[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: загружено (1).jpg (17.89 KB, 187x269)
17.89 KB
17.89 KB JPG
I`ll start:
Noragami
Tonari Seki-kun
D-Frag
Inari KonKon
Maken-ki
Mikakunin
Sakura Trick
Nourin
Saikin Imouto
Seitokai Yakuindomo

Meanwhile shit trio:
Nisekoi
Pupa
Mahou Senso

Why does SHAFT suck so much?
*46位/*41位 ★ (**1,742 pt) [*,*42予約] 14/02/28 劇場版「Wake Up Girls! 七人のアイドル」 初回限定版[Blu-ray+CD]
***,150位/***,138位 ★ (***,239 pt) [*,**1予約] 2014/03/26 ニセコイ 1(完全生産限定版)【イベント優先販売申込券付】 [Blu-ray]
>>
>Name better anime adaptations this season than Nisekoi
Witch Craft Works
Golden Time
>>
>Why does SHAFT suck so much?
Shinbo sucks at adaptations. And schedules. And at keeping staff working in Shaft too.
>>
File: 1278126040592.jpg (36.55 KB, 460x460)
36.55 KB
36.55 KB JPG
>>100657931
>Saikin Imouto
>>
>>100657931
Meanwhile which manga is outselling the rest? Nisekoi

Nice trolling op.
>>
Sakura Trick and Nourin are the better SHAFT shows this season than Nisekoi.

Nisekoi is answer on question "what will SHAFT do when it`ll run out of Monogataris" - it`ll continue doing same shit reusing same style for everything regardless of source material.
>>
>>100658088
Nisekoi was outselling the rest before the anime too. Its mainstream WSJ manga.The ones buying it now are SHAFT fags that did not read JUMP,
>>
>>100658088
Seitokai Yakuindomo?
>>
>>100658157
I felt sorry for those who bought this anime without reading the manga first.
>>
>>100657931
>comparing movie with series
>>
>>100658125
>Sakura Trick and Nourin are the better SHAFT shows this season than Nisekoi.
>
>Nisekoi is answer on question "what will SHAFT do when it`ll run out of Monogataris" - it`ll continue doing same shit reusing same style for everything regardless of source material.

Nisekoi will probably sell better than the other two, though. Shaft chose well in terms of picking something that will sell.

Remember that Infinite Stratos 2 was a big hit.
>>
I seriously hope none of you like Nisekoi, because it hit every shitty harem trope on its way down to the shitpile.
>>
>>100658460
Except SHAFT style completely does not fit the Manga and if anything, Mangafags are mad.
>>
>>100658071
Shit now I'm worried...
>>
>>100658570
>implying Nisekoi mangafags' utterly shit taste is worth anything
>>
>>100658645
>typical Shinbo shit eater
>>
>>100657931
Nisekoi anime is better than manga so it's quite a hard thing to do, OP.
>>
>>100657931
Is this le new epic troll for this season, guise?
>>
>>100658713
>Nisekoi anime
>better
That delusion reminds of Denpa Onna, Maria Holic, Sasami again.
>>
>>100658773
But the manga is terrible trash, it's not hard to do better.
>>
>>100658764
>calling shaft shift
>trolling
>new
Newfag please go and stay go

>>100658773
Negima and Natsu no Arashi even better examples
>>
>>100658794
>But the manga is terrible trash
Nice meme
>>
>>100658809
Just keep at it IRC. One day people will actually fall for your shit.
>>
Aku no Rotoscope
>>
>>100658794
If you dont care about story, humor and characters and you watch Nisekoi solely for Shinbo quirks, dont. Just rewatch Monogatari backwards or something.
>>
>>100658607
It's not adapting the manga/LNs anyway, just the author writing it again for SHAFT.
>>
Tokyo Ravens.
>>
>>100658839
It's fucking garbage, anon.
>>
>>100657931
Why is everyone so set to shit on this anime.

Anons were attacking the fucking PVs even.
Is this some sort of vendetta against SHAFT or some shit?
>>
>>100658839
>B-but shaft adaptation is shit
Nice meme
>>
>>100658879
Aku no Rotoscope is not this season, and it actually great adaptation. Plus it saved anime - next we get Ping Pong Rotoscope
>>
>>100658885
>Just rewatch Monogatari backwards or something.
I think I'll do just that, actually
>>
ITT: IRC shits, half-baked trolls and butthurt newfags
>>
>>100658907
It's just IRC.

Stop taking the bait.
>>
>>100658088
>Meanwhile which manga is outselling the rest?

Because profits = quality, yeah....
In Japan.
Where >>100646108 things like these happens.
>>
>>100658907
It is a manga that would be adapted better by prety much everyone but SHAFT. People knew SHAFT would ruin it, and now they got confirmation.
>>
>>100658885
>If you dont care about story, humor and characters
I care about those, which is why I don't read nisekoi anymore, because it fails hard at all those.
Its saving grace was the art which could be funny every now and then.
>>
>>100658907
>Is this some sort of vendetta against SHAFT or some shit?

It's a split between Shaft hate and hate for the manga, which is the most generic harem ever from the most mainstream manga magazine in existence. It's a perfect storm of hate. Sort of like how yaoi-pandering hate and KyoAni hate combined to make Free! constantly shit on.
>>
>>100658907
It's just the troll target of the season because Space Dandy didn't garner enough interest. Notice how it's the exact thread posted almost every day.
>>
>>100658907
SHAFT haters insist that the mediocrity of the show has nothing to do with the original source material and blaming the studio for doing shit job.
SHAFTfag on the other hand argue that the manga is shit, and what SHAFT did is making it somewhat interesting with its quirk.
>>
>>100658893
With Shinbo as director...

I won't be surprised if he pulled some headtilts, overhead views, split frames, and all SHAFT-y stuff.
>>
>>100658959
>If I keep forcing it maybe someone will finally believe me.
>>
>>100658952
IRC are SHAFT fags?
>>
I'm enjoying it being shafted.
I dropped the manga around chapter fifty though, right when Onodera confesses and "whoops what was that I fell asleep for a second there" "It was nothing"
That is also the point I'll probably drop the anime too
>>
>>100657931

Noragami is the best one IMO
>>
>>100659032
You can expect them, coupled with EYES.
>>
>>100659023
>SHAFT haters insist that the mediocrity of the show has nothing to do with the original source material and blaming the studio for doing shit job.
The thing it, everyone agrees Nisekoi is generic. However that is not a minus for a lot of people and one of reasons its popular in first place.

JC Staff or A-1 would be able to make cut and fun generic anime like the dozens they do out of this, and seeing the manga popularity it would be success. Meanwhile Shaft managaed to make something that neither appeals to manga fans, nor Shaft fans.
>>
If by shit adaptions you mean a shit manga that Shaft is working their magic with, I agree.

Also
>Witch Craft Works anime
>good

FUCK OFF. Why would you even bother adapt something where one of the main attractions is the great art if all your artists/budget is dirt tier. I'm not expecting perfection but the adaption looks like generic trash.
>>
>>100659123
Same thiing happened with Negima and Natsu on Arashi before
>>
>>100659123
>and seeing the manga popularity it would be success
Good one, there was no way a nisekoi anime would be successful. Its readers wouldn't buy it in the first place.
See almost every other jump anime adaptation and its sales.
>>
File: 1388410861785.jpg (658.15 KB, 1745x1200)
658.15 KB
658.15 KB JPG
>>100657993
>Witchcraft Works adaptation
>good
>>
>>100659143
Did you even watch it beyond episode one? While the fight scenes may not be as hyperdetailed, it's very faithful to the source material and contains a lot of little bits any shittier adaptation would have skipped.
>>
>>100659123
>one of reasons its popular in first place.

Its only popular on a certain demographic where it was puglished. Most of /a/non over here just hope that the author cash in enough from this manga and start working on the project when he is done with this.
>>
>>100657931
I think Pupa is significantly better than Nisekoi. Because each episode is only 5 minutes instead of 25.
>>
>>100659123
You know trolls are getting desperate when they claim that JC Staff would make a good adaptation.
>>
>>100659143
>Witch Craft Works anime
>good
Implying its not. Thats shit tier trolling her. Its great and gets better with every episode. Just wait till things get real and Aya Hirano Weekend. WCW currently steadily grows on /a/, possibly turning out the most enjoyable show the season since we already know manga is good and waht to expect.

Meanwhile Nisekoi is just plain boring, since despite or because of Shinbo`s direction - it just fails to be fun or even tell consistent story. Everyone who read the manga would tell you how flat and wrong the first episodes of Nisekoi felt. It`ll only get worse.
>>
>>100658907
Welcome to /a/. Pick a studio and enjoy your retarded studio wars.
>>
>>100659195
But the art (manly, cheap budget flames effect) is the only problem in that adaptation.

That aside it has been almost a frame-to-frame reproduction so far.
>>
File: Shaft vs KyoAni.jpg (383.59 KB, 821x1616)
383.59 KB
383.59 KB JPG
>>100659300
how can I choose, they're both so wonderful!
>>
>>100657931
You forgot gin no saji
>>
Will i enjoy Nisekoi if i watch it without ever reading its source material?
>>
>>100659388
Probably more if you haven't realized yet what it is.
>>
File: licky lick.jpg (38.81 KB, 393x196)
38.81 KB
38.81 KB JPG
>>100659195
Except fire and Chronoire's tongue it's pretty good
>>
File: wcw.jpg (1.82 MB, 2279x1440)
1.82 MB
1.82 MB JPG
>>100659195
This troll again. I bet you dont even read the manga. Its GREAT adaptation. One of the best one could wish for - great characters adaptation, great direction, humor transmitted perfectly, nice art.

You`ll be hard to name which studio could have done it better.
>>
>>100659217
>Its only popular on a certain demographic where it was puglished.
The biggest manga magazine in Japan, read by more people than most of others combined, publishing few million copies weekly?
>>
>>100657931
>better than Nisekoi
i can't count how many anime those are better than Nisekoi
>>
>>100659281
JC Staff right now has two good adaptatios this season. Meanwhile SHAFT 0
>>
>>100659300
I like SHAFT, but i think SHAFT Nisekoi adaptatio is shit? What now?
>>
>>100659388
If you watch it exclusively for SHAFT visuals - yes. Otherwise if you liked the manga, ulikely.
>>
>>100659553
Are you seriously claiming that JC Staff is doing a good job with their cheap adaptations? You should get your delusions checked.
>>
>>100659505
Where the majority of the demographic is underage kids.
>>
>>100659630
well, it's better than SHAFT adaptation
>>
>>100659630
WCW is not cheap and quite well animated and good looking.

Golden Time is cheap in comparison, but its actually very good adaptation. Manga fags complained at begining about not using manga designs, but that complaint was gone as soon as people realized it actualy works good. Koko is a miracle.
>>
>>100659388
I don't think there is a way to enjoy Nisekoi. Maybe if you don't speak Japanese and turn off subtitles, you might not understand what's going on long enough to enjoy a few minutes, but ... nah, forget it. The clichés are too obvious. Maybe if you really like straight lines and patterns, you can just skip through the video and watch some stills.
>>
>>100659800
What is your exact buthurt with Nisekoi manga? That Double Arts was cancelled?

Nisekoi is typical long running romcom like Love Hina, Ranma, Hayate, School Rumble, whatever. It has great characters, nice humor and every cliche in a book (and yes, people WANT them).

It seems the buthurt stems from moronic shippers thinking its some kind of Amagami or other shit, while its episodic pure comedy. I wonder if people shitting on Nisekoi now would have troll School Rumble or Hayate same way when they aired.
>>
>>100659948
>I wonder if people shitting on Nisekoi now would have troll School Rumble or Hayate same way when they aired.
Are you seriously comparing Nisekoi to Hayate and SR? Both were a lot better in the comedy department. Also
>great characters
Oh come on.
>>
>>100659948
>What is your exact buthurt with Nisekoi manga? That Double Arts was cancelled?

No the author is butthurt over Double Arts being canceled and made Nisekoi to be generic as fuck to prove a point
>>
>>100659457
>that TN

Not even needlessly leaving a word in japanese and then translating it in a TN in the margin compares to my hatred for this kind of bullshit.
>>
>>100657993
>Golden Time

Golden Time is shit by itself, but the adaption is Sakurasou tier.
>>
The Nisekoi hate machine is 1 or 2 people who keep repeating the same shit every thread.

The manga isn't supposed to be taken seriously. It's a light comedy that you enjoy with barely a string if story arc to hold it all together.

That you autists can't have a little fun says more about Nisekoi then some anime adaptation.
>>
>>100660068
>No the author is butthurt over Double Arts being canceled and made Nisekoi to be generic as fuck to prove a point
[citation needed]
>>
>>100660068
Citation needed.
>>
>>100660157
But Sakurasou Adaptation was great production and direction wise? Its just that LN itself was complete ad pointless shit. Kinda like Town Where we rage (though TWWR suffered fate it deserved - adaptation by Gonzo)
>>
>>100660157
>Golden Time is shit by itself
Way to display your shit tast in public.
>>
>>100660157
This poster is having sexual relationship with a bird.
>>
>>100660276
>>100660235
You won't find any. It's just a portion of the retarded fanbases made up reason why Nisekoi is dogshit.
>>
Mekaku City Actors would be better done by Yamakan and Mari Okada. They did good job with BRS.

SHAFT likely to turn it into another pointless slideshow.
>>
>>100659366
Yep, both are shit, Trigger and A-1 Pictures are the new Shaft and Kyoani
>>
>>100657931
Except Nisekoi's adaptation is just fine.
>>
>>100660693
Yeah. No. Its like makig Lars von Trier adapt "Scrubs" into movie.
>>
I might drop it when the full harem kicks in, but until then I like it more than any of the shit you said was better.
>>
>>100660776
Stop it with the baseless hate, you're only making yourself look more stupid.
>>
>>100660868
As opposed to people that hate manga and preach that Shinbo "improved" Nisekoi?
>>
>>100660282
There was no direction nor great production. Just cirlcejerk over favourite character.
>>
>>100660793
Umh.. you are beyound help. I can only pity you.
>>
>>100660776
How about you prove that Nisekoi is a bad adaptation then?
>>
File: 1386471222179.png (563.08 KB, 867x766)
563.08 KB
563.08 KB PNG
>>100660932
>umh
>...
>beyound
I am the one pitying YOU, underage faggot. Why don't you FUCKING LURK MORE before trying to tell someone they have shit taste? You faggots just keep accumulating more every fucking year.
>>
>>100661057
oh irony
>>
>>100660938
People watching it for first time ask if its Bakemonogatari
>>
>>100661146
And that proves what exactly? Do you even have proof of such claims?
>>
>>100661146
Did you even read the manga?



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.