[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


Early in part 5, gold experience was pierced in the hand by the arrow inside black sabbath's mouth.

Why did giorno not get gold experience requiem right there and then?
>>
Because part 5 is a poorly written mess.

Realistically you could probably say that the arrow did not consider him worthy at that point.
>>
Araki has no idea where the plot was going for most of part 5. It's why king crimson's power is explained completely differently during the initial fight with Bruno to the stuff at the colliseum at the end.
>>
File: 1389365262245.png (158.27 KB, 625x626)
158.27 KB
158.27 KB PNG
>>100775707
I, err, umm...
>>
>>100775841

>king crimson's power is explained completely differently during the initial fight with Bruno to the stuff at the colliseum at the end

but it wasnt, that was just different translations
>>
just like Kira gained the "Bites the Dust" ability when pierced, maybe some of the Gold Experience abilities that were only shown later came from that

the Requiem thing happens only if the stand fuses with the arrow, since iirc GE returned to normal after Giorno removed the arrow tip
>>
>>100776082

>the requiem thing only happens if the stand fuses with the arrow

Nope.avi

Silver chariot requirem drops the arrow several times and doesn't revert or dissapear.
>>
Well obviously it was a fuck up which is only one of many in the shit stain known as part 5. I could explain it however that it merely evolved Giorno's stand and gave him one of his other abilities that just manifested as a poor explanation of "giving life", like the retarded way he heals people.
>>
>>100775707
Given that Gold Experience has a really poorly defined power set that changes and evolves throughout part 5 you could probably explain it away by that.
>>
>>100775707
He wasn't worthy. The arrow seeks the person when he's worthy.
>>
The simplest answer is that that arrow had already pierced many people and it didn't have enough power left to give a requiem to a stand
>>
File: araki13a.jpg (29.19 KB, 336x252)
29.19 KB
29.19 KB JPG
>>100775707
Welcome to Araki, son.
Forgetting things sice 1986
>>
>>100775707
Don't look for an explanation. Araki was making things up as he went along.

>>100776792
Indeed
>>
>>100776082
>He didn't read Purple Haze Distortion

Giorno still has GER
>>
>>100775707
Because simply piercing the hand is not enough. I don't remember any instances of people gaining stands due to arrow-inflicted flesh wounds.
>>
>>100776899
Wait, that thing's canon?
>>
Why is the art for Part 5 so bad in the beginning compared to the previous parts?
>>
>>100776988
>I don't remember any instances of people gaining stands due to arrow-inflicted flesh wounds.
Did you read Stone Ocean?
>>
>>100777015
Not really but shhh
>>
>>100777032
Yes, but I don't remember it well.
>>
>>100777042
Ok, but Do you know where to find a download? I can't torrent right now
>>
>>100775707
>Cutting your fingers with the arrow is the same as getting it stabbed in your chest
>>
>>100777085
I don't know, did you google?
>>
>>100777015
Araki drew all the illustrations, so is clearly fake and fan-made.
>>
>>100777026
He was transitioning styles between the great style of Part 4 to his more feminine style of Part 6 and early Part 7
>>
>>100777146
Why would I ask if I hadn't?
>>
>>100777242
I don't know. And I have no link. Maybe you can do a bakabt or nyaa search.
>>
>>100777309
No luck, dammit. Not even the XDCC...
Oh well. Have fun reading it while I stick to playing shitty flash games.
;_;
>>
>>100777124
The arrow awakens Jolyne's Stand through a small cut in her fingers, just as it does to people that get shot in the throat.

JJBA is full of retcons and story inconsistencies. This is just one of them.
>>
>>100777239
I was thinking along those lines but I don't see how the art would downgrade like that unless Araki doesn't really take breaks in between parts.
>>
>>100777509
But Jolyne is a JoJo.
Of course JJBA has full of inconsistencies that don't matter but this is bullshit.
>>
>>100777614
Here's another question for you: how did Dio hide in his coffin for 100 years when Erina used it to escape the exploding ship?

Araki makes things up as he goes along depending on what he thinks is cool and is willing to ignore story inconsistencies if they conflict with that.
>>
>>100777509
See
>>100776683
Part 4 makes a huge deal out of this, because Kira doesn't get killed by the arrow
>>
>>100777697
Unworthy people aren't unaffected by the Arrow. They die because they get stands that go berserk. Giorno didn't do so. He was simply unaffected by it. Which means that Araki hadn't come up with the idea of Requiem stands when he wrote that chapter.
>>
>>100777597
At that time he didnt, each release was consecutively following the other
>>
>>100777694
I think you didn't read my post.
>>
>>100777838
What could be a more major story inconsistency than the fact the main villain of the series had no way of escaping death at the end of part 1?

And there's no reason to think that Jojos develop stands more easily than other people. Hell, they need the Arrow to do so (even if it's indirect), while other people such as Polnareff develop then naturally.
>>
>>100777816
That explains a lot of things
>>
>>100777939
You're still not getting it.
I said that there are inconsistencies, which overall don't matter. Not even Dio's comeback at the beginning of part 3 matters, Araki could have written it anyway he wanted (like the guys just finding the head intact).

All we've seen indicates that JoJos develop stands genetically, so saying that a simple contact with the arrow would activate the stand isn't a leap. And unless I'm omitting other shit in part 6 we've never seen any other person just get grazed by the arrow and still develop a stand.
>>
That'sbullshitbutIbelieveit.jpg
>>
>>100777428
Cheer up Anon
https://mega.co.nz/#!DcM2XCTI!eeRK89SqqBpfhHRvL44G1TeydAaQ2oUJbqYxb_LhSAc
>>
>>100778118
Have we ever seen someone get grazed by an Arrow and not develop a Stand?
>>
>>100778139
y-you too
>>
>>100778118
>All we've seen indicates that JoJos develop stands genetically
Joseph, Jotaro, Holly and Josuke got their stands because of Dio.
Jolyne got hers from the Arrow.
>>
>>100777694
I wonder why Araki's editors don't make him clear up inconsistencies. Though the coffin can be easily explained by saying there's another coffin or some bullshit like that
>>
>>100778220
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/05/120516115903.htm
You could say they all have the "Will of Joestar", which simply means they're genetically predisposed to be baddass. In the right conditions, they would have more potential than other people.
>>
>>100778220
Indeed. Every human has the potential to develop a Stand. It's just that the vast majority of people aren't capable of controlling them and the process of the Stand awakening kills them.
>>
>>100778220
And this post does not in any way contradict what it quotes.

>>100778263
They don't care, and no one does either. JoJo is a series that can get away with shit like that. Araki himself frequently plays on that sort of thing anyway, like Jotaro getting a new uniform in part 3.
>>
File: 1384539936846.png (664.34 KB, 815x588)
664.34 KB
664.34 KB PNG
He wasn't worthy at the time.
>>
>>100778220
All people have the potential to develop a stand (More so for JoJos since their family bloodline is OP), and if i remember correctly the only stand users Dio made was his tarot card groupies.
>>
>>100778458
>the only stand users Dio made was his tarot card groupies
Dio awakens The World -> Joestars get stands too due to blood connection (maybe because of The World's true ability).
>>
That's clearly cut and not pierced. Also every translation says light is shining so clearly something was about to happen but didn't.
>>
>>100778263
False bottom. It was explained.
>>
>>100776792
>Forgetting things sice 21986 BC.
There. Fixed that for you.
>>
>>100778683

>Jolyne gets cut in the finger
>Gets a stand
>The alien dude from part 4 gets grazed
>Develops a stand-like ability
>>
>>100778726
>they were both in the same coffin

thats fucking hilarious
specially if dio went WRYYYYYY while she was still on it
>>
>Light coming out the wound
I think it was on it's way, like when Silver chariot scraped it's finger on the arrow it partially activated its ability but not completely.



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.