How many of these shows you have not watched?
all of them because i'm not autism
I haven't watched a single one of them because I have a brain and like to put it in good use when I watch my anime with engaging plots and not some 12 year old girls acting stupid.
is this chart supposed to be a joke?
none of this qualifies as patrician entertainment
try adding cowboy bebop, eva and tatami galaxy and maybe we'll talk
>Logh of galactic heroes
>Legend of galactic heroes of galactic heroes
Minami-ke, Kirino Mosaic and Ichigo.
Are they any good?
>endless eight for hipsters
9. Lots of boring SoL.
I've seen K-ON, Monster, Kaiji and the first season of Milky Holmes.
LoGH, Hidamari & Princess Tutu in my backlog. Aria I've picked up as a manga.
Great taste, my fine gentleman.
I tip off my hat to you, sir.
Kiniro Mosaic is shit. It really does not belong.
Spoken like a true pleb
>For 12 year old girls
A lot of people will call OP a trollpost but that's really the typical taste of a very high powerlevel viewer.
That's a pretty patrician joke you made there, by accident probably.
>hasn't seen Milky Holmes 2
Get on that shit nigga.
Also capitalise your I's.
>not enjoying one of the best shows of 2013
Looks like we've got some tossers among ourselves, lads
It's fairly standard for /a/nons, at least I'd hope it is.
It literally had 2 good episodes and everything else was complete generic and repetitive tripe. It's shit.
I couldn't make it past a single episode of kirino mosaic, I got to the part where they attempted to speak uhhn-gor-rish and I had to drop it.
Any of the SoL stuff, because SoL doesn't interest me at all.
But the Engrish was the most adorable part of the whole show.
Not when 1/3 of it is from the last 2 years.
Not even one
I'd actually be curious about what an "official" must see list by /a/ would contain, but I'm also afraid of finding out the exact tastes of the board.
Except a good few of those are not about some little girls "acting stupid"
At any rate, this essential "list" is shit. I might be biased however because I consider very few anime to be "essential".
Old anime sucks. It's not even in 720p.
A big log of shit
Dropped very, very hard
It started going stale at one point. Not sure if I dropped or what, though.
Dropped dropped dropped
Dropped. It was only good as a child.
Another hard dropper
Never heard of it, probably insta-drop material.
There was another series called aria which was completely unrelated. Someone told me to watch this aria and I only saw the first episode of the other aria before dropping hard.
Isn't it like shit or somethin'?
Monster, knt, kaiji, and logh are all great, but why knt and not the widely superior mushishi?
The person who made this chart probably hasn't seen LoGH and only added it to seem "refined"
What a fucking joke of a list.
I refuse to watch the yurishit on that list.
>Sora no Woto
>Not Tatami Galaxy
Almost 0 effort put into that crap. They had no budget so they repeated the same shit with 2 extra scene they swapped in and out and exactly one extra VA'd WORD CHANGED BETWEEN EPISODES. Not even a fucking line, a single fucking word.
>he thinks Endless Eight for hipsters was anything more than pretentious drivel
You're horrible. And awful. Horrawful.
I can more or less understand and agree to those, but how did Sora no Woto end up being best of 2010?
>Non Non Biyori
This is awful
>He couldn't keep up with the subtitles
>He think Sora no Woto was anything but a watered down Haibane Renmei with K-on designs.
>Never heard of it, probably insta-drop material
>let's make 9 nearly identical, repetitive, boring episodes just to drive home an underlying meaning that any otaku watching it already knows, and let's use an "artsy" visual style so otaku will eat it up and call it deep
>not literally the definition of pretentious
>let's make the viewer empathize with Yuki's suffering in order to frame the events of The Disappearance
>not a bold, genius decision with artistic merit
Is the second season really that much better?
Not that anon but I wasn't too impressed with the first season.
>anything that requires more than two brain cells is pretentious
If anything, the SoL stuff is far more pretentious.
This post is so incorrect. I know it's bait though.
Sora no Woto is Haibane Renmei done right. Trufax.
Its pretty damn good if you like funny retarded girls doing retarded things.
>Never heard of it, probably insta-drop material.
You are literally the worst kind of pleb I have ever witnessed in my life. Please leave and never return.
Because it's a charming, beautiful series about mankind's stubborn refusal to give up hope even in the worst of circumstances.
Gr8 B8 M8, I R8 It 8/8, No H8.
Can you please explain why you think Tatami Galaxy is bad, without using buzzwords like 'hipster' and 'pretentious'?
>all that plebeian, shit taste in here
You really don'tlike Yuasa do you?
>says the solhomo
Irony almost killing me.
More like essential P/a/shitrian core.
Undeniable proof of bad taste
No. It was absolutely appaling. I can't comprehend that anybody might like it.
You mean, plebei/a/n?
Too "pretentious" for them
You're right, I don't wear plaid flannel and thick-rimmed glasses whilst drinking PBR and listening to some local band you've probably never heard of.
Ive watched 1 episode of NNB and Kaji and LogH are on my backlog
red cross = did not watch
green hook = did watch
rest = read comments
>no SnK or KlK
what a shit list
I'm a little upset that some of these are included on a troll chart. CCS is the definitive magical series. Ichigo Mashimaro is the definitive cute girls doing cute things. A lot of these are genuinely great shows. I'm not sure what you're doing but you should be ashamed.
It is repetitive, poorly-paced, boring and tries too hard to seem deep when it is not.
>listening to some local band
How's that even a bad thing?
LOGH, Monster and Kaiji, they are all in my backlog though.
Great opinions, son.
Next time you should keep them to yourself, so it doesn't make you look like the total turbonewfag you are.
It is also creative, well-paced, entertaining, and presents all of it's themes extremely well.
That is not a criticism.
You gotta have at least a few things that are good for a troll chart to work, and either way some shows that the general, "Tell me what to watch dudes??!" will never like.
What do you mean, I'm already 18 years old.
Boring Shit. Dropped.
Still on my Backlog
Most beautiful anime of all time.
Most funny anime of all time
Most comfy anime of all time
>Havent watched, yet.
Good, but overrated. Story is nice, but Tenma got bring as a character over time.
Nice anime, cozy and had some good gags.
>Kino no Tabi
Again, good, but overrated. The morals and themes sometimes were just to trivial.
One of the funniest anime I know of. But got worse in the later seasons.
>Non Non Byouri
Average SoL show. Cozy yes, but rarely funny.
I liked it.
Not watched, yet.
Not watched, yet.
Watched S1. Average anime. Kamichu!, Mokke, Mushishi and Gingitsune are similiar but all better.
Dropped after Ep02. Not necessarily bad, but just not my taste.
I'm afraid your subjective opinion is objectively wrong.
>boring and tries too hard to seem deep when it is not
Very original way to write "pretentious".
How shocking, a show about a time loop is repetitive. And it's not even that repetitive, aside from the same general episode structure.
What do you mean by that? Too fast or too slow?
That's just you having ADHD.
>tries too hard to seem deep when it is not
It doesn't try hard to seem deep. It has a simple message conveyed in a unique and engaging way.
>implying there's any other kind
>get of load of this faggot
>Good, but overrated.
I see what you did there.
It's not a great troll chart when none of it is actually bad.
Besides Kiniro Mosaic, Milky Holmes, and YY.
I've only watched k-on and the reason is that i haven't seen more than 40 shows
Wow, this is worse than /mu/core
Protip: don't bother with TG fans, they have their heads way too deep in their collective ass
Any fan of Yuasa wroth their salt knows he has made way better original shows than adapting that bad novel.
Fucking stop this
When did you start watching anime and how many series are you following this season?
Comedy is what Yuasa is best at and it works amazingly in Tatami Galaxy, that is his roots.
Kemonozume is far worse.
Worst comparison. Tatami Galaxy isn't pretentious because everything is explained to the viewers. Haruhi is one of the most pretentious shows by one of the most pretentious studios. It tries to give the impression that it's super deep and intelligent when it actually isn't. It doesn't have anything to show or anything meaningful to say.
Tatami Galaxy has shit to back it up in the actual show, where as Haruhi everything is in TV tropes articles.
I just found TG a really fun watch with an unusual and interesting art style.
I don't see any of this supposed "2deep4u" shit you seem to be going on about.
This thread is cancer.
I've seen around half of the chart, rest is on my backlog.
A: You're pretty observant to recognize I'm the same guy.
B: Hey, man, I was actually really close. Pic related. When I made the image you're referring to, I wasn't putting my own tastes on it, you know. That was genuinely my attempt to represent what I perceived to be the average tastes of /a/ as a collective. As pic related shows, I think I did a pretty good job.
not a single one
not really in to moe
Oh yeah, let me twist your argument so you come out as a dumbass and me as the superior and more intelligent poster, by pointing out how my narrow point of view is what dictates what shows are good and which aren't.
Top tier comment.
I liked Non Non Biyori but Yuyshiki was dull and Kiniro was average and bland.
i started 1 and a half year ago but i've been watching almost 3 times as much for the last half years this season i'm following some 8 but i will probable only finish half of them
OK, you got me, I laughed.
There's nothing deep about TG. Anyone who says it is deep is either so retarded they think it is deep, so paranoid of being called pretentious they're over-sensitive to unusual stuff or they're just some retard trying to make /a/ hate it.
Are you implying you did anything different with your comment? Are you implying you somehow have an enlightened wide point of view?
Only four of the series on that list are actually good. I'll leave to guess which ones.
>No Rose of Versailles
You have no right to call yourself a patrician.
I called it a bad novel. The deep word, was an adjective to describe someone's ass.
I did the exact same thing you did.
I'm just letting you know, that's not how counterarguments work and that you should stop making stuff up just because you think TG is better than his other works.
AKB is garbage. YYS is boring. Kiniro is gratingly annoying. NNB is actually good, but you don't like it because it's good, you just like it because it has cute girls in it despite it being good. You'll eat up any dogshit as long as it has moe girls and SoL in it.
Okay, first off capitalize properly. Second, drop down to 5 series tops this season that you know you'll finish and start marathoning older anime when you have the time.
2/10, actually replied
>I called it a bad novel
But we're discussing the anime, not the novel.
Why exactly is it bad?
>inb4 hipster, pretentious etc
I liked NNB because it was the best, most consistently excellently-executed SoL since Aria, but you know, keep projecting and all.
>causal as fuck taste right there
My guess is that you have subpar taste.
Nothing I said was made up, his roots are in comedy. He began with Shin-chan and some Doraemon.
If you think I'm gonna put any more work into my counterargument than you did in your original argument, you are very mistaken.
actually seen all of them except holmes
>Actually putting princess tutu on a troll chart
Why would you do that, OP?
>No Galaxy Express 999
>No Space Battleship Yamato
>No Serial Experiments Lain
>No Tatami Galaxy
>No Rozen Maiden
>No Hokuto no Ken
>No Cromartie High School
>No Haibane Renmei
>No Ghost in the Shell
I may look past all this but
Shit chart, fuck off plebian.
Why did you like all of that other garbage, then?
That's not what projecting means, you fucking retard. Projecting is when one PROJECTS their viewpoints onto others. If I liked things solely because they had cute girls in them and I was assuming you did for no basis, I would be PROJECTING myself onto you, thus the term. But I don't. Stop using words you don't know the meaning of, it makes it even more apparent that you're a retard. But then again, you like AKB, YYS, and Kiniro so we already knew that anyway.
Not too sure why Evangelion isn't on that list.
Also NNB is fucking shit. It just happens to have a very vocal fanbase who spam polls with 'NON NON STRONK' and all that bullshit to fluff up its nonexistent popularity.
The creator probably actually believes he is correct
LoGH, Tutu, Monster, Kaiji?
>Dropped. It was only good as a child.
Shit taste to the max.
Not that guy but
>NNB is actually good, but you don't like it because it's good, you just like it because it has cute girls in it despite it being good.
>you just like it because it has cute girls in it despite it being good.
>you just like it because it has cute girls in it despite it being good.
>you just like it because it has cute girls in it despite it being good.
What exactly were you doing there?
>well my grammar sucks I can't change that also most series haven't released more than three episodes so I have hard to chose which to drop also it's really hard to find which old series that are the best you got any good list of which is great?
Haha, what a newfag, right guys?
But really, patrician is as buzzword a term as you can get around here.
You do realize all of the endless 8 were animated from scratch just like all the other episodes right? They contain the same events but in different order, with different camera angles, different apparel, ect. It had nothing to do with budget, endless 8 happened in the LN as well
11/12 because that chart mixes genres and taste.
>Why did you like all of that other garbage, then?
I didn't like AKB; that image is the results of a poll.
Yuyushiki was incredibly unique and charming in its natural depiction of friendship and perfect blend of comedy and iyashikei.
Kiniro Mosaic was close to moe distilled into its purest form. There's not a lot more to it than that, admittedly, but then again there wasn't anything really stand-out that entire season.
Actually a decent chart, could be better but whatever.
>Endless Eight for hipsters
Immediately disregarded. Any time I see an AOTY chart I look straight to 2010. If I see Endless Eight for hipsters I close the image, knowing its creator has too low of a powerlevel to recognize pretentious drivel when he sees it.
I don't know about TG but he's right on the mark with E8
Troll list, but anyway
K-ON: it took a while to get used to that art style and when I grew to like it from seeing it on /a/ so many times it already ended so maybe one day.
LoGH: too long.
Tutu: doesn't look interesting to me.
Monster: doesn't look interesting to me.
Kiniro: backlog, waiting for the last BD.
Kino: doesn't look interesting to me.
Minami-ke: don't like the art style, which is important for SoL.
NNB: don't like the art style.
Kaiji: doesn't look interesting to me.
CCS: doesn't look interesting to me.
Natsume: I prefer girls, thank you.
Aria: don't like the art style.
>OP mixes genres
Are you serious? He lists like 10 slice of life shows.
Disappearance was the movie.
There was no endless 8 in the movie.
How has no one noticed that?
Does yuyushiki get better after the first few eps.
I dropped it after the second episode when they just spent a minute saying "wander" or some shit.
Yeah, and I hate most SoL. Hence why I've only seen one of them, Kaji and LoGH are in my backlog though, I'll get to LoGH after Macross.
Yeah, it does.
All of them except for Kaiji.
I'm trying to get to them, slowly but surely.
I dunno, why he's comparing them. The only similarity is a time loop, they're both executed very differently.
2/10 I replied.
>Tutu: doesn't look interesting to me.
Why are there still people that post on /a/ and have not watch that show?
>tfw can only recognize 8 of them
Soon, I have my own backlog to finish then I might watch one of these depending on the mood.
I am surely not the only one, considering how many series exists is hard to watch them all.
>Natsume: I prefer girls, thank you.
It's good regardless
>Aria: don't like the art style.
Shit taste right here.
>LoGH: too long.
True, but you have to admit it's literally the only flaw of this series.
Since when has Haruhi even pretended to be deep, where are you getting this accusation from?
Akira isn't actually a good movie.
Just read the manga.
No anon, you are the pretentious drivel.
I have only watched tow of them,the rest are crap.
Organize those folders properly anon.
>not sure why Evangelion isn't on the list
Maybe because EVA was made before 2002?
Cardcaptors Sakura is the only thing that I've watched from that list.
And more importantly, I don't care, and I'm not in the least interested in the others.
>A reverse trap going on adventures with her talking motorcycle and revolvers doesn't look interesting to me.
All of them.
Only watch what sounds like it has an interesting plot
I watched 3 animes last year
This is my monthly /a/ visit
How does this thread have replies?
eh I wasted 2 hours watching worse things (like Martial Hearts, fucking hell), it cant be worse than that.
Like how? I dont have many of them those are all there are, except Moe with some subfolders, I usually watch and delete.
Put your movies into folders, and set all the icons right.
Then make a backlog and a completed folder and sort them.
Tatami Galaxy is 'Endless Eight for hipsters' according to that misguided anon.
Watched three, dropped one, because I'm a mangafag.
Don't forget the animation and style changes, or the outdated technology from the 70's.
Now here's a list I can get behind
Nope and nope.
Agree with 2013.
But I think it's dumb how there are people on /a/ who think AOTY is some kind of objective thing.
As a huge Sherlock Holmes fag, on a scale of 1/10, how much can I possibly enjoy Milky Holmes?
Wats 2000, 2001, 2003, 2005, 2006, and 2009?
Seen K-on, logh, Monster, Kino no tabi, Kaiji, CCS. Enjoyed them all. I'll get round to the others someday.
>02-04 will never happen again.
>and set all the icons right
I want to have them all in the same style, I downloaded those from that guy roaming /a/ in a single pack and he didnt have...all those I am missing so I would not know what to do now for I wish to keep the same style.
Do I really need order? They are so few that with a glance and memory I remember it all.
There is nothing that I need to look for, althought I agree about the icons.
>People like this have posted their opinions in this thread.
>As a huge Sherlock Holmes fag
From that point of view, 0/10
>As a huge[...]fag
0 because MH has nothing to do with detectives.
Your liking of Holmes will most likely not affect your enjoyment of the series since it's mostly just namesake references and it's more of a comedy than a detective series.
Also, what did you think of those two semi-new Sherlock movies?
Then I'll gladly avoid it. Thanks anons.
Ah, I see.
>all they do is drink tea
>all they do is drink tea (and alcohol, in moderation of course)
If you like one, you'll like the other. Both anime have a tight pack of friends too, and they like to party.
Fuck, we should make a tea-core chart and put stuff like you've hyouge mono
Go download the rest then.
I would suggest order. At least just put your movies into their own folder so you can set their icons at least.
>Putting new shit on a chart
It doesn't matter how much you like a show, you don't put it on a list when it's less than a year old. Putting something like LoGH on a chart next to NNB is ridiculous not because of taste but because one of them has clearly stood the test of time and the other ended a fucking month ago.
It has some references, so maybe a bit.
From all of those I've only watched Monster... Should I watch the other ones? Are they really good? (Kinda new here)
Having K-On! and IM on the same chart (even if you're shitposting) is redundant since the latter does cute girls doing cute things much, much better.
Yeah, I bet they all head to bed before 9 too. Gotta rise and shine early in the day and capture democratic planets day by day.
You mean the ones with RDJ and Jude Law?
They're enjoyable as action movies, but not as enjoyable if you take it as a Sherlock Holmes movie.
I like RDJ and all but his portrayal of Holmes is not one of my favorites. Holmes is supposed to be a dick, but also a gentleman (which is why I don't like that autistic version of Cumberbatch's). The whole movie felt like Tony Stark - Detective edition..
>being this new
>(and alcohol, in moderation of course)
Can I abandon a friend?
Johnathan dies, there, no need to watch it now. Lirk more little shitstain.
That's not a very well-rounded chart. Out of that whole list I'd only recommend LoGH, Tutu, Kino, Kaiji and CCS.
The rest are mostly SOLs although Minami, Aria and Ichigo stands out. Then there are shows that are literally 'hilariously bad' e.g. Milky Holmes. Pick your poison.
That's pretty neat.
You wouldn't recommend Natsume?
It's one of the few shoujo series I'd consider legitimately good.
>The rest are mostly SOLs
Is that supposed to be an insult?
Nice trolling there.
Thanks, I'm gonna watch those then. Apparently people here don't like new members haha
I downloaded the january 17 pack and not a single icon for anything I have. I could understand if it was something obscure but nope.
>Logh of Galactic Heroes
>Legend of the Galactic Heroes of Galactic Heroes
>i am just pretending to be retarded.
>not shit mazinger
I'm sorry, but you fucked up son.
Ironically it make 2013 look like a good year.
WHY THE FUCK IS MONSTER EVEN THERE WHAT
>silently leave /a/
11/16 are from 2005-2013 alone
Glad to help! /a/'s elitism is pretty shallow to be honest, you can find plenty of help in the midst of discussion threads like these.
But shit mazinger is shit.
>not yamato 2199
such shit taste
>raging over a troll chart
Did you download a diff pack or the full pack? Because I do not believe for a second that in the pack of thousands of icons there were no matches.
>why don't they take the bait?
>1974 and 2012 are the same year
It's a remake for faggots who can't digest the original because of their newfaggotry.
Not that it's bad but it's not original content and it would be better to leave the AOTY place to something original. Plus, it discourages newfags from watching the original.
oh I see, I am downloading the full one now.
If you're like me, who's too retarded to use Photoshop to make a chart. What would it be about if you made one and what would you put in it?
I'd make a Noir-core chart. I'd put Darker than Black season 1 in it, Jiraishin manga, Sanctuary manga, and Noir, to start off. Of course I'd ask /a/ for suggestions for more titles.
None of them because I don't watch Chinese girl cartoons.
its a better animeted, more coherent version. Making someone watch the old version just because its old is stupid.
Do you even know what Kino no Tabi is, newfag?
good job on automatic assumption
>just because it's old
Are you pretending to be retarded? You should always watch the original of anything.
>Making someone watch the old version just because its old is stupid.
Not because it's old but because it's good. If you can't appreciate the original, well I feel bad for you.
Also, don't use Rumia for shit like that please, I'm pretty sure she wouldn't like it.
>FMA is better than Brotherhood
Thats what you sound like
Ritsu is best girl
But brotherhood is the original there.
In the case of FMA, the original would be the manga, or brotherhood, which is an adaption of the original manga. Try not to be stupid.
f-fine, I wont use her like that. I wasnt attacking the series, I'm just saying, if the remake is faithful enough (which it is, as I have seen both) There isn't much wrong with an updated version.q
That is actually a good list. Somebody who hasn't been into the genre for a while would hate all the slice of life and DEEP shit on there.
But the original FMA is the manga.
The original, first incarnation of Yamato is the 1974 anime.
>But shit mazinger is shit
Oh my Allah. What a fucking pleb you are.
/Yeah, but there's way too much SoL shit there. The substitution of masterpieces like Azumanga for seasonal cutesy shit like Kiniro and NNB is a travesty.
>I'm just saying, if the remake is faithful enough
Why not both?
> isn't it like shit or somethin'
This. Hyouka is AOTY though.
Those years had better anime.
the original poster who started this argument berated the series as being "for newfags" when it was just a remake that was updated to look like it wasn't made in a bygone era. I'm saying there's nothing wrong with watching the remake.
The only one I have watched is LoGH.
How come The Melancholy of whatshername isn't on that list?
>Sora no Woto above disappearance
>Non Non Boring
That's not true. Jinrui, Uchouten, Katanagatari, Tatami Galaxy will be remembered as well as those earlier AOTYs.
Why do people keep forcing this piece of shit anime? Its easily the shittiest anime on that list.
>everything is all fine and well
>all of a sudden, episode 51
What the fuck, guys? I didn't ask for PTSD!
Jesus fucking christ.
>2 anime from 2013
That should prove that this list is shit.
How dumb do you have to be to not see how tongue in cheek that statement was?
>the original poster who started this argument berated the series as being "for newfags"
I was the original poster. I just thought a remake is not suit for AOTY place no matter how good, we should give another anime that offers some original content that place if possible.
Also it easily can discourage newfags from watching the original, I liked 2199 but /a/ is too reluctant to try anything pre-90's as well as anything with over 27 episodes.
If a condensed one cour Galaxy Express 999 remake would ever happen, I doubt anyone would bother watching the original, despite /a/ being the less shitty corner of the internet when it comes to discussing anime, it could use expanding it's powerlevel a little.
Nichijou male or female version is better than ichigo
11 out of 16. Cool list actually. My favorite one is probably Natsume.
Yeah, those are pretty fun.
K-On is better because it has more cake
>/a/ is too reluctant to try anything pre-90's as well as anything with over 27 episodes.
I'm going to start Gundam soon