[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


JC Staff once against proves its > SHAFT

Nisekoi is ruined adaptation of popular manga, full of QUALITY, having no relation to original material shinbo quirks and 3 frames per second "animation".

Meanwhile, WCW is a glorious adaptation of a kind fans could only dream of,

Why would any author in sane mind prefer SHAFT for adaptation of their works over JC Staff? Would never happen. I bet the person in WSJ responsible for giving Nisekoi to SHAFT is already fired.
>>
File: quality.jpg (792.40 KB, 1280x1440)
792.40 KB
792.40 KB JPG
>>
Does SHAFT even try?

Also, compare OPs:
Generic shitty jpop overused already in Oreimo and stuff. I bet you cant even differe different songs from each other.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=171RFw-u7Qs&hd=1

JC Staff:
Unique OP picked with real talent to highligh atmosphere of second cour
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HZpqa69qRck&hd=1
Godlike ED
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUTQuzoROdY
>>
>>
This season even ARMS, DEEN and Silverlink proven they are better than SHAFT, i am not even starting on KyoAni
>>
>>100175943
This thread reminds me that we'll never get glorious Little Busters adapted by SHAFT and we have to settle for that abortion from JC Staff.
>>
>>100175943

Nisekoi manga is shit. What the fuck are you on about?
>>
File: 2439.png (1.75 MB, 1280x720)
1.75 MB
1.75 MB PNG
I enjoyed Nisekoi and WCW, What do I win?
>>
>>100176322
shit taste award
>>
>>100176245
>DEEN
>Better than SHAFT
Sakura Trick only manages a pale imitation of SHAFT's particular quirks.
>>
>>100175943
>WCW is a glorious adaptation of a kind fans could only dream of
No. Its okay and all, but no.
>>
Can't really blame them on doing bad when they're doing the best they can with adaptations. You just can't polish a turd as Nisekoi is showing.
>>
>>100176322
Geez, runing a page from manga like that.. Sasuga shinbo! The more filters and inverted colors the better!
>>
WCW is shit and you should feel bad for watching it. It's DAL/IS tier of bad. And it's full of CGI.
>>
>>100176367
>pale imigation
You realize its done by actual people that are responsible for Hidamari style in first place?

Sakura Trick and Nourin are better "SHAFT" anime this season than Nisekoi. I wonder who still even works at shaft anymore..
>>
>>100176462
A turd like Nisekoi would be gold in hands of JC Staff or A-1. Oreshura was ten times worse, yet its still better anime than what Shinbo churns
>>
>>100176520
shittybait.jpg
>>
>>100176520
Comparing DAL and IS in same sentence already shows your fail. IS is quit high budget, while DAL is cheap as fuck (still great, waiting for S2. Fuck Origamis!)

WCW is rather nice budget adaptation from JC Staff, Golden Time gets cheaper threatment. Still WCW looks visually lot better than Nisekoi - which is like usual, is turning out to be Shafts seasonal failure.
>>
Starting episode 4-5 WCW will be /a/`s AOTS.
>>
File: 1388410861785.jpg (658.15 KB, 1745x1200)
658.15 KB
658.15 KB JPG
>WCW is a glorious adaptation
Haha oh wow anon, that's some pretty hilarious trolling

>left
>Fury of the universe
>right
>nyanpassu~
>>
>>100176674
Who cares about budget, it's about being cliche/waifu fest.
>>
shaft is love, you don't know what you're talking
>>
>>100176735
>edgy shit better
nah fuck off pls
>>
>>100176537
Well it looks like those people lost their touch in the meanwhile and they can only fail at reproducing what they did with Hidamari.
>>
>>100176735
I am manga fag, and you are retard. WCW adaptation is great. Or are you that guy that cries in Bones threads that they ruined Chaika?
>>
>>100176735
The left looks like horrible art
>>
File: 1388875360195.png (312.87 KB, 536x653)
312.87 KB
312.87 KB PNG
>>100176788
>>
>>100176788
>I-it's supposed to look like shit
And this kids is what happens when you're left without any arguments.
>>
>>100176735
le cool meme!
>>
>>100176735
yeah I was kinda expecting her to "become" flames rather than just getting surrounded by flames like the manga implies but ehhh that such a unimportant detail
>>
>>100176537
>You realize its done by actual people that are responsible for Hidamari style in first place?

Namely, the director.

http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/people.php?id=47628
>>
>>100175943
At least use Bones (Noragami) or Dogakobo (Mikakunin de Shinkoukei) if you want to bash SHAFT in.
>>
>>100176735
Do you want them to spend their entire budget to animate this one scene?
>>
>>100175943
Nisekoi is shit and nobody cares about the quality of the adaptation.

However, I was looking forward to WCW until I found out JC Staff was involved. Fuck JC Staff and their horrible CG. Oh, and lets not forget the godawful original ending they're surely force down our throats.
>>
Why do people even care about Nisekoi when it's the usual case of a good short series forced to become an never-ending garbage?

Manga is shit for ages.
>>
File: 1328993562426.png (25.08 KB, 250x250)
25.08 KB
25.08 KB PNG
>>100176735
But JC did a fine job making Flame Witch look broken as fuck.
>>
File: first kissu masuzu.jpg (107.81 KB, 1280x720)
107.81 KB
107.81 KB JPG
>>100176587
I miss Silver
>>
This thread is so samefag I don't even. Sasuga shitposter-sempai, stepping it up to the max.
>>
>>100175943
Oh, is this le new epic troll meme for the season?
>>
>>100176946
>But JC did a fine job making Flame Witch look like a drooling retard
>>
>>100176735
Jesus Christ her fucking face. She looks like she's high or something. Less wrathful display of power and more absent mindedly standing around in fire without realizing it.
>>
>>100176935
People don't read manga. That, or Nisekoi didn't become never-ending garbage until later (which SHAFT most likely won't cover, but isn't this shit 2cour?).
>>
File: This is a bait.png (356.51 KB, 701x295)
356.51 KB
356.51 KB PNG
>>100175943
>>
>>100177073
It's 2 cour, but people have been saying it's only 20 episodes.
>>
File: wcw.jpg (1.82 MB, 2279x1440)
1.82 MB
1.82 MB JPG
>>100176735
I like the manga, but i love the anime. Some static pages can not be reproduced (unless made static as well), but anime does most scenes actually better. Manga has a lot of poorer pages compared as well. The whole rabbit fight, despite CGI was ctually handled better than manga. Witches are cuter.

The only thing i like in manga more is Fire Witch design in normal form. In anime she looks more like normal girl, while in manga she seems evenmore tall and unfeminine.
>>
>>100176735
>dat face
nah OP you are wrong
>>
>>100176921
The argument with JC staff stemmed by a fact SHAFT fags pretend Shaft "improved" Nisekoi, while in fact its piss poor adaptation any other studio could habe handled better.
>>
>>100176164
>watakushi

Are they any good? Are they better then Horrible at least?
>>
>>100177143
This was really nicely done, I will give them that.
Flames are disgusting though. And the backgrounds are just dull.
>>
>J.C STAFF in charge of adaptations
>>
>>
>>100177193
Ain't seen none a that nowhere. You're talking shit.
>>
Shaft killed the Nisekoi...

http://yaraon.blog109.fc2.com/blog-entry-21214.html

That more and more people are buying the manga after the first episode.
>>
Could you imagine how shitty WCW would look if done by SHAFT?
>>
>>100177453
>Shaft fanboys buyiing manga
> on amazon
beyoung retarded

Nisekoi fanbase is WSJ one and they hate what shaft done with it.
>>
>>100177238
I think HS is Funi for this show, in which case it's tru hardsub shite. Either way, I use Wata, and don't see any fault with them so far.

The v1 for their ep1 was pretty shite, though. That was a preair tl without tlc tho
>>
>>100177494
character designs based on the original.
Interesting visuals.

chiwa saito
>>
>>100177453
You don't understand what anime is for. People are buying the manga because an adaptation anime is a commercial for the original product. They're trying to get you to go read the ln or the manga.
>>
>>100177494
Somewhat like Sasami. So yeah, pretty shitty.
>>
wcw looked like boring shit. I dropped as soon as I saw her entering the bus because nothing about the show seemed to be likable
>>
>>100177528
>this much denial

NiseKoi is going to get a big boost in manga sales. It's practically inevitable from having an anime.
>>
>>100177528
It's exactly the opposite.

But nice try.
>>
>>100177528
>Nisekoi fanbase is WSJ one and they hate what shaft done with it.
>they hate what shaft done with it.
Nice source faggot.
>>
>>100177563
>he can't into sarcasm
>>
>>
>>
>>100177707
>witch + guns
>hits lolis

Best witch.
>>
Nisekoi should first start using actual animation before even thinking of competing with anithing. The QUALITY, shitty effects and SHAFT backgrounds was painful
>>
>>100177855
Black Lagoon tier
>>
File: Wcw_16_0021.jpg (711.89 KB, 1119x1600)
711.89 KB
711.89 KB JPG
WCW is so good because of Tsutomu Mizushima, not JC Staff
>>
>>100177887
>>100177855
>[Melting Brain playing in the distance]
>>
>this thread
Go back to SeventhStyle, retards.
>>
>>100176537
>>100176904
He also worked on Maria Holic, I'm starting to think the only thing Shinbo works on is monogatari and meguca but has his name slapped on everything anyway.
>>
>>100177955
Bake is Oishi. And he left. The reason we are not seeing Kizumonogatari for so long is likely they had no one to make it after he went.
>>
>>100175943
No Fuck JC Staff, they ruined my favorite mange, The VA for Honoka is way off, and many of his Moe moments have been removed or don't get much focus.

I want my moe Honoka back.
>>
Even if JC Staff was better than Shaft, that doesn't make them any less shit.
>>
>>100175943
I just noticed smiley faces in the fire...
>>
>>100176904
>was episode director for of the most of Hidamari stuff

He is the genius behind Hidamari!
>>
>>100178115
So, you would be ok with it being adapted by SHAFT?
>>
Low-tier troll thread. At least the troll makes his own thread instead of posting in the Nisekoi thread. I guess he didn't get enough replies there.
>>
>>100178328
Can you refute any of the things OP said? No, since its objective facts.
>>
>>100178297
Not sure, don't think they would work well. But I just my Moe Honoka back.
>>
File: ISHYGDDT.jpg (30.54 KB, 600x450)
30.54 KB
30.54 KB JPG
>>100175943
>Liking this faggot anime
Nigger this anime is beta-tier, this MC's show even annoying than Nurutu
>>
Witchcraft, D-Frage... there were so many more interesting manga adaptation than Nisekoi on paper this season.

But Shaft delievered the best first episode of all manga adaptation. Great work, Shaft!
>>
Is this trolls trying to go for another round of their Trigger/Shaft/Kyoani studio wars? This is extremely low tier shit.
>>
Between SHAFT and Manglobe, which would you chose? suicide is not an option
>>
>>100177238

Their translation was fairly bad, it's probably best to wait for FFF.
>>
>>100178441
Nice troll. First Nisekoi episode managed to be unfuny and delivering story horribly, looking like detached mix of elements none of which shown correctly. Class scenes, knee hit, animalfarm, gangster wars - everything was subpar
>>
I thought Nisekoi anime was fine.
>>
>>100178540
Welcome to Nisekoi in general. So subpar it sells.
>>
>>100178540
trying this hard
>>
>>100178582
Its shit. Natsu no Arashi and Arakawa as well. Only anime only fags that just mastrubate to Shinbo style can find them ok.
>>
>>100178649
>the "Nisekois is shit so its ok anime is shit!" fag
I bet you would praise Yotsuba adapted by Shinbo too, cocksucker
>>
>>100178768
I would suck everything if it means that I get a Yotsubato anime.
>>
File: 1389372476832.jpg (253.63 KB, 1115x755)
253.63 KB
253.63 KB JPG
Do we have tolerable eng subs for ep 2 yet? How's shi0n?
>>
>>100178667
Arakawa was great. Fuck off
>>
>>100176322
Shit taste.
>>
>>100178831
Watakushi-Nameless was fine
>>
>>100178959
Arakawa was fun because of source material. It was however shit adaptation. Saint Young Men is from same author, and thankfull it was not adapted by Shinbo, thus became actual hit.
>>
Witchcraft was pretty plain. It's one of the JC Staff show no one will talk 2 weeks after the last episode.
>>
>>100179203
HAHAHA

HAHA

HAHAHAHAHA

Good fucking joke
>>
>>100179289
Its a rule by now, not exception with SHAFT.

Negima by Xebec > Negima?! by Shaft
School Rumble > Natsu no Arashi
Kyouran Kazoku Family > Sasami
Katanagatari > Bakemonogatari
K-On! > Hidamai (same magazine, while K-On manga was garbage in comparison)
Joshiraku > SZS
Dazle > Maria Holic
Drakuriot/Strike the Blood > Dance in Vampire Bund

I fully expect Memaku City actors to be worse than BRS
>>
>>100179353
Sad but true
>>
Although JC Staff does so much generic stuff - the only modern JC Staff show I know the name is Joshiraku. And Joshiraku is already some years old.
>>
>>100177238
Their karaoke went spastic on me during the opening.

Also, they mistranslated Mario star as Mario start situation, and I can remember a couple other places that sounded awkard.

They use "crafting witch" instead of "witch of the atelier" but so is HS so...
>>
So, as i understand, Tower witches are actual heroes, working to prevent end of the world, while Crafting witches are an evil sect that tries to maintain status quo and want to see the world end normally, rather than unleashing a power to fix it

MC switches sides and it goes full Shana?
>>
>>100182860
what



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.