[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


Anime saved tier:
Wake up girls!

Anime Unsaved tier:
Wizzard Barristers

God tier:
Chu2
Nagi no Asukara
Golden Time
Inari KonKon

Great tier:
Zvezda
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Noragami
D-Frag!
Nourin
Seitokai Yakuindomo*
Witch Craft Works
Sakura Trick

Ok tier:
Tonari no Seki-kun
Gin no Saji 2nd
Kill La Kill
Nobunagun
Saikin, Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga.

Meh tier:
Buddy Complex
Nobunaga the Fool
Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta
Space☆Dandy

Shit tier:
Sonico
Homotora
Hoozuki no Reitetsu
Mahou Sensou
Nisekoi
Pupa
>>
File: 1389850648448.gif (21.63 KB, 360x180)
21.63 KB
21.63 KB GIF
Mad fags with bad taste incomming
>>
rate my blog
>>
is nisekoi bad? so far i watched the first episode and like it.
>>
>>100400163
Bad manga? No.
Bad adaptation? Yes.
Enjoyable if you just swallow Shinbo-shit and dont care about manga? Yes.
>>
ITT niggers post shit lists to get reactions

Wake up girls is SHIT
>>
>>100400239
Well done, nigger.
>>
Oh, it's you again. Isn't your list slightly different?
>>
>>100400281
Of course, impression of the shows changes as season progresses. Its not set in stone.
>>
>>100400210

I'm curious what was wrong with the first episode?
>>
>shit tier
>Mahou Sensou
Eeehhh
Granted i've not watched the second episode yet but this looked like it had great potential. I quite enjoyed the first episode.
>>
>>100400355
You are a tripfag so no wonder you have the shittiest taste on this board.
>>
>>100400210
I read it and I watch it, it's better in anime.
Also
>God tier:Chu2
That explain, into the trash, here we go.
>>
>Anime saved tier
Sakura Trick

>God tier
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Nagi no Asukara

>Great Tier
Nisekoi
Chuu22
Golden Time

>OK Tier
Noragami
SoniAni

>Meh Tier
Sekai Seifuku
Magical Warfare

>Dropped Tier
Everything else
>>
ZX Ignition gonna be da best, calling it now
>>
>>100400163
Thread is done by the one Nisekoi thread troll.

If you're lucky he will tell you how much better Sakura Trick is as Shaft show.
>>
>>100400587
>how much better Sakura Trick is as Shaft show.
Implying this is not corret. Both No-Rin and Sakura Trick are better "Shaft" shows this season than Nisekoi
>>
>Good/Fun-tier
Space Dandy
Tonari no Seki-kun
D-Frag
Nobunagun

>Decent/promising-tier
Sakura Trick
Hoozuki no Reitetsu
Wake Up! Girls

>Mediocre-tier
Nourin
Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha
Go! Go! 575

>Bad-tier
Super Sonico The Animation
Nisekoi

>The sewers are all muddied with a thousand lonely suicides over how shitty this is-tier
Pupa
>>
Good/Enjoyable:
Noragami
D-Frag
Loliquest
KLK

Okay:
Chuu2
SYD 2

Disliked:
Nisekoi
Pupa
WCW
>>
>>100400024
I fixed your list since you have no taste what so ever and are probably just b8'ing replies by shitposting like that.

God tier:
Zvezda
Gin no Saji 2nd
Tonari no Seki-kun
Sakura Trick

Great tier:
Noragami
D-Frag!
Seitokai Yakuindomo*
Inari KonKon
Nisekoi
Nobunagun

Ok tier:
Chu2
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Nourin

Meh tier:
Nobunaga the Fool
Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta
Space☆Dandy
Wake up girls!
Homotora
Wizzard Barristers

Shit tier:
Sonico
Hoozuki no Reitetsu
Mahou Sensou
Pupa
Buddy Complex
Witch Craft Works
Saikin, Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga.
>>
God Tier:
D-Frag!

Great Tier:
Chuu2
Nourin

OK Tier:
Nobunagun

Yes, I am really late this season. I intend to rush everything else on this weekend.
>>
>>100400928
says the guy with a shittiest taste so far. Are you /b/astard?
>>
File: Spoiler Image (73.66 KB, 818x419)
73.66 KB
73.66 KB PNG
>>100400928
>Nisekoi
>great
No anon, you are the b8.
>>
>>100400994
yamada-kun anime when?
>>
>>100401296
Soon, hopefully.
>>
Eternal top of the list tier
>Space Bros

Can't wait for next week tier
>Seki-kun
>Wizard Barristers

Okay tier
>WUG
>Space Dandy
>Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta

Dropped
>SoniAni
>poopa
>Chuu2 2

Trolled again tier
>Sailor Moon
>>
File: gold.jpg (197.62 KB, 1277x714)
197.62 KB
197.62 KB JPG
So far I've enjoyed:
Tonari no Seki-kun (Short of the Year)
D-Frag
Strange+
Witch Craft Works
Noragami
>>
what's wrong with nisekoi?
>>
>>100401338
Not by SHAFT too, hopefully.

Trailer was by Liden Films and looked great. Also still waiting for Denpa Kyoushi by A-1 and full Assassin Classroom
>>
>>100401633
There's nothing wrong with it, it's a pretty perfect adaptation, people are just butthurt about shaft in general, nothing new.
>>
>>100401633
It is killed by Shinbo direction and unnecessary unfitting shaft "style", would be better done by A-1 and JC staff.

Saint Young Men > Arakawa
Negima by Xebec > Negima?! by Shaft
School Rumble > Natsu no Arashi
Kyouran Kazoku Family > Sasami
Katanagatari > Bakemonogatari
K-On! > Hidamai (same magazine, while K-On manga was garbage in comparison)
Joshiraku > SZS
Dazle > Maria Holic
Drakuriot/Strike the Blood > Dance in Vampire Bund
>>
>>100401633
Everything. It's painfully generic and irritating. There were so many cliches in the first episode that I thought this is suppose to be a parody. But no, it plays them completely straight.
>>
>>100401670
You really have shit taste if you think its an ok adaptation.
>>
>>100401720
what was bad with the adaption in particular?
>>
>>100401724
You've clearly not read the manga. It's painfully generic an irritating in the source, why the hell should they change anything about it?
>>
>>100401837
Bad direction in particular, subpar adaptations of relevant scenes like kneekick, mafia confrontations, animal farm. Scenes seems detached in style and direction, not fitting together creating contrieved impression - while actual plot is straightforward and simple in manga. Shitty animation, SHAFT backgrounds, terrible color scheme.

WCW looks like it has more budged and quality than Nisekoi this season...

Just look at Yamada-kun trailer, HenNeko, WCW, OreShura etc and realize why Nisekoi adaptation is shit.

Its Negima vs Negima?! all over again
>>
File: 1354151831633.gif (2.74 MB, 300x169)
2.74 MB
2.74 MB GIF
>>100401720
>would be better done by JC staff.
>>
>>100401837
>replying to a pasta
>>
>>100401963
JC Staff makes a better looking and directed adaptation this season. While two other studios make better "shaft" style shows than actual SHAFT.
>>
Anime saved tier:
Wizard Barristers

Watching tier:
Kill la Kill
Sakura Trick
Saki
Chuuni Ren

Not watching at the moment tier:
The rest
>>
>>100401967
>still being in denial pretending Nisekoi adaptation is ok
Its Maria Holic, Denpa Onna, Sasami deja-vu. Die hard SHAFT post gatari newfags deny obvious until theres simply no room for argument and then pretend the show never aired.
>>
>>100401952
>WCW
>GOOD ADAPTATION
HOLY SHIT, NOW I'M FUCKING LEGIT MAD.
YOU ARE A FUCKING RETARD WITH NO TASTE WHAT SO EVER.
DID YOU EVEN FUCKING READ THE WCW MANGA AND THEN WATCH THE ANIME? THEY BUTCHERED THE SHIT LIKE THERE'S NO FUCKING TOMORROW. IT WAS DOWNRIGHT BAD FUCKING EVERYWHERE, FROM ANIMATION TO VOICE ACTING TO FUCKING COPYING THE PLOT FROM THE MANGA. JUST LOOK AT THIS SHIT. LOOK AT IT. DID YOU SEE THIS FUCKING SCENE IN THE MANGA? THIS ALONE IS REASON ENOUGH TO BOYCOTT THAT FUCKING TRASHY KOREAN LOVING COMPANY THAT JC STAFF IS.
FUCK OFF BACK TO #SIZTRA YOU FUCKING SHIT EATER.
>>
>>100402076
>Anime saved tier:
>Wizard Barristers
It is unsaving anime, by bringing out all the worst in it - mindless action, shameless fanservice, slut characters and edgy gore and rape.

Not that we are not enjoying it.
>>
>>100401952
You seem to be hating Nisekoi for being Nisekoi, not because it's being animated. Everything you've said that you don't like about it is taken straight from the manga, what else would you expect?
>>
File: wcw.jpg (1.82 MB, 2279x1440)
1.82 MB
1.82 MB JPG
>>100402130
You are retard. Its great adaptation. Try harder next time, everyone simply ignores you in WCW topics by now. You probably did not even read the manga.
>>
>>100402215
The opposite. I dont dislike Nisekoi, i am disappointed it got animated by studio like SHAFT. Its generic like shit yes, but its its main appeal.

I would not want School Rumble (guh Natsu no Arashi...), Ranma, Kenichi, or any similar manga slaugthered by shaft (wonder how anyone even gives them manga adaptations after Negima and NnA).

Meanwhile i would not mind likes of Yumekuri adapted by them for example
>>
File: superteatime.png (1.06 MB, 1278x716)
1.06 MB
1.06 MB PNG
Anime is saved tier:
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei

God Tier:
Noragami
Nagi no Asukara
Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta

Good Tier:
Golden Time
Chu2-2
Inari Konkon Koi Iroha

Wait and See Tier:
Mahou Sensou
D-Frag

Literally Shit Tier:
ImoCho
Wake up Girls!

Haven't seen it yet Tier:
All the other shit
>>
>>100402285
What makes you think I'm even in WCW topics? I've dropped this shitty adaptation after the first episode due to how horribly executed it was, I have no reason to watch a manga I like being butchered by a low tier studio.
>>
>>100402130
IRC please go and stay go.
>>
>>100402378
Wrong episode and wrong scene m8. Try harder.
>>
Watching Tier:
Chuu2 Ren

It was the only thing that I found interesting mainly because I'm a sucker for moe and cutesie shit.
Any recommendations within my tastes?
>>
>>100402369
So a troll basically, thanks for admitting.
>>
>>100402418
Nisekoi
>>
>>100402634
Mikakunin
>>
>>100401720
>Negima by Xebec > Negima?! by Shaft
>Joshiraku > SZS

0/10
>>
>>100402172
Except the action isn't mindless, the fanservice isn't shameless and the sluts are great.
>>
AOTS:
Sekai Seifuku

Having a blast watching:
PuPiPo!
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren
Gin no Saji 2nd Season
Kill la Kill
Nobunagun
Noragami
Seitokai Yakuindomo*
Onee-chan ga Kita!
D-Frag!
Hamatora
Robot Girls Z
Sakura Trick
No-Rin
Hozuki no Reitetsu
Tonari no Seki-kun
SoniAni - SUPER SONICO THE ANIMATION

God damn it, Umetsu:
Wizard Baristas

Three episode rule:
Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha

Watching for the trainwreck value only:
Pupa

Watching for the SHAFT value only:
Nisekoi

Dropped for now, in the order of the most to least likely to pick up again:
Engaged to the Unidentified
Space Dandy
Witch Craft Works
ImoCho

Biggest number of entertaining shows in years.

10/10 anime is saved.
>>
>>100402378
>>100402425
Yup, sure thing IRC.

Lets ignore how people who actually read the manga replied to the anime when it originally aired.

>>99434739
>All that bad CGI

>>99434853
>Is it just me or were the scene changes really abrupt?

>>99440521
>JC Staff
>Adaption

>>99441169
>MC is way too tall in the anime. What the hell?

>>99478374
>I'm not too happy about CG in the first episode. The rabbits looked fine to be fair but if they keep up the CG then that'd suck since the battles were the good part of the manga.

>>99479685
>author's probably insanely pissed off
>fucking dogakobo shouldve pick WCW up instead of JShit Stuff


And this is just the tip of the iceberg, the first few threads about the anime are non stop complaining about how JC Staff butchered the adaptation.
>>
>>100402912
IRC attempts to troll WCW is cute. Especially considering it`ll likely grow to one of the largest show this season in a few episodes once plot kicks in.
>>
>>100402912
Both JC Staff shows this season, WCW and GT are great. WCW has noticably larger budget at that. SHAFT simply cant handle such show even technically - since cant animate for shit. Can you imagine Railgun by SHAFT?
>>
>>100402912
I'd just like to say I didn't read the manga and I also thought the adaptation was shit. One of JC Staff's worst.

I don't understand how people can not have a problem with it.
>>
File: 1389677680209.gif (1.98 MB, 206x720)
1.98 MB
1.98 MB GIF
>>100403100
Please be original at least. Samefagging only brings you that far.
>>
File: 1389124970016.png (42.22 KB, 286x398)
42.22 KB
42.22 KB PNG
>>100403019
>grow to one of the largest show this season in a few episodes once plot kicks in
This isn't Sekai Seifuku, Noragami, Tokyo Ravens, Nisekoi or Wake Up, Girls! No one's even going to remember it a few seasons later.
>>
>>100403100
I did read the manga, and you are either trolling or genuine idiot.
>>
>>100403193
Uh, is anyone even watching Tokyo Ravens?
>>
File: Untitled.png (74.42 KB, 1401x505)
74.42 KB
74.42 KB PNG
>>100403192
No, try harder.
>>
>>100401720
>Joshiraku > SZS

No.
>>
>>100403193
Tokyo Ravens and Strike the Blood faded away already to no come back.

Seikai Seifuku - will see how it develops. Its original work that hyped a lot, but no guarantee so far it will be actually great.

Noragami is Bones and meh manga, so despite great quality it`d fade instead of growing by default.

>Nisekoi
>plot kicks in
hah

Wug does not need to grow, its already saving anime.
>>
>>100403265
Nice edit.
>>
>>100403264
Judging from the threads a lot of people are.
>>
>>100403321
Maybe if you have pleb taste that enjoys Shitbo quirks more than source manga humour.
>>
>>100403355
That's what I mean, I didn't see a lot of them. But I'm not on /a/ 24/7 so eh.
>>
File: Wastelands.jpg (75.57 KB, 200x764)
75.57 KB
75.57 KB JPG
>ALERT
Corrected Chart
>ALERT

Anime is saved tier:

God Tier:

Good Tier:

Meh Tier:
>Winter Season

Shit Tier:
>Honourable Mention: Wake Up Girls!
Really guys, stop hyping this shit
>>
>God tier
Sakura Trick
>Good tier
Space Dandy
Tonari no Seki-kun
Onee-chan ga Kita
Noragami
Chuunibyou 2
Gin no Saji 2
Inari Konkon
Hamatora
The Pilot's Love Song
>OK tier
D-Frag!
Nobunaga the Fool
Nisekoi
>Shit tier
Hoozuki no Reitetsu
Pupa
>Haven't watched yet tier
Wake Up Girls!
Nobunagun
Wizard Barristers
Sekai Seifuku
Witch Craft Works
>>
What's all this about WCW not following the manga? I read the manga and the anime seems on point to me. Actually
>>100402130
>TO FUCKING COPYING THE PLOT FROM THE MANGA

Wait, so we wanted an anime original plot now? I'm confused. Is this show getting trolled by retards? Because this is some really weak trolling compared to what happened to Bakemonogatari.
>>
>>100403594
>not wanting invisible trumpets by the best studio for anime adaptations
get taste bro
>>
Shit tier:
Chu2
Nagi no Asukara
Golden Time
Inari KonKon

meh tier:
Zvezda
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Noragami
D-Frag!
Nourin
Seitokai Yakuindomo*
Witch Craft Works
Sakura Trick

good tier:
Tonari no Seki-kun
Gin no Saji 2nd
Kill La Kill
Nobunagun
Saikin, Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga.

great tier:
Buddy Complex
Nobunaga the Fool
Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta
Space☆Dandy

God tier:
Sonico
Homotora
Hoozuki no Reitetsu
Mahou Sensou
Nisekoi
Pupa
>>
>>100403926
I see what you did there, but your taste is still shit.
>>
If Nisekoi and WCW were done by the other's production companies, they would BOTH be rolling in huge amounts of money. Guessing the mangaka for nisekoi just gave in to his greed when he heard SHAFT's name being dropped.
>>
File: yokoi.jpg (35.18 KB, 386x707)
35.18 KB
35.18 KB JPG
>>100400024
such bad taste, like the white trash of anime audiences.
>>
>>100404020
I agree on Nisekoi, but which other studio would do WCW better?

Madhouse bombs this season with Mahou Sensou. A-1 would be pretty much same as JC Staff. Production IG, given nice budget, could probably do better fire effects but thats it. In terms of adaptation and direction WCW is pretty spot on.
>>
>>100404020
>Implying Shaft isn't going to roll in money from Nisekoi
>>
>>100404153
Feel free to correct it where you think its wrong.
>>
>>100404157
Like it did with Negime, amiright?
>>
>>100404302
Like JC Staff did with everything that isn't a butchered adaptation of Raildex.
>>
God tier:
Wake up girls!

Great tier:
Nobunagun
Wizard Barristers
Nourin
Seitokai Yakuindomo*
Witch Craft Works
Sakura Trick

Ok tier:
Zvezda
D-Frag!
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Sonico
Saikin, Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga.

Meh tier:
Nobunaga the Fool
Space☆Dandy
Nisekoi


Shit tier:
Mahou Sensou
Pupa
Space☆Dandy
>>
God tier:
Wake up girls!

Great tier:
Nobunagun
Wizard Barristers
Nourin
Seitokai Yakuindomo*
Witch Craft Works
Sakura Trick

Ok tier:
Zvezda
D-Frag!
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Sonico
Saikin, Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga.

Meh tier:
Nobunaga the Fool
Nisekoi


Shit tier:
Mahou Sensou
Pupa
Space☆Dandy
>>
>Shit tier
>Hoozuki no Reitetsu

Are you a dumb faggot?
>>
>>100404664
Aside from OP, its litterally the dumbest show only newfags can unironically enjoy. Shit that was done 100 times and better.
>>
>Actually good shows this season
Sakura Trick
Zvezda
>I have to watch it because shaft
Nisekoi

There is literally nothing else good this season.
>>
File: T213986123.jpg (177.27 KB, 1280x720)
177.27 KB
177.27 KB JPG
(Yay; Nay)

Heavenly Hash:

Tonari no Seki-kun (beautifully appropriate opening/closing and a direct manga adaptation as far as the 2nd Ep., expressive voice actress; devilishly short at ~7 min)

Log Horizon (for the unadulterated JRPG/DQ influence; noob storyarc is tosh; more complex characters have taken backseat recently, mass generic CGI enemies seriously detracts yet works as in a VG, lack of global political intrigue)


Ham & Cheese:

Samurai Flamenco (another ordinary-superhero archetype which shifts into semi-enjoyable WTF high gear in imitation of the waning tokusatsu genre, quirky gadget weapons, ordinary cop foil creates ethereal dream-like contrast, references to Western super hero comic characters; plot escalates into hilarity and nonsensical quibbling From Beyond--Hazama must be a Mittyesque figure, strange narrative choices and plot devices)

Nobunagun (SFX makes grand percussive debut, powerful OST, background art style, obtuse humor; 'epic' shading for additional drama, wallpaper pattern infill, mass generic CGI enemies make for boring cannon fodder, strange characterizations)
>>
>>100404814
>There is literally nothing else good this season.
You are litterally the dumbest shitposter on /a/
>>
>God tier
Tonari no Seki-kun
Chuu22
SYD*
Nagi no Askuara

>Great tier
Wake Up, Girls
Sekai Seifuku
Kill la Kill

>Good tier
Wizard Barristers
Golden Time
Log Horizon

>On the fence tier
D-Frag
Buddy Complex
Nobunaga the Fool

>Shit tier but I'm still watching it for some reason
Samurai Flamenco

I really don't know about D-Frag though. Part of me wants to drop it but I don't know what I would be missing out on since I usually really like those kinds of shows
>>
Still watching:

Seitokai Yakuindoimo
Space ☆ Dandy
Noragami
Tonari no Seki-kun
Nobunagun
Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta
D-Frag!
Wooser no Sono Higurashi Kakusei Hen
Hamatora
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren
Onee-chan ga Kita
Sakura Trick
Houzuki no Reitetsu
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
Wake Up, Girls!
Nisekoi
Wizard Barristers ~ Benmashi Cecil
Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha
Sekai Seifuku ~ Bouryaku no Zvezda ~

Dropped:

Mahou Sensou
Pupa
Nourin
Witch Craft Works
Nobunaga the Fool
Buddy Complex
>>
Enjoying the most:
Noragami
Yowamushi Pedal S2

Good, but also the potential to go really horribly:
Hamatora

I watch this to be entertained:
Samurai Flamenco
Log Horizon
Kuroko no Basuke S2
Gundam Build Fighters

I don't really know why I watch this:
Kill la Kill
Space Dandy

Dropped Shit:
Pupa
Sonico
D-Frag
Mahou Sensou
Nobunaga The Fool
>>
>>100404892
>Samurai Flamenco
>Hating the only anime with an actual plot
>>
>>100405017
>Nourin
Why? It's pretty funny. Judging by the rest of your picks I'd think you should be able to enjoy it.

Did you drop it at the opening scene or something?
>>
>>100405100
Didn't like the MC
>>
>>100405042
I don't really know if you can call Samflam a coherent plot. Things just seem to be happening and everyone goes along with it. There was even a dick beam in two episodes ago. Or was that last episode? I forgot.
>>
File: 1374050540909.jpg (131.61 KB, 1280x720)
131.61 KB
131.61 KB JPG
>the shaft animation is the only part of nisekoi that makes me like it

it's lonely having good taste over here. also tsundere a shit.
>>
>>100403926
Hoozuki was unfunny garbage.
>>
>>100400755
New addition since I just finished S1 of Seitokai Yakuindomo and watched the two episodes that came out this season.

>God-tier
SYD*
>>
>>100405230
>Shaft
>Animation

I want you to take a minute to reflect on what you just said.
>>
>>100405289
>am I fitting in yet?
>>
>>100405597
>am i fitting in yet?



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.