinely think this is a masterpiece. I used to get mad about it, though.
>>
>>100804232
>Completely different scenarios. Christmas is the biggest holiday in the West. Here, both sides were seconds away from killing each other.

But no, it's not /that/ different. Replace Christmas with Amazing Grace in the world of Sora no Woto, the song which seems to be of significance to a most everyone and you've got almost the same effect. You also forget that they still were gonna fight anyways, but that moment of ceasefire bought enough time for reinforcements.

Also, the soldiers in that ditch were in the process of killing eachother, and they still did a ceasefire.
>>
>>100804494
I just can't suspend my disbelief enough to trust the writing. It felt like a cheap trick, like when you watch an action movie where the bomb counter stops at 0:01. Again, I'll repeat myself but it didn't flow well along with what the first 10 episodes were like. It tried to be what it's not.

Honestly apart from the ending, I thoroughly enjoyed the show and it was relaxing as hell. I got what I expected for the most part.
>>
>>100805195
you need to watch Symphogear, Frontier, AKB0048 and more anime in general
>>
>>100805195
You need to watch more fiction in general. But yeah.

I liked the ending but the crying scene prior to it felt iffy. To each their own.
>>
>>100805360
I've seen more than I should as it is. I'm disappointed with myself now how mad I got over this since it's been awhile. Not that I could stop watching it after 10 years now anyway.

>>100805585
I'm actually a massive sci-fi books nerd so it's even stupid to me how I couldn't find the ending believable enough. I do understand the message it was trying to convey.


Now you can let this thread die. I'm off to bed. I can always argue about some pointless show on /a/ another day.
>>
>>100801951
>mfw I missed the 4th of january get-together

did you guys even have it anyway?
>>
>>100802342
What about all the off-model animation?
I enjoyed the show, but that flaw was really distracting.
>>
>>100806796
Wait, there was a get together? Or was that the annual stream?

I missed that too
>>
At least it's not the power of friendship.
>>
File: [how sweet the sound].jpg (1.45 MB, 1280x720)
1.45 MB
1.45 MB JPG
Go fuck yourself OP, the entire show was great. The Amazing Grace at the end made me tear up.
>>
>>100806796
>>100807661
The annual stream happened.

I missed most of it.
>>
>>100806910
I didn't think it was that bad. Then I rewatched it. Holy shit. Everybody turns into blob people if they're five feet away from the "camera."

But hey, the backgrounds were beautiful, and that's what really matters right?
>>
>>100811383
OP must not be American.

If he had the blood of great patriots running through him, he would understand what Amazing Grace does to any apple pie-loving heterosexual red-blooded god-fearing soldier in the army of the Lord.

Glory, glory hallelujah!
>>
>>100811645
B-but Amazing Grace was written by a British guy.
>>
>>100812112
Yeah, and so was My Country, 'Tis of Thee, but fuck you guys, it's ours now.
>>
>>100801951
I thought it was a good anime. I watched it when it came out and didn't watch it again, but it was a rather decent anime revolving around soldier girls doing soldier things like ending war and making me want them to make out.
>>
>>100811383
>>100801951
Are there any penis edits for when they play the trumpet?



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.