[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: worstadaptation.jpg (120.38 KB, 1100x786)
120.38 KB
120.38 KB JPG
>Worst direction of the season
>Worst adaptation from a manga of the season
>Best variety of music of the season
>>
File: ep02_146.jpg (45.93 KB, 346x296)
45.93 KB
45.93 KB JPG
I don't think it's nearly as bad as everyone says it is.
>>
>>100523448
just trolling
>>
>>100523380
>Worst direction of the season
That's not CoD: Magical Warfare.
>>
Is it opposite day?

The adaptation is the only good thing about it, the source material is fucking abominable.
>>
File: Screenshotfromthattrick.png (751.32 KB, 1280x800)
751.32 KB
751.32 KB PNG
>>100523556
90% of the episode was this kind of shot
>>
>>100523617
>adaptation is the only good thing about it
Did you read the manga? It is funny. Did you see the anime? It's not.
>>
I haven't read Nisekoi, but I imagine it isn't any better than this shitty adaption makes it out to be.
I still haven't decided whether or not Shafts fucking shafting hurts or helps it, though.

How long is this one planning to run, anyways? Isn't the manga long as shit and still ongoing?
>>
>>100523676
>implying that's not top-tier scene composition
>>
>>100523380
Are we talking about Nisekoi?

Sure, it's a nonsense OP.
>>
File: 1967478747374.png (617.75 KB, 1280x800)
617.75 KB
617.75 KB PNG
>>100523729
It can be cool once or twice but not all the fucking episode.

Also what happens with that guy at the left's face?
>>
The people who are hating on the Nisekoi adaptations are either ignorant or staunch mangafags who still think that Nisekoi the manga isn't just a shitty generic romance with an obnoxious fanbase. Face it, Shinbo actually made this show watchable. If he had done a frame-by-frame adaptation of this shit we would've ended up with J.C.Staff-tier garbage. Instead, he turned something utterly generic and ironically filled it with so many tropes that it is turning out to be one of the best shows this season. The art, the delicious voice from KanaHana and the ClariS OP make this show a potential masterpiece.

I predict that this show will be as good, if not outright better, than its *Monogatari predecessors.
>>
File: 1344922346240.png (34.34 KB, 213x292)
34.34 KB
34.34 KB PNG
>>100523972
>ClariS OP
>>
File: chitoge1.gif (2.74 MB, 409x230)
2.74 MB
2.74 MB GIF
It's nice to see a show witch such a nice comedy timing.

It's several steps ahead of the manga. Just imagine a studio would try to turn the lastest episode into drama.
>>
>>100524029
Well, at least the off-vocal version is gonna be good
>>
>>100523972
>ironically filled it with so many tropes
And that wasn't the manga? And then it kind of fell over the edge and stopped being ironic.
>>
File: 1381433115683.png (189.83 KB, 512x512)
189.83 KB
189.83 KB PNG
>>100523720
>I haven't read Nisekoi
>it isn't any better than this shitty adaption
>haven't read Nisekoi
>shitty adaption
>>
>>100523972
You can't be serious. The manga has the "false relationship" cliche basis but the anime has it too, so don't complain about it. The story of the manga is good and makes you forget about how cliche it is while the anime is just moemoe shots of the girls and general shots of the scene. If that doesn't bore you, it's because you are not human.
>>
>>100523972
>I predict that this show will be as good, if not outright better, than its *Monogatari predecessors.
Amazing.
>>
>>100523720
I'm of the view that Shaft always improves things in the adaptation. Not always enough to make it good, but always at least better than the source.
>>
>>100524140
It is an adaption, and it is shitty.

That's how I was using that. I can understand your confusion though, as it was open to misunderstandings.
>>
File: 1390010403355.gif (295.43 KB, 700x704)
295.43 KB
295.43 KB GIF
>>100524172
>moemoe shots
What?
>>
>>100524210
>Natsu no Arashi
>>
File: 19876784396845.png (539.17 KB, 1280x800)
539.17 KB
539.17 KB PNG
>>100524234
this
>>
>>100524210
They turn most of the stuff to something unique, so people still talking SZS or Arakawa and all the other shows om /a/.
While the lastest JC Staff adapatation is already forgotten two weeks after the last episode.

The Nisekoi nailed the light-hearted feeling of the first manga chapters perfectly.
It's like "they got it" and we can only hope the Shaft staff can conservate this feeling longer than the original.
>>
>>100524314
Who are you quoting? Just "Natsu no Arashi" would've been just fine. What was the point?
>>
>>100523676

90% of all Shaft shows is this shot.
>>
>>100524314
>even the mangaka says the anime is better
>>
>>100524172
>moemoe shots

Do you drink those out of a loli's bellybutton?
>>
>>100524403
And it's a very bland one.
>>
>>100524342
She's smiling.
>>
Anyone updated the Shaft's VA image?
>>
File: e001.12.jpg (121.75 KB, 728x1093)
121.75 KB
121.75 KB JPG
>>100524138
Not the guy you are replying to, but Nisekoi had a very original one-shot before the editors told the author to sell-out and turn it into a rom-com.

Shinbo is mostly being deliberate with those tropes. In episode one, for example, Chitoge held a piece of toast in her mouth (a well known trope used since Evangelion) while the manga did not have that. In fact the head-tilts and the SHAFT style is so distinct and obvious that you know Shinbo is trying to parody and reference instead of adding references for the sake of it.
>>
>>100524504
>(a well known trope used since Evangelion)

We have an expert here.
>>
>>100524549
Not to mention
>mangahere
and
>mangafox
Two in one special here.
>>
File: 1387361763512.jpg (26.77 KB, 300x300)
26.77 KB
26.77 KB JPG
>>100524504
>>
The two Nisekoi episodes prove. You can have the most generic plot ever. If you deliever it on the point, it's still entertaining.

It's not about being self-aware or doing a parody. It's just doing a good job.
>>
>>100524504
>(a well known trope used since Evangelion)
I could have agreed with your point if you were not a raging moron.
>>
>>100524314
One very good example of Shaft improving something.

>>100524355
Indeed. People here complain a lot about some of his habits in his directing, but Shinbo Akiyuki really is a talented director. Plus most importantly he loves what he does, and has fun making anime, which always helps in making an entertaining show.
>>
>>100524971
Wow calm down there. You'd better explain what you are talking instead of replying with a handy ad hominem.
>>
>>100523380
I somehow liked Chitoge in the manga but she is kinda shit now that they animate her crap.
>>
>>100523972
>I predict that this show will be as good, if not outright better, than its *Monogatari predecessors.

How to spot a troll pasta.
>>
>>100524504
> (a well known trope used since Evangelion)
Whats with all the troll posts.
Some people are incredibly determined to shitpost in threads about certain series.
>>
>>100523380
Should I bother with the mango? Is Onodera going to win?
>>
File: ep02_145.jpg (176.92 KB, 1280x720)
176.92 KB
176.92 KB JPG
>>100527743
It was pretty obvious before it even aired that the anime threads would be shitposted to hell and back.
>>
>>100527790
>Should I bother with the mango?

No, not if you can get the superior anime. Maybe after the anime.

>Is Onodera going to win?

heh
>>
>>100527821
>heh
So it's a no? She'll be happy though right?
>>
>>100523972
well i think, it will more watchable with JCstaff adaptation
this adaptation is too shit
>>
Show gives me Arakawa vibes.

Though Naoyuki Tatsuwa did barely something for Arakawa.
>>
It's a pattern with SHAFT. As much as people tend to fellate them (and especially Shinbo), their track record over the past 3-4 years has been uneven at best.
>>
>>100523972
JC Staff has done some good stuff, but I agree that anybody but Shinbo/Shaft wouldn't have been able to give any life to Nisekoi.

I don't know about Nisekoi being better than Monogatari though. I guess I'll just have to be patient and see.
>>
File: 1374869874416.png (83.74 KB, 308x765)
83.74 KB
83.74 KB PNG
>2014
>being J.C. Staff hater

Anyways, even though Nicekoi may be not nearly as good as MM!, Toradora or Seto no Hanayome, but as a combo of these shows Nicekoi is ok. At least I definitely will keep watching.



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.