[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: Mui Aiba.jpg (126.74 KB, 1280x720)
126.74 KB
126.74 KB JPG
Why is Mahou Sensou getting so much hate to the point that minority are saying is the worst anime of this year?
>>
>>100224160
They mostly complain about the animation
>>
At first I thought she turned him into a wizard by kissing him and I was ready to be upset by how WRONG that was.

But then Tits McGee and Gilgamesh and it's just being exposed to magic makes you magic oh okay then
>>
It's generic and very bland. The MC being super strong out of nowhere with a bamboo sword against some guy with a giant sword reeks of stupid. Heroine even though she's supposed to be a magician was pretty much useless.

It doesn't get worst award though. Worst is Pupa.
>>
>worst anime of this year
That's not Pupa.

Anyway
>MC has a girlfriend
>this other girl falls on top of him, almost kiss
>she will fall in love with him too
No.

>practice sword (bamboo) deflects fuckhuge (metal) sword
Double no.
>>
It's not good but it's certainly not the worst. I'll give it the 3 episode rule. Worst of the season is probably Buddy Complex or WCW.
>>
This is shit just like Nisekoi and half the shows that aired so far.
>>
It's a generic as fuck shonen and idiots picked it up thinking it wouldn't be.
>>
Good for them that Pupa exists.
>>
>>100224289
>This is shit just like Nisekoi
Are you fucking retarded?
>>
>>100224310
No. It's mediocre and bland just like Nisekoi. Actually, no i'm sorry, Nisekoi is worse, the only redeeming thing in this is that is made by Shaft.
>>
>>100224310
I HAVE THE KEY
NO I DON'T
NO YOU DON'T I DO

JOKES ON YOU, THIS GIRL WHO HAS NEVER APPEARED UNTIL NOW IS THE ONE WITH THE REAL KEY
>>
>>100224349
Your post implied that the anime were similar in terms of story, characters, art, etc. You should've jsut said it's as bland as Nisekoi.
>>
>>100224304
>>100224268
>>100224263
I haven't gotten around to Pupa yet but holy shit is it really that bad? I kind of had hopes for this I hope you all just have shit taste or something or I'm going to be really let down.
>>
I like how they didn't even bother hiding themselves and talk about magic and whatnot while people are out there hunting them down.

Bamboo sword clashing with steel blade produces a metallic sound, I didn't know that too.
>>
I suppose some people are still butthurt that madhouse is adapting this kind of material.

>>100224263
You learn that if you use attack magic in normal world against other mages it bites you in the ass, so she couldn't do much. I agree the bamboo sword part was pretty silly, but i guess it can't be helped. Superior nippon wood and all that.
>>
>>100224404
>holy shit is it really that bad?
Literally the ONLY thing it has going for it is it does what it's supposed to.

It's so fucking shit, though. Literally makes no sense, garbage characters, censored to hell, garbage art and animation, and the fucking voices weren't even in sync with the animation.
>>
>>100224387
Oh. I'm sorry then, my mistake.
>>
>>100224404
It should be renamed to
>How can an anime that's only four minutes long be this terrible?
If you read the manga at all, it pretty much goes like this
>Hi onii-chan
>Butterflies kukuku
>Onii-chan am I kawaii?
>Blood-C level censoring
>The end

I wish I could say I was exaggerating. It's like a worse version of Blood-C but condensed.
>>
>>100224263
>>100224268
>>100224304
>>100224404
Pupa is at least original, even if it was terrible. Also, Pupa is just a 4 minute short.
>>
>>100224358
the manga is like. Oh this must the the girl ! BAM fuck you here meet a new girl. Ok then this girl is the one BAM ! Nope here another new girl. Then this time she MUST be the one BAM ! New girl mother fucker
>>
Come on guys at least it's not bamboo sword cutting through a broadsword
>>
File: 1386212246388.gif (184.40 KB, 297x168)
184.40 KB
184.40 KB GIF
>>100224619
>>
The fight was stupid but I liked it. I thought it looked nice.
>>
>>100224639
Now shop the katana into a kendo stick.
>>
>>100224483
>Blood-C level censoring

Sounds like it should be fun.
>>
Mui is so fucking delicious, but I can't quite tell why. At the moment, only watching this because of her.

>Why is Mahou Sensou getting so much hate
First episode had so much fucking stuff shoved into it, re-used animation, a lot made little sense, villains were pretty bland, and bamboo lasting against a giant sword.
>>
>>100224759
It's worse than that, 80% of the screen is blacked out.
>>
I'm going to give it a chance. It's not especially bad, but it's generic so far.
>>
File: 1385589008881.jpg (37.47 KB, 475x352)
37.47 KB
37.47 KB JPG
Three episode rule.
>>
>>100224527
Seriously? Is that how Nisekoi is? Guess I'm going to drop it.
>>
>>100224160
I do not know. The only negative I saw in it was that the first episode was convoluted. I think its probably manga or novel fags that come here and shit up every thread with spoilers.
>>
File: 2426.png (1.11 MB, 1280x720)
1.11 MB
1.11 MB PNG
Cliched and bad first episode.
>>
>>100225573
>Implying it can be spoiled
>Implying it won't be predictable as shit
>>
>>100225573
>the first episode was convoluted
Considering that convoluted mess is the only thing with which the anime is being judged so far, it makes sense that some people consider it the worst show of the season.
>>
>>100225595

How edgy. He's gonna be a bad guy right?
>>
>>100225701
Well it was a bit more convoluted than normal but I think its possible that the worst is over. We will have to see with the next episode.
>>
>>100225573
You didn't see bamboo blocks massive sword as a negative?
>>
It was a cliche after cliche mess. Nothing felt natural and the character's responses and actions were mostly illogical and inappropriate for the situation they were in.
>>
Because we were tricked into thinking it would be the new Shana.

Instead we get shitty animation, fail fanservice with cowtitmagic-girl, a plot that is impossible to take seriously if you have any braincells, and the main NOT only not being a TsundeRie, but even manages to have the shittiest voice ever.
>>
File: 1340165184563.jpg (103 KB, 1280x720)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
I can't support an anime that disrespects my Kingu with a shitty rip-off.
>>
File: 1242741204846.jpg (27.72 KB, 440x336)
27.72 KB
27.72 KB JPG
>>100224160
>infodumping
>bamboo is strongest material known to man
>shoot all perverts
>don't react to gun in face
>wizard tuberculosis
>stupid wizards hurting themselves when they know the rules about attacking other wizards in the real world
>stupid wizards spreading wizard tuberculosis when they know the rules about attacking kids in the real world
>"You're a wizard, Harry!"
>and so are your friends
>now all aboard the Hogwarts Express so you can meet all your new classmates and never return back to a normal life ever again without going through pain so bad you pass out
>>
Eh,
I found it entertaining at least.

But there was some points that just seemed retarded.
Bamboo lasted far too long against a metal sword. You could reason that maybe he only blocked along the flat side or something, but it's ridiculous regardless.
Then there's how those two were fucking retarded, using magic, thereby giving those guys magic, and then losing their own. What is this?

I can accept to some degree that the MC's power let him be a badass with a sword. But beyond that, it was ridiculous. I'll be watching this for a couple more episodes, and make a judgement by then.
>>
>>100226229
This, plus

>script literally feels like it was written by an early teenager
>>
This season has too many wizards.
>>
>>100226480
I've already had enough of wizards from last year's disappointing Kamen Rider. I don't want to go through a bunch more lacklustre magic shows.
>>
>>100225945
No, why would I? Do you even have any idea how hard wood is? A dull smashing blade like that wont go through with one hit unless the sword was secured at both ends. Do you even physics?
>>
Well this guy goes of with a rant

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OpQGA0ebU_U
>>
The show is generic and predictable, but at least it looks really nice. That alone makes it better than half the shows airing right now.
>>
>>100226842
I hope you're not implying Noragami looks bad.
>>
>>100224160
Writing was a mess, almost Valvrave level, with the difference this wasn't a mess in a funny way.

I mean, is an urban fantasy light novel adaptation so you can expect trophes but the rushed way it happened made it specially annoying.

And all that exposition, is as if a teenage was explaining you his idea for a new original anime instead of an actual anime.
>>
Well, they had to air something to make the rest of this season's trash look good, like WCW.
>>
>>100226422
Also

>No point in all the infodump because that rules doesn't apply in the other world
>Becoming a mage is not a drama when you can stop being one any moment attacking other mage.
>>
>>100226957
Valvrave wasnt funny. It was dropped.
>>
>>100226999

>WCW
>Trash

No
>>
>>100226765
I see you never actually played with bamboo shoots as a kid, and the point is that the blade would cut through the bamboo, but that the bamboo would snap, easily after the multiple repeated hits in quick succession shown.
>>
>>100226957
Please don't compare Valvrave to this crap.
>>
>>100227043
I see you have never played with swords.
>>
>>100224160
>worst anime of this year
>January
You say that like it means anything.
>>
>>100226799
Jesus Christ that guy uploads a lot of videos in a short span.
>>
>>100227112
What some people do for trashy views
>>
>>100227043
isn't that the blade*
>>
>>100225503
Yeah ti's pretty ridiculous, but if you take it for what it is -- a dumb cliche storm -- it gets to be pretty entertaining
>>
it might be good if it`s getting so much hate from \a\
picked up
>>
>>100225503
It's a shit harem
Most people watch it to see what SHAFT makes out of it
>>
they shoved to much information on episode 1

also will Lancer coming back later?
>>
>>100227181
Good luck
You probably end up liking it to spite "/a/"
>>
>>100227181
Yeah, when in doubt, check its troll level.
>>
>>100227049
Yes,Valvrave is even worse than this
>>
It was even more bland and generic than Strike the Blood. I had to pause the episode at points to take in how shit it was.
>>
>>100227034
yeah, sorry. Can't ride that hype train. I see nothing appealing or spectacular about WCW's story or animation. It's pretty average in every way so far. Which is why it looks incredible by comparison to things like this.

>>100227043
Would have been fine if he was doing proper parries, but direct blocks is downright retarded.

That and the whole.. well, it was espoused upon already "Hurr dur attack human, he becomes wizard, I lose my powers like a retard."
>>
>>100226957
>I love her, I want to marry her and when this is over im going to confess!
>When its over
>WAHHH IM A MONSTER WHO CAN NO LOVE

Worst fucking forced cliche in literature. Fuck that shitty fucking show.
>>
>>100227363
>I see nothing appealing or spectacular about WCW's story or animation.
You don't want to be treated like a princess? That's probably the issue.
>>
File: 1384728277957.jpg (70.59 KB, 1280x720)
70.59 KB
70.59 KB JPG
>>100227322
No it isn't, What are you talking about.
>>
>>100227418

>blonde girl will not win
>alba mui will win

Why ;_;
>>
>>100227322
Yes, but Valvrave is at least on that point "is so bad that is good" because at least makes you laugh. This is just plain bad
>>
File: Wavergames.jpg (57.88 KB, 399x338)
57.88 KB
57.88 KB JPG
>>100225595
Sup Waver.
>>
>>100226229
Dont forgert the

>Sunflare is safe because burning someone's retines with magic light isn't damaging at all so it can't be considered an attack
>>
>>100227404
Yeah, that's likely the problem.
>>
>>100224160

I want to kiss Mui Alba.
>>
it's shit, but you gotta admit, the ED is pretty good
>>
This show had so many stupid/generic shit that it kinda numbed me throughout the whole episode, I didn't even feel mad about the bamboo sword.
>>
Put simply, it's a blender of various very generic tropes all thrown together in a generic way to create something incredibly generic.

And let me just say that even generic stuff can be done well - this wasn't. The first episode was a clusterfuck
>>
>>100226957
Exposition is good. Without it you end up with trash like Valvrave where no one has any idea what's going on and 90% of all discussion is [citation needed].
>>
>Miyano as MC
>Nao Toyama as FeMC
>Asami Seto as blonde tits
>Kenichi Suzumura as Yoshitake

Damn that VA lineup, wasted on this shit show.
>>
No point in watching it. It'll just be fights, asspulls and magic infodumps of the worst kinds. Chara design is nice but animation is mediocre, and I doubt there's even gonna be some good fanservice to justify the wasted time. Call me if this becomes a boobfest or if it gets so bad it actually starts to be funny.
>>
Did they explain the whole bamboo sword thing in the LN?
>>
Because it's that bad.
>>
>>100228645
Apparently it was a fucking broom handle.
>>
>>100228645

It also broke in the LN.
>>
>>100228438

Not to mention the ED by Nano



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.