[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: download.jpg (14.38 KB, 186x271)
14.38 KB
14.38 KB JPG
The last hope for the anime industry
>>
Does he nail his sister though?
>>
You're right, if this shit bombs, there's still some hope left.
>>
>>100162450
>The last hope for the anime industry
>SAO clone
>bland angsty mcdarkedge MC
>harem
>shounen asspull plot resolving

We're fucking screwed then.
>>
I hate to break it to you, but most are already predicting it to be the second coming of SAO. Sure, you'll save the industry with money I guess.
>>
>>100162565
It's by no means similar to SAO.
>>
>>100162450
Then we're fucked.
Trust me, I read the source.
>>
>>100162747
>bland angsty mcdarkedge MC
>harem
>shounen asspull plot resolving

so, how is it not SAO?
>>
File: 05-08.png (12.18 KB, 500x500)
12.18 KB
12.18 KB PNG
>>100162565
>SAO clone
>>
>>100162565
>>100162588
Yea, It's all magic and no video games.
The author considers himself a modern J.K.Rowling.

>>100162819
>bland angsty mcdarkedge MC
No emotions
>harem
Including love
>>
>harem
wat
There are couples fucking everywhere and every girl, who dares to make her feelings known gets a clear cut rejection.
>>
>>100162819
>bland angsty mcdarkedge MC
How does that even work with next to no emotion?
>harem
There is his sister. The girl that confessed to him but got turned down. And then there is a girl that might like him a little bit but really nothing more. Wouldn't call it similar to SAOs harem.
>shounen asspull plot resolving
It's not. Have you even read the novel?
>>
File: sao2.png (258.25 KB, 1600x900)
258.25 KB
258.25 KB PNG
DENGEKI BUNKO STRONG
>>
File: kagetane_manga7.png (126.27 KB, 405x271)
126.27 KB
126.27 KB PNG
>>100163138
Mahouka threads will be full of people complaining about Gary Stu.
SAO 2 threads will be full of Frodos.
Black Bullet threads will be full of people screaming "SnK RIP-OFF" to no end.

At the very least, I hope SAO2 and Mahouka threads will pull in the shitposters away from Black Bullet threads. Wouldn't hold my breath, through.
>>
>>100163138
MF Bunko J is stronger.
>>
>>100163238
Shh, you're only giving the IRC more fuel with your insight.
>>
>>100163302
The only good one I see is No Game No Life
>>
What is this, "download" anime?
>>
>>100163359
What he said. Although mahou sensou has cute girls.
>>
>>100163340
Does this "IRC shitposting crew" actually exist?
>>
>>100163513
It does.
>>
>>100162489
They aren't brother-sister , she is his cousin from his mother's side
>>
>>100163767
Oh... So he nails her then?
>>
>>100163797
more or less
>>
>>100163767
no she isn't
>>
>>100163767
What? They have the same mother.
>>
>LN adaption with high school MC
>any chance of being good

I bet you loved SAO too
>>
>>100163767
Get it? This is Gary Stu shit just like SAO, so the joke is the MC's sister is actually his cousin just like SAO all over again, even though she isn't. But even if it's false, it doesn't matter because no one can tell the difference between SAO and Mahouka anyway. It's all the same shit, amirite?

So funny.

Hahaha.
>>
>>100162565
>bland angsty mcdarkedge MC
>angsty

Silly anon, it's even worse. He's too cool for angst.
>>
>>100162872
But J.K. Rowling is the modern J.K. Rowling

Did you mean J.R.R. Tolkein?
>>
>Madhouse

Adaptation decay incoming.
>>
I thought you guys knew better than to reply to an obvious troll who's trolling this by using SAO, which he is also proxy trolling.
>>
>>100164143
Hmmm?

HSotD_WEG_MISSIONACCOMPLISHED.jpg
>>
>>100164196
are you talking of OP?
>>
I enjoy the first couple light novels, but damn if the MC isn't the biggest gary stu ever. Assuming I didn't miss anything here:
-Instant recovery factor (think wolverine), but can be used on others if he can endure their pain.
-Basically a computer for reading/writing spells. Can read what other people are doing as they cast it and can do crazy positional computations to cast his own.
-disintegrate magic
-with focusing gear can cause nuclear level explosions... with a drop of water.
-physically in crazy good shape, also part of a top secret A team.
-Is a top world magic tool designer. Overturns one of the commonly held beliefs of magic during the tournament arc.

Was kinda fun reading the first few, but goddamn it's like he had a checklist to hit every teenagers power dream.
>>
>>100162872
>Modern J.K. Rowling
But she isn't dead yet, or even retired
>>
>>100164443
Or good
>>
>>100164402
OP and the troll trolling with SAO are the same person.
>>
>>100164463
Yeah that
>>
>>100164196
Usually the people complaining about SAO are too stupid to just say Gary Stu, which is what they mean 90% of the time.

If you honestly deny the MC of Mahouka of not being a gary stu though then you're deluded as FUCK.

Mahouka really isn't that good, especially not "last hope of anime" tier.
>>
>>100162450
Another incest piece of shit, yay.
>>
>>100164438
There's no way you got all that from the first couple volumes. Too familiar of copypasta from trolls.
>>
>>100164546
You say that like it's a bad thing
>>
>>100164546
>Hating incest

Get out.
>>
>>100164585
Just spent 5 min typing it (with typos)...
If I remember right that's through book 7? It's been awhile, the one with the attack on the school bored the hell out of me. It's not til book 4 that you really start feeling that the MC is just stupid broken.
>>
>>100164618
No.
>>100164609
It isn't necessarily good either.
>>
>>100163359
You spell Vanadis wrong
>>
>>100164546
Get lost.
>>
>>100164666
Wincest is always good. Stop being such a faggot.
>>
>>100162450
I'm sorry to say but this series is shit, OP.
>>
>Hax/overpowered = sue

This is getting old.
>>
>>100162450
This series is so shit even the incest sucks.
>>
The people saying it sucks will be the first ones downloading the torrent, including myself.
>>
Angry hater in here amuses me. I don't know why he's trying so hard.

And this thread is clearly a bait thread, which he probably made to troll it up.
>>
I would laugh if by the end people would eventually call mc alpha and husbando.
>>
>>100164902
It does get used wrongly a lot, however it fits to a T in this case.
>poorly developed character, too perfect and lacking in realism to be interesting. wish-fulfillment.

I'll probably watch it when it gets animated. I'll probably enjoy it as well. But I'm not even going to try to defend it or call it good by any means.
>>
>>100164941
It really is. I dropped the manga ages ago.

I heard it's actually pretty damn popular though, in Japan.
>>
The SAO fanbase pre-emptively thanks the Mahouka fanbase for sharing its duty of containing all of /a/'s shitposters within our inevitably awful threads. It was tough going it alone in summer 2012.
>>
>>100165153
Whether a character is developed well or not is irrelevant. Attribute of perfection is commonly a trait of it, but it usually depends on execution and writing rather than the exists of the attribute. Tatsuya is perceived to be perfect in the eyes of the students around him, and such thoughts and depict are mostly because their abilities/skills can't compare to him. That's the case for most (not all) of them. However, readers would know that's not exactly the case since we read his inner thoughts and narrations of events and situations by the author.

Griping about realism? Seriously? Unless a series is written with hard science or something, any anime, manga, LN, or VN are not going to be realistic. One of the enjoyments of 2D is to not be realistic. And that's fine so long as it's enjoyable.

Wish-fulfillment can be applied to practically any character that anyone wants to be for countless reasons.
>>
File: 1375764629556.jpg (30.34 KB, 853x480)
30.34 KB
30.34 KB JPG
Haven't read the novels but if they basically adapt the manga then i'm fine with it.
I don't see a reason why people are comparing this to SAO though, it's not a harem, not set in a video game, and pretty much everything is explained whether you like it or not.
>>
>>100165524
>it's not a harem
since you didn't read the novels I give you the benefit of doubt and just say "not yet" instead of insulting you.
>>
>>100166752
I personally find it hard to call a series a harem when only one girl ever actually gets scenes with him. All the other girls have had maybe one or two good scenes with Tatsuya, it's always Miyuki otherwise. And those few scenes were spread out over the entire series.
>>
I got a boner for gary stu,s
>>
>>100166752
But some girls get boyfriends
>>
>>100162450
MC looks like Kirito, so it's basically SAO clone only with sisfuck, right?
>>
>>100169625
But it's Kyousuke.
>>
raped



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.