[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: konata1.jpg (89 KB, 704x396)
89 KB
89 KB JPG
So /a/, what do you hate more? LS or GL? No plot or stupid plot that's often mistaken as deep? Moeblobs or Garmasses?
>>
LUCKY SHIT IS SHIT
>>
I like both
>>
More importantly, I hate you.
>>
I like both
>>
Hate them both.
>>
I like LS.
>>
Like both, LS more than GL. Idon't need deep, philosophical bullshit. Just lolis and explosions
>>
They're both fine. I probably enjoyed Lucky Star a bit more, though.
>>
I like both. Although I'm a much bigger fan of Gurren Lagann.
>>
I'll go on record and declare Gurren-Lagann as anything but mindless, completely incomparable to GaoGaiGar or the like. The show is that of a strong opinion, one carried by an unflinching speech. The delivery of a multi-layered meaningful assertion is the ultimate objective, a carefully calculated achievement towards an "altered state of mind".
The narrative strips a media swallowed down by purposeless plot convulsion from unnecessary fluff and successfully intertwines in a concrete shape of unyielding palpability what is commonly recognized as separate: argument, theme and symbolism take a single. From the depths of nostalgia the forgotten but powerful voice of honest beliefs surfaces within a technique of representation built over naked, yet fundamental, ideas. In more than one way this essential notion behind the storytelling is deliberately old-fashioned yet actively forward-looking.

Stagnation, mindless progress and the very nature of human "evolution"; with a manifest yet subtle use of imagery such an abstraction becomes core for the script. They're amazingly broad, basically limitless, yet due to their handling tangible enough to be substantial. Textually knitted into the actual writing without even resorting to term dropping; eloquently described through a seamless combination of visuals, dialogs and raw feelings.
>>
>stupid plot
So Utena's director and Ashita no Joe's mangaka are untalented hacks who don't know what they're talking about?

Where do you get off saying a comment like that?
>>
>>10027717

Bitches don't know what "seinen" means.
>>
>>10027867


Even from the very first episode, the attributed core theme is unconcealed to the eyes; enclosed tightly into the premise behind Kamina's constant claims of a "burning youth" breaking through a "ceiling" towards an idealized heaven of freedom. The physical "ceiling" keeping Jeeha village in the underground is just allegoric of a limitation decided by "those that came before"; a literary reiteration that outlines the complete creative purpose. Something that could be called a "youth chained by the foolishness of their ancestors" if you wanted to be dramatic.

From the same episode, we are presented with the "burden of responsibility". The Elder states it clearly: "I'm not taking care of you orphans because I want to! It's because I'm the elder and it's my task to ensure the future of this village."

It's simple, yet very eloquent. A piece of brilliant characterization.
>>
I like both. Of course, zealot fans from both sides are almost equally annoying. I find GLfags in general more annoying.
>>
What's with the people claiming over-analyzation?
From what I've seen, they were internally consistent and supported by quotes and examples. It also fits together and makes a lot of sense. So, really, people going "lulz you can overanalyze anything" confuse me. Maybe they just don't know how to analyze such things as literature, movies, or other entertainment mediums, and instantly assume that anything involving the catching of subtle points leading to a larger theme (which is essential if you know anything about writing themes into a novel/movie/animation series) to be "over-doing" it?
>>
sage for faggot
>>
>>10027874
How do you feel about Lucky Star Cirno?
>>
>>10027923
It's okay. I hated the first few episodes, and I didn't like it as it went on. But a few of the scenes, especially with Anime Tenchou, made me laugh.

I'm generally not a fan of slice of life.
>>
The arguments for GL have been internally consistent, and uses quotes and examples to support it.
I also find these analyzations to be well formed, in general, taking advantage of the smaller (yet not insignificant in any way) moments to drive the point home. It's something everyone should get through their first play through.
>>
Both shows became exponentially worse as they progressed, but Lucky Star always had Lucky Channel, which redeemed the show as a whole at the end.
>>
>>10027988
The phrase you're looking for is "I liked each show less and less as they progressed."
>>
>>10027988

My personal enjoyment is determinative of actual quality.
>>
>>10028004
Yes, but that's because they became worse.
>>
I liked LS

I don't want to watch GL because I might like that too
>>
>>10028046
No they didn't. You just liked them less. Quit speaking as if your opinion is fact. You are perfectly capable of hating a good show.
>>
>>10028004
You're such a fucking douche, you know. You'd be a douche even if you could pull a intelligent opinion out of you lardy NEET poo-poo-hole. Douchebag.
>>
>>10028046

And how do they became worse?
>>
>>10028060
My opinion IS fact!
>>
>>10028064

>douche

I lol'd.
>>
>>10028069
>>10028067

Then expect yourself to be flamed on 4Chan.
>>
>>10028043
My personal enjoyment is the only thing that matter
>>
>>10028064
The phrase you're looking for is "I think you're a douche."
>>
I find GL to be an incredibly fun show.
>>
>>10027988
>>10028004
Much like Lewis Black, this anon just wanted to be able to use the term exponentially in an every day sentence.
>>
make this thread end
sage
>>
10/10, OP
>>
LS is too shitty.
>>
Don't ever fucking use the term "Garmasses" again. Do you know how hard it is to be GAR? Its one thing to ravage a few women and become a man but to reach the next level while bench pressing a truck and listening to "The Final Countdown" is no small feat. How dare you insult the few truly GAR people left on this planet by trying to make being GAR sound like something generic. Becoming GAR is a very difficult and grueling process. I am beginning to doubt you are even a male. GAR is a very deep and complex thing. It should never be compared to something as simple and one dimensional as moe. The only type of person who can possibly fail to grasp this concept is an ignorant housewife that bakes cookies all day thus contributing to world obesity. I would gladly tend to your lonely vagina if you really are an ignorant housewife, thrusting my Pillsbury cookie dough rod into the experienced heat of your oven until you forget all about your oppressive husband.

...
>>
GL = GREAT animation and good plot. Over-analyzed by ratarded and annoying fanboys (GLfags). Fanbase : gaiafags, ANNfags, narutards and a part of /a/ users.

LS = you know, comedy with otaku and culture references, a little hard to understand (like pani poni dash). Fanbase: moeblob lovers (FAP) and some gaia/narutofan fags (LOL TIMOTEI, KAWAII GIF ^_______^).

I like both, but i prefer LS.
>>
>>10028234
failure
>>
>>10028398
So they're BOTH shit.
>>
>>10028398
>Over-analyzed by ratarded and annoying fanboys
Again, /a/ posters calling the Utena director and Ashita no Joe's creator "Retarded."

What makes your opinion more valid than theirs? Prove it.
>>
>>10028422

yes, but i can fap to LS cast over and over.
>>
>>10028444

What's sad is the retarded and annoying fanboys don't realize what they are =/
>>
>>10028213

It's because of that special that I use that word. His show is premairing the day before my B-Day. I'm stoked.
>>
I love most of the moeblob faggotry out there. However, I find Lucky Star a terrible show, and GL an excellent show.
>>
>>10028444

i dont give a shit about directors or that screencap.

THE fans re retarded, not the director or the anime.
>>
>>10028523

fuck off GLfag.
>>
>>10028444
They're not calling the creators retarded, they're calling the fanboys retarded. aka you, Cirno.
>>
Don't ever say GL is meaningless. Not because it isn't, but because you'll attract Cirno.
>>
>>10028578
>>10028563
>>10028523

0/10
>>
>>10028563
But my point is that the fans aren't over-analysing anything. It's all laid out right in front of you. If it's being over-analysed, then it should be very easy for you to prove.

My other point was that if you're saying the fans are over-analysing the show, then so are Utena's director and Ashita no Joe's creator.
>>
It seems like we've gone back in time. What is happening here?

Actually, SOMEONE PULL THE PLUG QUICK, WE CAN STOP NEWFAG SUMMER BEFORE IT RUINS THE FUTURE.
>>
lucky star
>>
LS > GL

Stop with the LS and GL troll threads. nao.



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.