[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: magical-warfare.jpg (115.38 KB, 600x793)
115.38 KB
115.38 KB JPG
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2014-01-16/even-magical-warfare-original-creator-didnt-think-the-anime-was-a-good-idea

Not even the author likes Mahou Sensou.
>>
>I think there are other good works. Don't do it.'"
Even the author now his LN is a bundle of cliches and there's a thousand more well written works more deserving of being animated.

Honestly, he's not wrong. And when even the author itself says something like this you know there's something fundamentally wrong in how these things are handled.
>>
It kind of seems like he was forced to write something he didn't want to
>>
Episode 2 6 mins to go
At least we have Nano ed song

http://dec.2chan.net/18/res/24687203.htm

Stream=usual place
>>
>"I feel like I've been jabbed with a bamboo sword"
>>
>"I feel like I've been jabbed with a bamboo sword"

My sides.
>>
>>100356767
>I wanted to make easy money ripping-off characters but I didn't want to be exposed, now the anime made it obvious that I'm a shit writer, baw.
This faggot is gonna have a hard time working in the industry again, the publishers aren't going to approve that he said specially when they are spending money to promote the LN.
>>
>author knows his novels are complete utter shit
>for some reason Madhouse decides to animate them

Madhouse are fucking retarded.
>>
File: (゜Д゜).jpg (15.39 KB, 350x234)
15.39 KB
15.39 KB JPG
>As for his favorite characters, Suzuki chooses Mui ("she's just easy to write")
C'mon, at least pretend you actually care about what you do.
>>
>>100357657
You are retarded, it's not Madhouse who decides to animate material but publisher of LN.
Madhouse is just contracted animation studio
Same with No game no life and Mahouka
>>
>>100357770
Madhouse could have said no.
>>
So what exactly makes it so terrible?

I've only watched the first episode of the manga and yeah it's overly generic, but what's with the huge criticism?
>>
File: 2427.png (1.40 MB, 1280x720)
1.40 MB
1.40 MB PNG
The first episode was just full of cliches it wasn't that bad, Lets see what 2nd episode is, Least we know it'll be a happy ending.
>>
>>100357794
Why would they? They get cash for work.
>>
>>100357794
You answered your own question pal.
>>
>>100357794
>Resisting Kadokawa/Dengeki money
Who would say no anyway?
They are in the brink of financial problem so they had to get money somewhere.
>>
I read thread on animesuki few days ago and here some spoilers:
-MC's brother, Gekkou becomes magician and is pretty much main villain
-Kurumi madly loves MC and hates other men " Men besides Takeshi should go extinct."
-MC loves Kurumi
-Mui fall for him too
-Kurumi is dying at the end of 6th volume 7th isn't out yet
>>
Ohh yeah well, FUCK that author. Im going to like it in spite of him. AOTY. That will show him.
>>
>>100357950
who is kurumi again
>>
>>100357998
not!Saber
>>
>>100357887

Very generic source material combined with the adaptation rushing through an entire volume of material in one episode (normally anime goes through that amount of material in 5-6 episodes).
>>
I was already thinking about dropping this the moment the girl almost shot the MC in the face because she fell out of bed on top of him. It didn't help when the MC used a bamboo sword to block a huge steel sword, complete with the sound of metal on metal clashing.
I sort of thought there may be some Valvrave-tier stupid fun here, or at least when watching this with /a/, but I guess not.
>>
>>100356767
>"since it's a magical girl story."
>haremshit targeted at chuuni faggots
Yeah, no.
>>
>>100356767
Is that notGilgamesh?
>>
>>100358082
It's like he doesn't give a fuck about anything, at all. No wonder it's so fucking generic and uninspired.
>>
>>100357957
Oh fuck you, stop liking my series
>>
>>100357887
Generic as fuck, the LN wasn't intricate to begin with but the anime isn't even bothering trying to make sense of the shit.Plus the characters and setting makes it look like a weak F/SN parody that will turn into a porno any second.
>>
>>100358077
>It didn't help when the MC used a bamboo sword to block a huge steel sword, complete with the sound of metal on metal clashing.
The fight was stupid but I thought it at the very least looked nice.
>>
File: 1389890701317.jpg (59.04 KB, 1440x810)
59.04 KB
59.04 KB JPG
Oh so not-Gil had an imouto?
>>
I wanted to like it up until SUDDENLY, EVERYONE GETS MAGIC. It was just so uninspired.
>>
Maybe he was like Naoshi, wanting to write something like Double Arts but they forced him to write something like Nisekoi instead.
>>
>>100357950
>MC loves Kurumi
Are you trying to trick me again?

MC actually fall for childhood friend?
>>
File: 1317025091993.jpg (19.04 KB, 500x500)
19.04 KB
19.04 KB JPG
I wonder how it feels to work hard on a series and then have the anime version flop because of QUALITY or bad directing.
>>
>>100358283

Yes he does. Kurumi is the main heroine but not the main girl.
>>
>>100358292
I think most would just be glad that they can see their creation animated
>>
>>100358283
And apparently, she dies. And notShana probably wins. Dammit Japan
>>
>>100358292
The novels were always complete shit.

This isn't about the adaptation being bad.
>>
>>100358292
>work hard
Have you read parts of the source material? It's dire and generic looking, you could say 'He still worked hard even though he's done a poor job' but just look at the reason for his favorite character:'..Well it's easy to write her'.
>>
>>100358292
>He feels that the anime is fairly interesting, though, and is surprised at how much they have been able to do with the material.
Author seems to be fine with the adaption, just confused why it got one in the first place.
>>
>>100358352
I'd say it's relative and depending on the person. Honestly, I'd prefer to not have anything than be given a shittily made something.
>>
>>100358292
;_;
>>
>>100358352
Even if it was Tsukihime-tier?
>>
>>100358439
This looked good.
JC staff later apoligised for their retarded choices
>>
>>100358485
>JC staff later apoligised for their retarded choices
[citation needed]
>>
>>100358455
Japan likes it, only the west hates it
>>
>>100358439
But the midriff and vagina bones was godtier
>>
>>100358075
That was a good call from part of madhouse, the whole start of the LN is slow as shit and they crammed it up in 1 episode, that's a smart move.
>>
>>100358510
Look in the archive or google
Director apologised for going to much into "moe"
>>
Somehow this will sell 20k+ and become the next raildex.
>>
>>100358525
I thought they didn't like the Fate anime hence the remake? How could they enjoy an even worse adaption when both would have the similar audience?
>>
>>100358663
>Director apologised for going to much into "moe"
But not for absolutely raping the story? Then his apology matters a shit.
>>
>>100358439

Fuck, please don't remind me.
>>
I'm going to like it and not even the author can't stop me.
>>
>>100358568
gg pls
>>
>>100358722
This is what he meant
>>
>>100358784
can*
>>
>>100358784
Can it being irredeemably shit stop you?
>>
>>100358803
I don't see how invisible trumpets are moe but whatever. At least he knows he fucked up even if he said it retardedly.
>>
>>100358803
>says x
>but he really meant y!
>>
Kaname when, we need sane persone here
>>
>>100358844
If it's as generic as people said, there's no way it will be "irredeemably shit" right. At most people will say its not memorable at all, generic and other standard stuff.
>>
>>100356767
Wait this is an adaptation? I thought this was an original new anime because of how ripoff the characters are.
>>
>>100358784
Me too, it doesn't matter how bad and generic is the writing if there is fights and magic it's a must watch for me (except if it's a shitty fanservice show like Zero no Tsukaima, I don't bother with them).
>>
File: 1369000745426.jpg (15.07 KB, 373x309)
15.07 KB
15.07 KB JPG
>author acknowledges it's shit
>it will sell high anyways
>>
Wait, does this mean that it's not even in "so bad it's good" territory? Is it just trite bullshit?
>>
>>100359454
Respect for the death, yo.
>>
>>100360005
It means you can't read
>>
The story might be shit, but author of LN draws delicious girl.
I can get behind that.
>>
File: 1389836019099.jpg (285.91 KB, 1920x1511)
285.91 KB
285.91 KB JPG
>>
>>100362537
LOOK AT THOSE BOOBS
>>
>>100359620
>*8. *9,932 **9,932 Mahou Sensou Vol.7

Not really.
>>
I feel bad for the author.
It's painfully obvious he didn''t want to write this.
>Suzuki also revealed that the project started when Shinbashi "encouraged" him to write about magical girls.
>Suzuki chooses Mui ("she's just easy to write")
>Shinbashi notes that he answered "disinterestedly."
I really hope this flop so he can start working on something else.
>>
>>100364195
If the anime succeed,you can wait for 30k or more
>>
First episode was better than I expected. Not gonna drop a show just because the author himself admits its dumb, that's follower mentality.
>>
>>100365919
>author himself admits its dumb
Actually the whole conversation was about Author sarcasm about anime, that he feel disappointed why they decide to change everything for original source, thus he said "being jabbed by bambo sword". He himself never think his work as dumb.
>>
>>100364372
>about magical girls.
>MC is male
>not even a trap
>it's a harem
>>
>>100366419
Two girl aren't a harem



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.