[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/


File: anibracket1.png (355.19 KB, 1200x507)
355.19 KB
355.19 KB PNG
I've selected 8 shows based on their status as:
>mainstream, popular TV anime
>from after 2007
>which are widely discussed and largely criticized on /a/
>and are not strictly romance/harem or Slice of Life (there's a potential second bracket for that)

I'd like for you to vote in this 3-round bracket to decide which of these "entry-level" shows is the one most enjoyed by /a/ relative to the rest. This is not necessarily about which one is objectively the "best", but rather which one you personally like watching the most from each voting round.

1. Sword Art Online vs Attack on Titan
http://strawpoll.me/1001594

2. Fate/Zero vs Code Geass
http://strawpoll.me/1001595

3. Kill La Kill vs Gurren Lagann
http://strawpoll.me/1001602

4. Steins;Gate vs Madoka
http://strawpoll.me/1001604

After sufficient votes (500?) have been received or the thread 404s, I'll post the winners of this round and the links for the finalists.

Use the thread to discuss your choices, make predictions, or complain about the "fanbases".
>>
This is dumb, and you should feel bad.
>>
File: 1372289428282.gif (2.47 MB, 350x318)
2.47 MB
2.47 MB GIF
>>100003551
Thanks for your input!
>>
Madoka > Gurren Lagann > Fate/Zero > Steins;Gate > Geass > Shingeki > KLK > SAO

Fix your brackets.
>>
>>100003477
>strawpoll

>>100003551
>>
File: 1353083181624.jpg (1.89 MB, 1661x2074)
1.89 MB
1.89 MB JPG
>>100003477
SnK beats Sao
Geass beats F/Z
TTGL beats KLK
Madoka beats S;G

Geass beats SnK
Madoka beats TTGL

Madoka wins.
>>
>>100003864
I can more or less agree with this list.
>>
>>100003864
Looking good.
>>
>>100003864
KLK>SnK
>>
>>100003864
This. And the top four are miles better than the bottom four.
>>
>>100004172
Only the OST.
>>
>>100003477
Ideally the final would be between F/Z and Madoka.
>>
>>100004258
>Nothing Happens On Titan
>Staring Edgemaster

>"Edgemaster your mom is kill"
>"no"
>"Edgemaster move the boulder"
>"no"
>"Edgemaster stop Jewtitan"
>"no"

>Actually
>wall is tidans
>:DDDDDDDDDD

10/10 its okay
>>
>>100004241
The top four are legitimately good anime.

The remaining four, well, aren't.
>>
SAO>SNK
It's actually enjoyable.
>>
>>100003864
Personally I would move KLK above SNK and maybe CG and maybe set Fate/Zero equal to TTGL but other than that this is about right
>>
>>100003477
>CG winning over F/Z
Sasuga shit taste.
>>
>>100004734
>liking Urobuchi trash

Code Geass is far from being good but it's still better than anything that hack could write.
>>
>F/Z and Geass are 50/50 split

keikaku doori
>>
CG and Zero are now tied
>>
File: ben.gif (1.49 MB, 300x300)
1.49 MB
1.49 MB GIF
>>100004789
>>
KlK is the only show that isn't even finished. Choose another.
>>
>>100004734
>Code Geass
>anything but a masterpiece
>>
>>100004654
Not really.
>>
>>100003477
SAO is the only anime you listed that fulfills the criteria you described.
>>
>>100003477

Wby did you even list a show that isn't finished exactly?
>>
Including KLK seems questionable since it hasn't finished airing yet.
>>
>>100003477
Look, I love KlK but putting it against TTGL is unfair to it.
>>
>thinly veiled recommendation thread
>>
>>100004930
I considered that, but being more than halfway through and constantly compared to these other shows I felt that I couldn't leave it out. Oh well!
>>
>>100005086
I laughed.
>>
>>100004991
You obviously have NOT been here long enough if you think that.
Each one of these shows at one point or another have been labelled "Mainstream shit" by /a/ and blamed for letting website X feel accepted on /a/ or board Y making threads here.

It's the way of the board.
>>
>>100004930
This. I don't even like it but I feel it's unfair, surely there's something better to use.
>>
>>100003477
Not fair that the 2 weakest shows here both get to be in bracket #3
>>
I really think putting s;g against madoka of all things is unfair. Its just an adaption wich leaces a lot out.
>>
>not harem
>Sword Art Online
>Steins;Gate
>>
>>100005254
And 1, 2, and 4 are on the same side of the bracket.
>>
This is going to end up being Geass vs Madoka
>>
>>100005388
>strictly
>>
>>100005165
I've been here long enough. I know what I said and I standby it. Out of all the anime you mentioned, SAO is the only one that fits every piece of criteria you picked, and as far as the whole "we're being invaded!" mentality goes, SAO and AoT are the only possible /a/ that really fall under that category since /a/ only started really bitching about being invaded like it does now after KS was released. Before then people would only complain about /b/ whenever there was shitposting or Gaia in the case of Naruto/Elfen Lied threads.
>>
>people actually rating F/Z higher than Code Geass

Just please just commit suicide.
>>
SnK > SAO
F/Z > CG
TTGL > KLK
S;G > Madoka (This one was hard, liked both but I possibly enjoyed S;G more)

Finals will most likely be F/Z against Madoka.
>>
I like how SAO and SnK are in the same bracket, because neither would ever reach round 2 otherwise. Geass has a free ride to the finals.

At least Gurren Lagann and Steins;Gate are arguable and might actually give a good showing against Madoka.
>>
Where the fuck is Eva?

- Sincerely /m/
>>
>>100005709
Man, the 80's were my favorite part of 2007.
>>
>>100005709
My guess is that he chose the anime that are uber popular right now.
>>
>/a/ having taste in anything
wwwww
>>
>>100005788
You're about a decade too early.
>>
>>100005709
>Eva.
>From after 2007.
>>>/m/
>>
File: 1375317817501.gif (2.46 MB, 600x338)
2.46 MB
2.46 MB GIF
>>100005591
You haven't been talking to me, but please explain how SAO is the only one to fit the criteria I've set. What don't you think the others pass?
>>
Pretty sure CG vs F/Z is the only actual poll on here that could surprise anyone. Maybe Steins;gate vs Madoka but I'd be surprised if 'dokes didn't win.
>>
>>100003864
Great taste.
>>
>>100004525
>edgemaster
>coming from someone who thinks klk is better than fucking snk
>/v/ memes spouted everywhere
shitposting is against the rules
>>
>>100005686
I was mostly just curious about which of the two was generally more liked, because I didn't like either.
>>
>>100005834
Sometimes I post retarded things. I knew I should have double checked.
>>
File: 3400292.png (238.36 KB, 640x448)
238.36 KB
238.36 KB PNG
lelouch vi britannia commands you to vote for Code Geass
>>
>>100005591
SAO is the one that doesn't fit, because it's pretty much just a harem.
>>
>>100003864
Geass > > > > > > > the rest

no need to thank me
>>
>>100006166
>Actually thinking that CG will get more votes than madoka or steins;gate
>>
File: 1387855752799.gif (967.42 KB, 490x367)
967.42 KB
967.42 KB GIF
>2, 4 both almost 50-50 split

Really? I mean I had a hard time deciding too but I can't imagine the balance is actually that even. I smell IRC
>>
>>100003864
Not 100% but I mostly agree with this. Good taste.
>>
>>100006592
I'm honestly starting to wonder if someone's voting multiple times.
>>
>>100006772
That's preposterous! Strawpolls are a sacred trust, what kind of monstrous person would sully their good name by doing something as shameful as proxying?
>>
>>100006772
That or a lot of non-posters who really like Steins;Gate.
>>
>>100006772
I don't doubt it, and frankly I don't care. It's to be expected. The result affects nobody. If one fanbase is rabid enough to proxy for their favorite show, then that tells me something too.

Again this isn't about which show is the "best artistic work", "best community" or whatever. It's about what your personal favorites are.
>>
> S;G > Madoka

really?
>>
>Steins;Gate, F/Z, TTGL in the lead
Fuck yeah, great taste today /a/
>>
>>100007375
See
>>100007315
>>100006772
>>100006939
>>
Stein's Gate vs Madoka was pretty tough
>>
>>100003477
>and are not strictly romance/harem or Slice of Life (there's a potential second bracket for that)

So long as you actually know what a SoL is, and don't go around calling things like Nichijou or Toradora SoL, sure.
>>
Why is Madoka in the lead?
>>
>>100003864
Wow, pretty sums up my view, personally I'd put Fate/Zero above Gurren Lagann but I'm a Typemoon faggot so there's heavy bais
>>
What if you didn't like a show while it aired but liked it on the second or third viewing?
>>
2 and 4 are the only polls that dont have an obvious winner.
Its probably safe to move lagann and SnK to the next round OP.
>>
Since shitposting is against the rules, that makes Sword Art Online the clear winner.
>>
>>100007650
You vote for the one you liked MORE.
>>
S;G>Madoka>Geass>Gurren Lagann>F/Z>SnK>SAO
>>
>making me choose between Kill la Kill and Gurren Lagann
shit anon, why do you do this to me?
>>
SnK>SAO (Though I haven't seen SAO)
Fate/Zero>Code Geass
Gurren Lagann>Kill la Kill
Steins;Gate>Madoka and I haven't even seen the anime for Steins;Gate but I've read the VN.
>>
>>100007856
If you had seen the anime that would probably change. The VN is a lot better.
>>
SG>CG>FZ>GL>MSM>SNK>SAO
>>
If the final isn't Fate vs. Steins;Gate, /a/ confirmed for shit taste.
>>
>>100007962
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KLK
>>
>>100008003
Maybe if it were a chuuni competition.
>>
>>100007918
I think one big reason Madoka didn't impact me as much is I was never into the magical girl genre, along with the fact I watched it in 2012 and knew about it being really dark, where as watching it live had episode 3 be a huge turn in tone.
>>
This is stupid.
>>
Madoka<Steins;Gate
Fate/Zero>Code Geass
Gurren Lagann>Kill la Kill
Shingeki no Kyojin>Sword Art Online

Fate/Zero>SnK
Steins;Gate>Gurren Lagann

S;G>F/Z

Why are SAO and SnK inluded in this poll. Everyone knows neither of will will make past round two.
>>
SnK > SAO, This bracket will not make it to the finals
F/Z > CG. This bracket will be in the finals
TTGL > Unfinished IRC fodder. This bracket will not make it to the finals
S:G > Madoka. This bracket will make it to the finals

Finals will be S:G vs F/Z
>>
>>100008216
>>100008250
Guess you have your answer, OP.
>>
>SnK vs SAO
Well played OP, that's about the only way either one could make it to the next round.
>>
Surprised about SG winning over madoka. Did not seem like /a/ liked SG that much compared to madoka.

Also what is with the capcha being so hard now. Seriously I can barely do it now.
>>
>>100003864
Completely accurate, though I'd personally move F/Z further up the list.
>>
>>100008419
More vocal, I suppose.
And yeah, I've been having problems for captchas since early december as well, no idea what's going on there.
>>
>>100008419

Fans of other shows could also be voting for Steins;Gate to just get rid of Madoka. Its just strategic voting.
>>
>>100007631
I never said that would be just a Slice of Life bracket either, but rather entry level shows that lean on the Romcom/SoL side. CUTE GIRLS

Was thinking:

Oreimo
v
Toradora

Chuu2
v
K-ON

Yuru Yuri
v
Non Non Biyori

GuP / Monogatari
v
Hidamari / IS
>>
>S;G is winning

Garbage pool
>>
>>100008419
I just found Steins;Gate more interesting overall. Though I may also be a bit biased because the third Madoka movie ending annoyed me.
>>
>>100008524
if it's romcom/sol, add Aria and Clannad, and throw haremshit away
Aria has to fucking win it
>>
>>100008524
Aren't you forgetting Haruhi? I think it belongs in at least one of the brackets.
>>
>>100008419
Check MAL or ANN. Steins;Gate was a historic hit with the Western ultra-casual audience
>>
>>100008524
>Non Non Biyori
What? And where is Lucky Star?
>>
>>100008524
>putting monogatari in the romcom bracket rather than the pretentious bullshit bracket
It's almost like you don't want to give the other shows a chance
Switch it for Haruhi
>>
>>100008524
SoL and Romcom are pretty different though, but that's fine.
>>
>>100008702
Right with Haruhi and SYD
>>
>>100008419
People hate Madoka because of the fanbase.
>>
>>100008662
>>100008657
Frankly I could make the whole bracket Kyoani stuff and it would work.

I'm looking at shows that cause arguments and shitposting. I don't think Aria qualifies for that.
>>
>>100008810
Are there seriously people who would vote against the show in a poll because of that?
>>
File: 1366508452548.jpg (101.03 KB, 501x540)
101.03 KB
101.03 KB JPG
>>100008867
Unfortunately, there are genuine retards like that on /a/.
>>
>>100008867
sure
>>
>>100008810
People hate all these shows because of the fanbase, that's the point of pitting them against each other.
>>
>>100008934
Madoka gets it especially bad because of all the shenanigans with the earthquake and the various shitstorms every other week it was airing.

There are far fewer S;G threads on current /a/ than there are Madoka threads, so people tend to call the show things like cancerous and shit, regardless of their actual opinion.
>>
>>100009029
Don't you remember all the S;G copy pasta? It's the Big Bang Theory of anime remember?
>>
>>100009129
Yes, but I'm talking *current* /a/.
>>
>Purposely setting up an SnK win
Redo the fucking brackets
>>
Useless shit TTGL is gonna win everything
>>
>>100009192
SnK and SAO should compete as they were both super popular when they were airing. Kill la Kill and Gurren Lagann because of similar staff, and the rest don't have much of a relation.
>>
>>100009192
It makes sense that they'd be against each other though.

Just how many times was SnK called SAO 2.0 before it aired?
>>
>>100009264
Madoka and Steins:Gate aired at the same season
>>
KlK goes out to TTGL
Madokafags>Steins;gatefags
SnK beats SAO
Code gay-ass beats fate


TTGL Beats madoka, unless I've underestimated madokafags
SnK beats CG due to troll voting

TTGL Wins the cancerbowl
>>
File: 1340496719701.png (815.91 KB, 1280x720)
815.91 KB
815.91 KB PNG
>Fate/Zero actually winning against Code Geass

Did not expect that.
>>
>>100009335
Madoka is losing right now
>>
>>100009332
Alright, didn't know that.
>>
Like the Denver Broncos, please just let Madoka lose. Thank you.
>>
>>100009560

Why? Its already won anime?
>>
>>100009560
So Madoka's gonna win just like the Broncos
>>
I'm kind of surprised Madoka is losing out to S;G, I'm pretty sure it was way more popular on /a/.
>>
>>100009391
Why not? Do you expect new posters to have watched an ancient show as CG? I'm quite sure those who voted for fate weren't around for the flood of Orenji and check mate threads.
>>
File: 1386276187363.jpg (76.03 KB, 445x399)
76.03 KB
76.03 KB JPG
>KLK
>mainstream
in your dreams, tumblrfag
>>
>>100009770
How is it not mainstream? It's the most popular anime of 2013 besides Attack on Eoten.
>>
Is there any reason you put the vertical series images horizontally?
>>
>>100009770
Seriously, it should be Bebop or Death Note or something.
>>
File: 1366496875793.jpg (21.81 KB, 612x585)
21.81 KB
21.81 KB JPG
>>100009832
>Bebop
>Death Note
>after 2007
>>
>>100009832
I'd agree but besides Geass all of those shows are only a few years old
>>
>>100009823
Because lazy
>>
the phrase "mainstream anime" is redundant, all tv anime is or used to be mainstream
>>
>>100003864
replace SAO with shingeki and that list is golden
>>
>>100009752
Code Geass came out in 2007...are people really this out of the loop?
>>
I really think it's unfair to have KLK up there. You probably wouldn't have included any of the others while they were half finished. I also think you should have mixed up the matches because group B shits on A.

SnK > SAO
F/Z > C:G
TTGL > KLK
S;G > Madoka
>>
>>100009730
and thats why its losing because the people who don't care for S;G or Madoka are obviously going to vote for S;G since Madoka still geting like 10 threads a day so they find the fanbase more cancerous.
>>
>>100009604
>>100009671
No.
>>
>>100009912
>all tv anime is or used to be mainstream

Yeah, because shit like Fractale and C3-bu are totally mainstream.
>>
Steins;Gate just made me feel really warm inside. I don't know if it's a better anime than Madoka, but Madoka didn't leave as much of an impression on me.
>>
File: 1360291015793.gif (195.07 KB, 640x360)
195.07 KB
195.07 KB GIF
>>100009950
Actually it started in 2006 but it was like late October and continued until 08
>>
>Not having Code Geass and TTGL in the finals.
>Code Geass not winning.

thanks /a/
>>
>>100010030
Movie was shit, though.
>>
File: 4317119750_4d5c719004.jpg (39.13 KB, 500x449)
39.13 KB
39.13 KB JPG
>Kill la Kill
>Mainstream compared to Meguca, SnK, SAO
By what measure was this decided? It definitely wasn't something logical like BD sales
>>
>>100009197
pretty much this
>>
Should have thrown out SAO for FMA:B, would have made group A more interesting.
>>
>>100009950
Hey man, that's 7 years ago. Seven.
>>
>>100010082
viral marketing
>>
>>100010082
The amount of threads on /a/, probably. There's at least three KLK threads up on /a/ at any given moment now.
>>
Wouldn't something like Monogatari be more fit than KLK?
>>
>>100003477
>2007
What's with that arbitrary choice? Do something like 2004, and replace KLK with something like Death Note since it isn't over.
>>
File: 1359145137097.gif (1.99 MB, 486x583)
1.99 MB
1.99 MB GIF
>>100010082
>BD sales

All the kiddies at LocalCon are definitely buying those Titan BDs
>>
>Madoka losing
>Code Geass losing

There's no way the polls are legit. Too late for today to write a script and correct the mistake though. Will do so tomorrow if any of those 2 advance.
>>
>>100010030
When Kurisu was brushing up against Okabe's face I couldn't stop grinning.
>>100010061
I found it entertaining, but it wasn't really needed. Steins;Gate already had a solid ending.
>>
>>100010082
This anon is right, why put up an unfinished show that isn't mainstream; just to compare it to TTGL?
>>
>>100010088
SnK would have been fucking buried if that were the case. You'd have the same problem, but reversed.
>>
>>100010161
>Monogatari
>mainstream
Name me a site that knows about Monogatari that isn't /a/.
>>
>>100009752
CG was fun and all, but it was a pretty bad show. And Type-Moon has been around for a lot longer anyway.
>>
>>100010218
Crunchyroll
>>
>>100010218
MAL.
>>
>>100010105
i guess some people are more with the times than others, personally 2007 series still feel new to me
>>
>>100003477
Code Geass > Everything else.

are you even trying OP?
>>
>>100010191
You forgot to mention
>Barely losing

I'm not that surprised considering they're being compared to decent titles.
>>
File: 1366316946470.png (181.76 KB, 350x350)
181.76 KB
181.76 KB PNG
>>100003477
>tfw my top 5 anime are Madoka,Code Geass,Fate/Zero,TTGL and S;G

I guess im a huge faggot who don't belong here.
>>
>>100010218
MAL, ANN, CR, etc etc. Only shonenshits like Gaia wouldn't know about it.
>>
>>100010218
every anime site in existance
>>
>>100010161
Either Bakemonogatari or FMA:B would have been better fits and stronger contenders.
Then again retards would say the former is a harem because they think "harem" means "more than one significant female character"
>>
>>100003477
>s;g beating madoka
kyouma stronk
>>
>most these shows
>mainstream
They may be popular with our people, but most are far from being mainstream.
>>
>>100010082
It's one of the most popular series on Crunchyroll. It's mainstream as fuck.
>>
>>100010218
I challenge you to find a website with anime discussion where people don't know about -monogatari.
>>
>>100010211
That's true but then group B wouldn't embarrass group A as badly as it does.
>>
Wait a minute, Geass was from 2006.
>>
>>100010340
Gaia
>>
>>100010292
They're extremely popular for a reason. It's rare that those kinds of titles are completely, irredeemably shit. They may be overrated and the fanbases may be awful, but they're hardly as horrible as people make them out to be.

There are exceptions like SAO though, I don't know why that garbage got so hyped.
>>
>>100003864
Madoka overrated.
>>
>>100010432
Try again.
>>
>>100010425
Tournament disqualified.
>>
>s;g is winning over madoka
either people hate madoka or s;g is actually good. Maybe I'll take a shot at it
>>
>>100010425
R2 was 2008.
>>
>>100008608
madoka movie 3 shouldn't count because it was essentially just an alternate ending
>>
>>100010486
>either people hate madoka or s;g is actually good

Both are correct, but I preferred the former in my own opinion.
>>
>>100010340
Just because there are a few dorks on every website still doesn´t mean its mainstream. Mainstream is asking people someone on the stream and a good percentage recognizing it. That is mainstream.
>>
Madoka > CG = F/Z = TTGL > S;G > KlK > SNK > SAO
If you disagree, you have shit taste.
>>
>Strawpoll cancer
>>
>>100009129
Big Bang Theory except with a well told and compelling plot, less retarded normalfag jokes, and more memespouting.
>>
Where the fuck is FMA? Angel Beats? Soul Eater?
Durarara? Highschool of the Dead? Mirai Nikki? All of those are more popular than Madoka, you fucking buffoon. You don't know shit.
>>
>>100010490
eva 3.0 was 2012 and it's not on there
>>
File: 1359744993464.jpg (1.93 MB, 4249x5000)
1.93 MB
1.93 MB JPG
S;G vs Madoka should have been the final OP you fucked up
>>
>>100010327
http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2013/12/03/monogatari-anime-series-has-sold-1-million-dvdbd-units-in-japan
Sasuga, anon

>>100010327
Still not on the level of its competition in this poll.
But regardless of popularity, I don't think a currently-airing show is really valid for this sort of thing.
>>
>>100010486
they should have been the two finalists, i'm surprised how retarded the brackets are
>>
>>100010600
Why the fuck would 3.0 be on there? It's a movie.
>>
code geass,nothing more to say
>>
>>100010627
it's mainstream
>>
>>100010597
>All of those are more popular than Madoka

There are idiots who actually believe this? The only one you might be right about is FMA:B.

>>100010650
The poll is for TV anime, stop being retarded.
>>
>>100010572
m8 let me fix that for you

first throw out the unfinished show, then

Madoka = F/Z = S;G > CG >> SnK >> SAO
>>
>>100010619
Then all of the yurifags and Homucifucks would've spammed the polls.
>>
>>100010609
Whoops, first response was to this faggot
>>100010218
http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2013/12/03/monogatari-anime-series-has-sold-1-million-dvdbd-units-in-japan

>>100010650
>I've selected 8 shows based on their status as mainstream, popular TV anime
>shows
>mainstream, popular TV anime
>>
>>100010292
I'm with you buddy.
popular does not equal bad.
Though opinions vary greatly with these particular shows.
>>
File: 1342810825213.jpg (41.48 KB, 500x224)
41.48 KB
41.48 KB JPG
>>100010572
Wow I actually agree with someone on /a/
>>
>>100010572
Everything is fine except Madoka should be lower. Why the fuck would Madoka lead the pack?
>>
>>100010709
>in Japan
We're talking murrica, dumbass.
>>
>>100010683
>The only one you might be right about is FMA:B.
You can't be this retarded.
http://myanimelist.net/topanime.php?type=bypopularity

In the grand scale, no one fucking cares about Madoka compared to every shounen out there.
>>
File: 1360038134849.jpg (86.88 KB, 800x654)
86.88 KB
86.88 KB JPG
>>100010597
>Mirai Nikki is more popular than Madoka
I literally burst out laughing. Go home YGFW

Also none of those shows have large, persistent hatebases on /a/, or threw the board into disarray which is really what this is about.
>>
>>100010683
Mirai Nikki is absurdly popular outside of /a/.
>>
File: Nobunaga Laugh.gif (2.62 MB, 275x155)
2.62 MB
2.62 MB GIF
>>100010597
>All of those are more popular than Madoka

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>100010693
If this is supposed to resemble any sort of playoffs you don't match the shitties and bests together off the bat, it makes for anticlimcatic progression
>>
File: 1373154914455.jpg (178.77 KB, 760x573)
178.77 KB
178.77 KB JPG
>>100003477
JIBUN WOOOOOOOOO
>>
>>100010768
steins;gate was actually pretty tame compared to some of these.
>>
>>100010768
It's about the most popular mainstream anime you fucking imbecile. Not most common targets for trolling on /a/.
>>
>>100010572
Madoka > F/Z > TTGL = CG > S;G > SnK > shit >>>> SAO
>>
>>100010569
Check the "top anime" section on MAL, bake and second season are both in the top 100.
>>
>>100010749
>MAL
>shounen
Go home.
>>
>>100010572
This is basically right.
>>
>>100010683
madoka isn't even in the top 30 most popular anime on MAL
>>
>>100010597
Call me when one of those show get nominated to win a oscar.
>>
>>100009897
>The joke

>several thousand kilometers
>Madoka
>most jokes

>this thread

>your head.
>>
>>100003477
Predicting S;G wins

S;G = TTGL = Madoka > F/Z = CG > SnK > SAO

Brackets are fucked up, should have made them better or done a straight poll.
>>
>>100010836
Let me fix what I wrote wrong.
Mainstream is asking people someone on the street and a good percentage recognizing it. That is mainstream.

DBZ is mainstream.
>>
>>100010749
Popularity on MAL just means how many people have it on their lists. It doesn't account for whether or not they like it or not.
For example, Death Note is number one for popularity by 100,000 people but it still isn't in the top 30 by ranking.
>>
Kinda unfair for KLK to be in here while it's still on going. Of course TTGL will be better because we already saw everything that it can show us.
>>
>>100004930
kik is better than lagann was when laggan was at this point
>>
>>100003477
>Putting Fate/Zero against Jibun Woo~

You fucking monster
>>
>>100010910
>Anime studios
>Caring enough to buy an oscar
>>
>>100003477
we're at just about 500 votes for each one OP
>>
>>100010922
I don't see any joke, I just see you pretending to be retarded.
>>
>>100010748
>We're talking murrica
No we're not you fucking mongoloid, half the shit in OP's list wouldn't be on there if this was the American mainstream
>>
CG > F/Z > TTGL > KLK > Madoka > S:G > SnK > SAO
>>
>>100010976
I agree with this, FMA:B would have been a better choice
>>
File: 1386646453955.jpg (15.39 KB, 180x157)
15.39 KB
15.39 KB JPG
>>100010910
What the fuck does that have to do with popularity? Unpopular indie movies get nominated all the fucking time for oscars. Most anime watchers are 13 year olds watching on streaming sites, not the people you find on /a/.

>>100010928
No one said ANYTHING about the quality. JUST the popularity.
>>
>>100007375
yes really

I suspect foul play but it still makes me happy
>>
File: 1367448308014.jpg (34.75 KB, 540x350)
34.75 KB
34.75 KB JPG
>Code geass is losing
>Madoka is losing

/a/ is dead.
>>
>>100010927
We're talking about within the anime-watching community, the average Japanese salaryman or working-class American is going to think Kyubey is some kind of Pokémon at best
>>
>>100010996
Are you fucking kidding? The only one who would be knocked off is Fate/Zero and even then, we could replace that with a show like Soul Eater or FMA:B. You're obviously from a poor country.
>>
>>100003864

Are you, me? That is exactly right.
>>
>>100010996
If its Japan, not even half would be on the list.
>>
>>100010172
He wanted TTGL in there. It's kinda obvious.

>>100010992
>The joke

>several thousand kilometers
>/this/ joke
>Madoka
>most jokes

>this thread

>your head.
>>
>>100003477
Just reading through the thread nobody disagrees with:

Remainder >>>>> SnK > SAO + Why is KLK Here

You could have found 3 good picks for this sort of thing, it's not too late to restart
>>
>>100011008
>KlK better than Madoka and S;G
2/10 made me reply
>>
Wouldn't Shippuden also qualify for this tournament?
Seriously, somebody should remake the bracket with 16 shows instead of 8.
>>
Come to think about it, Fate/Zero is not really on the level of mainstream as much as the others on the list are.
>>
>>100011008
Although it's still pretty unfair that KLK is here when it's only 13 episodes in. It'll probably end up being about as good as TTGL.
>>
File: Results.jpg (343.90 KB, 1447x761)
343.90 KB
343.90 KB JPG
The results, if we're stopping at 500.
>>
>Kill la Kill is too popular on here now!!
>Im going to act like I hate it so I feel different and cool
you are all pathetic, it saved anime!
>>
>>100011154
Fate Zero is more mainstream than Madoka.
>>
>>100011173
Code Geass and Fate/Zero need a runoff. Too close to call.
>>
>>100011188
Nope.
>>
>>100011173
I would prefer to see Code Geass win over Fate/Zero but oh well, at least all the other ones are alright.
>>
>>100011128
I agree with you
>>
>>100011173
>mfw I unintentionally voted for all the winning ones

t-thanks
>>
>>100011081

Long as TTGL is winning, all is right with the world.
>>
File: 4484.jpg (104.23 KB, 937x960)
104.23 KB
104.23 KB JPG
>>100010927
>>100010889
>>100010836
>>100010827
>>100010780
>>100010749
>>100010597

HELLO I AM OP

IF YOU LOOK...HERE, YOULL NOTICE:

>which are widely discussed and largely criticized on /a/
>which are widely discussed and largely criticized on /a/
>which are widely discussed and largely criticized on /a/
>which are widely discussed and largely criticized on /a/
>which are widely discussed and largely criticized on /a/
>/a/
>largely criticized

YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO DECIPHER THIS

THANKS FOR COMING
>>
File: Results.jpg (342.63 KB, 1447x761)
342.63 KB
342.63 KB JPG
>>100011173
Ah, excuse the fuck up there.
>>
>SAO
lyl
Should have put it against Naruto as a bonus round
>KLK
Not even finished airing

I think it should've been more like
Fate/Zero vs FMA or DtB
Death Note vs Code Geass
Attack on Titan vs Gurren Lagann
Steins;Gate vs Madoka
>>
>>100003972
Your winner will be outed in the first round, how do you feel. Just proves cancer threads don't represent /a/'s overall tastes
>>
>>100011154
Neither is KLK but that shouldn't be on there regardless since it's not finished

>>100011186
IRC you should keep it to the dedicated threads, you're just going to get drowned out in all the other shitflinging here
>>
>>100011123
You need to stop letting your obsession with cute lolis influence your taste in media. Madoka was a decent anime but it was far from great.
>>
Frankly Code Geass, Fate/Zero, Steins;Gate, TTGL, and Madoka are all good despite being entry-level.
>>
>>100011173
>520
>512
>500
>525

Why is this allowed?
>>
>>100011227
If you just said popular instead of mainstream there wouldn´t be so much arguing about that.
>>
>>100011264
>Neither is KLK but that shouldn't be on there regardless since it's not finished
I fully agree. Which would have been a better entry, though? Shippuuden?
>>
>>100011307
Why does it matter?
>>
>>100011188
>Fate Zero is more mainstream than Madoka.
I'm not a Madokafag and I wish this was true but it's really, really not
>>
>>100011298
How are they labeled as entry-level, anyways? Just because they're popular?
>>
>>100011227
Where the fuck is Bakemonogatari then?
>>
File: 1385327658593.png (241.01 KB, 491x491)
241.01 KB
241.01 KB PNG
>>100011186
OY VEY
>>
File: .jpg (468.89 KB, 1024x3001)
468.89 KB
468.89 KB JPG
>>100010735
If I think about it, you're actually right.

Madoka was good but it was not outstanding.


Ohh wait a moment...
>pic related
No fuck you. I loved the witches and their worlds way too much to lower Madoka's ranking just because of the silly girls MCs.
>>
>>100011376
because /a/ culture
>>
If you make the losers fight vs each other in a similar manner to double elimination, you can create a sequential ranking for all of the shows.
>>
>>100011111
Nice dubs.
>>
OP, your brackets are fucked.

For instance, SAO vs SnK, when clearly those would have been the bottom two when voted by people on this board.

Not to mention KLK isn't even over yet.
>>
>>100011329
Bakemonogatari, or the Monogatari Series as a whole
>>
>>100011227
Bake or Brotherhood would have been better than an unfinished show op
>>
>>100011298
>meguca
>entry level
lel
entry level faggot can't handle the Urobutcher
>>
>>100011383
op probably doesn´t like it.
>>
>>100011227
Just rename the fucking poll to "best anime that are targets for trolling on /a/" because the title as it is is the largely incorrect and a poor title for what the poll is actually about.
>>
File: Lets dudududududududuel.png (103.54 KB, 268x355)
103.54 KB
103.54 KB PNG
Whens next poll?
>>
>>100010436
That's an easy one. Imagine an anime that cuts out all the bullshit, good and bad. One that takes a sub-sub genre that's only popular in anime (LIVING IN THE DATABASE, DATABASEWOW), and makes it so simple that it's a heat-seeking missile of mainstream-bait. Give it a plain english title that sounds just odd enough to evoke mild 'Japanese culture' imagery, such as swords and art, but not hard to say.

Also, make it not look too horrible. Shit, SAO is more Gateway than 3 InuYashas.
>>
>>100011274
>Madoka
>Lolis
How retarded can you KlKiddies be?
>>
>>100011398
Madoka was pretty damn good with how it presented the witches. Each had their own story that's pretty damn sad and the designs are just marvelous with Inu Curry
>>
K-ON would've killed all of these shows.
>>
>>100010572
close enough
>>
>>100011575
No it wouldn't have, it's not exactly 2010 anymore.
>>
>>100011216
geassfag butthurt his anime is shit
>>
>>100003477
See
>>100011472
>>100011307
>>100011244

Okay nice rough draft OP, now go redo it without letting your retardation bleed through.
>>
>>100011549
Nice you sure told him.
>>
Come on OP post that next poll, I wanna go to bed.
>>
>>100003477
>Prefering S;G over anything ever
Holy shit guys, what is wrong with you?
>>
>>100011549
Apparently retarded enough to type out a coherent post that didn't rely on name calling.
>>
>>100011671
The competition there is not exactly stellar.
>>
>>100011671
>Prefering Madoka over anything ever
Holy fucking shit, what's wrong with you?
>>
>>100011472
I think the comparisons make sense, even if in a tourney sense they aren't really the best matches.

SnK and SAO are the 'biggest things', the really popular mainstream shit people think are amazing.
KLK and TTGL are always compared because of Trigger/Gainax and because they are similar
Fate/Zero and Code Geass both have 'unique' MCs and both shows still have large following on /a/ (can't think of anything else)
Steins;Gate and Madoka both involve time travel... I guess
>>
File: 1356506544515.jpg (19.64 KB, 466x359)
19.64 KB
19.64 KB JPG
>>100011671
Its better than its opponent
If given the option to watch Madoka ever again I would choose literally anything else
>>
>>100011549
It doesn't even matter. Like the anon said, Madoka was decent but it wasn't fantastic. Get over it.
>>
>>100011671
Are you a rustled madoka fan or do you seriously think SnK/SAO > S;G?
>>
Best taste coming through.

Code Geass > Fate/Zero > Steins;Gate > TTGL > Madoka > SnK > Kill la Kill > SAO
>>
>>100011745
>Steins;Gate and Madoka both involve time travel... I guess

They also aired during the same season, and were hated and loved extensively while airing.
>>
>>100011446
Th-thanks.
>>
If you faggots were going to make one of these with 8 or 16 shows and OP's criteria, what would they be?
Assume "From 2007 or later" includes shows that aired in 2007, even if they started in 2006
>>
>>100011707
Compared to S;G it's a literary masterpiece.
>>
>>100011671
>>100011713
>Not liking these shows even a little bit
Holy shit guys, what is wrong with you?
>>
>>100011745
But the purpose of the thread isn't just to compare relevant titles, it is to label the "Best current mainstream anime". So including unfinished titles and titles like SnK/SAO is unfounded.
>>
>>100003477

Code Gayass is 2006 you shitting corpse.
>>
>>100011818
>liking things
Holy shit guys, what is wrong with you?
>>
File: 1370684154376.jpg (168.47 KB, 500x500)
168.47 KB
168.47 KB JPG
>>100011227
Look at this fag.
>>
>>100003477
>SAO
ONE FUCKING JOB ANON. ONE. FUCKING. JOB.
>>
Looks like Madoka and S;G are neck and neck now.
>>
>>100011806
>>
File: animebracket2.png (522.98 KB, 1200x507)
522.98 KB
522.98 KB PNG
>>100011383
>why can't everything be perfect

Because I didn't, and it's too late. I'm sorry. You can make one if you want.

Anyways, the results of this round.

Next round:

A. Attack on Titan vs Fate/Zero
http://strawpoll.me/1002141

B. Gurren Lagann vs Steins;Gate
http://strawpoll.me/1002147
>>
>>100011745
Another comparison for F/Z and CG would be shit storm potential, I suppose. Father's Day/Mother's Day for Fate/Zero and lelouch died, /a/ cried.

though frankly I wasn't here for either so I have no idea if the F/Z shit storm was even comparable to the Code Geass one
>>
>>100011805
Then say starting in 2006 you double nigger.
>>
>>100011884
SNK is going to lose by a landslide.
>>
>>100011884
Fate/Zero wins by a landslide, as it should be.

Eat shit titanfags.
>>
>>100011884
Fuck you Op its not over yet madoka is now winning
>>
>>100011884
We already know its Gurren lagann vs Fate
Get on with it
>>
>>100011398
My opinion > your opinion

Nice.
>>
>>100011884
>SnK vs literally anything other than SAO/Naruto
>Gurren Lagann vs S;G
Well gee I wonder how this is going to turn out
>>
Backing Gurren to win it all.
>>
>Decision made when CG and Madoka are literally 5 votes way from victory

shit thread
>>
>>100011773
Yes, I seriously think that. SAO is shit and SnK is average, but S;G is beyond shit. I felt so embarassed for the director while for watching the first ~8 episodes before droping it. I honestly haven't seen any half-popular anime that was this badly written in every regard.
>>
>>100011805
With 2006+ I would do the following 8 bracket:

CG vs Death Note
F/Z vs FMA:B

TTGL vs Baccano
S;G vs Madoka
>>
Much as it pains me to say it, Kill la Kill beats Gurren Lagann. That episode 13 did it.
>>
>>100011884
>people are actually voting for Eotens instead of F/Z

They just haven't seen it, right?
>>
>>100011884
How to fuck is steins gate winning? It's completley tied.
>>
Code Geass = Fate/Zero > TTGL > Madoka > Steins;Gate > SnK > KLK > SAO

I want filthy Madokafags to leave.
>>
>>100011957
>mfw madoka and s;g are fighting each other in strawpoll
>>
>>100011884
Kill yourself OP why is Steins;Gate here?
>>
>>100011805
Not including popular SoL/harem is kind of retarded criteria, and i'm including things that aren't hated on /a/ but:
ttgl
baccano
code geass
fma brotherhood
soul eater
shippuden
monogatari
durarara
hotd
meguca
steins;gate
fate/zero
mirai nikki
sao
shingeki
watamote

The winner is obvious but the real competitions are for second third and fourth.
>>
FATE/ZERO GETTING BLOWN THE FUCK OUT
>>
>Geass now winning
>Madoka now winning
OP is a faggot.
>>
File: 1388837593550.png (426.57 KB, 485x614)
426.57 KB
426.57 KB PNG
>All these butthurt Madoka fags
>>
>>100011805
Death Note
FMAB
Angel Beats
SAO
SnK
CG
S;G
TTGL

Boom fucking done
>>
No Madoka?
Shit thread shit op shit polls
>>
worst brackets ever

fucking shitty thread
>>
>>100012086
It was rigged from the very beginning
>>
>>100012086
Eat shit Yurifag
>>
File: 1344823205391.png (450.17 KB, 640x480)
450.17 KB
450.17 KB PNG
>>100012072
>The winner is obvious
Go on
>>
hue OP got troll so hard.

Geass and Madoka are actually winning now.
>>
>>100012056
>>100012057
>>100012086
He said he will stop at 500 votes, reading comprehension
>>
>>100011991
So what, you want the poll to continue until those 2 get in the lead?
They lost. Deal with it.
>>
>>100012072
What is FMA Brotherhood
Is it after FMA? or is it Dragonball Zai?
>>
>>100012013
restart the thread with this already, and why were the votes not cut at 500, what if a different show was ahead at that point?
>>
http://strawpoll.me/1002180
>>
File: 1389128572187.png (845.13 KB, 1280x720)
845.13 KB
845.13 KB PNG
SnK > Madoka > Geass > Gurren Lagann > Steins;Gate > Fate/Zero > KLK > SAO
>>
>>100012082
Probably some fag with a proxy. Up until now, F/Z was steadily winning by about 4-6%.
>>
>>100012013
>TTGL v. Baccano
I could never decide
>>
>>100011884
OH BOY I WONDER WHO'S GOING TO WIN
>>
>>100012031
Because OP is a Steins;Gay faggot who literally only made this tournament to personally proxyspam it. Madoka has always absolutely destroyed Steins;Gay in every poll made here on /a/. These results make absolutely no sense. And
Look at his choice of image here:
>>100011227
He's a piece of shit Shits;Gay fag without a doubt.
>>
>>100012182
Clash of titans
>>
>>100011883
Madoka:
- Breaks several cancerous anime/mahou shoujo tropes, like friendship always winning, important charcters not dying that early, the MC being a selfless saint who helps everyone without thinking of her own safety

S;G:
Is cliche incarnate. Has characters as flat as molten Gel-Banana.
>>
>>100012199
There are people with this kind of shit taste? Go back to your circlejerk thread.
>>
>>100012013
FMA - Baccano and F/Z - TTGL would be better brackets but this isn't bad
>>
File: facepalmrob.jpg (42.43 KB, 919x532)
42.43 KB
42.43 KB JPG
>this op
>let me ignore truly popular
>vote on my favs
>>
>>100012013
Feel free to do that. I don't care about including Baccano or Death Note because as far as your everyday /a/ threads are concerned, they are irrelevant.
>>
>>100012156
remake that follows the events of the manga instead of having an anime original story for half of it
>>
>>100012199
>CG>TTGL
you huge raging pansexual monkeyrimjob
>>
TTGL>KLK>SnK>Everything else
>>
>>100012294
Shit taste
>>
>>100011884
just go to the final round OP we all know the fucking answer
>>
ABANDON THREAD OP IS CONFIRMED FOR S;G FAGS.
>>
SnK>SAO
F/Z>CG
TTGL>KlK
Madoka>SG

F/Z>SnK
Madoka>TTGL

F/Z<Madoka


Anything else is just silly.
>>
>>100012199


>KLK under steins gate and fate zero
>Gurren Lagann under code gayass

what are you, a faggot ?
>>
>>100012182
The butthurt could not be more evident.
>>
>>100012013
Baccano is from 2007 though
Heck both Death Note and Code Geass R1 finished in 2007 anyway
>>
>muh row row fight the powah
>muh magical lolis
>muh chicken benders
>>
OP is spilling his dr pepper everywhere
>>
File: 1.png (19.03 KB, 121x117)
19.03 KB
19.03 KB PNG
>>100012261
What about
>Ignoring plot points for Reasons
>>
>>100012393
Go back to watching Fractale, fag.
>>
Can't wait for the results of this shitty contest be reposted all over /a/ for the next week as 'official'.
>>
Madoka>Geass=F/Z>S;G>TTGL>KLK>SNK>shit>SAO
>>
>>100012381
i thought death note started in fall 2005
>>
>>100012367
>madoka lost
>the final will be fate vs gurren laggan
What a shit taste, everyone go back to MAL. Sage for mad
>>
Why did Madoka pass S;G in votes as soon as the OP decided that S;G had won?
>>
>>100004930
Personally I'd substitute FMA:B but that's just me.
>>
>>100011884
>Oh God Madoka is about to beat my favorite shitty anime Shits;Gay I better stop the poll right now and pretend Shits;Gay won
>>
pffff Madoka vs TTGL would have been way more close.

Now this poll is completely useless since we all know what is going to win.
>>
>>100011884
If you're going to run the next round then at least make a new thread and delete the old one. Nobody will see this buried post.
>>
>>100012418
Thankfully by the other week no one will remember them. Even if posted as "proof" of anything, everyone will just laugh and greentext.
>>
As much as I'd like for Fate/Zero to win overall, we all know that TTGL is going to win.
>>
>mfw TTGL is my favorite and is clearly going to win but this poll played out like shit.
>>
>>100012472
OP stopped his proxy
>>
>>100012472
Because as >>100012232 pointed out, OP is probably biased for Steins;Gate.
>>
File: 1389408103359.gif (2.33 MB, 592x496)
2.33 MB
2.33 MB GIF
>>100012476
>Poll goes until 500 posts
>Madoka was losing by 8
>B-B-But my late game
>>
File: 1389323971126.gif (222.71 KB, 173x261)
222.71 KB
222.71 KB GIF
>>100012232
Actually no, I don't care who wins.

I voted for SnK, F/Z, S;G, and TTGL

and then F/Z and TTGL

Someone IS proxyspamming no doubt, but it isn't me. I don't trust the steady influx of votes, especially early on when the thread was new. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if SnK wins.
>>
>>100012437
fall 2006
>>
>>100012575
>I honestly wouldn't be surprised if SnK wins.
Just how new are you
>>
>>100012552
If OP was biased for S;G he would have switched it with F/Z so it would be a finalist. Sorry to say but the voting stops at 500 for a reason, so that potentially undecided (or back and forth) results can be concluded
>>
>>100012415
thanks for the rec
>>
File: 324234.gif (197.50 KB, 500x281)
197.50 KB
197.50 KB GIF
>all these assblasted medukafags
>>
File: 1359774547596.jpg (211.67 KB, 940x568)
211.67 KB
211.67 KB JPG
>>100012418
Please don't do this
>>
No one is voting anymore.You should have made a new thread.
>>
>so much mad over people not voting for their "totally shitty casual shit" they favor

Face it, /a/, you have the same plebshit taste as the casuals you love to hate
>>
>>100012418
crying like a bitch because the poll didn't go your way is very mature
>>
>>100012575
>especially early on when the thread was new.
That means you proxyspammed it. Don't fuck with me. I've been doing this shit for years. I know every trick in the book. The only way to rig a poll from the start is to create it yourself and spam it from the start.
>>
File: 1361168999842.png (94.25 KB, 367x247)
94.25 KB
94.25 KB PNG
>>100011884
Can we get to the next poll
Its clear who wins this round
>>
>>100010786
Anon said it right, the voting has slowed to snail pace since the first round
>>
File: 1389125630048.jpg (58.49 KB, 300x356)
58.49 KB
58.49 KB JPG
>medukafags crying that the lost in some unimportant poll

This entire thread is retarded, but at least something good came out of it.
>>
>all this butthurt for madoka not wining
guys its just a poll its not like its official
>>
File: 1386894184319.png (165.13 KB, 285x311)
165.13 KB
165.13 KB PNG
>>100012732
Fine.
http://strawpoll.me/1002212
>>
i just cannot see how gatchaman is not on the list...
>>
File: 4cccc16ecd0bc0full.gif (1.03 KB, 49x17)
1.03 KB
1.03 KB GIF
>>100012575
>but it isn't me
>>
Looks like the love for pure girls wasn't enough to overcome Proxy;Spamming
>>
>Steins;Gate 361 votes
>Madoka 361 votes

Wow. I loved both of them, but ended up voting for Madoka. I wish they were on opposite sides so they could battle it out in the final bracket.
>>
>>100012646
>buttmad IRC proxyspams worst show to win because muh sabotage
Yes, how new exactly.

>>100012730
I voted once, at the beginning. Then I looked at the polls. Lots of votes were coming in early on, even though the thread was dead.

I thought someone was intentionally trying to spam a tie so there couldn't be a clear winner however, as that would be the best way to ruin my thread.
>>
>>100003864
I'm actually a little scared about how much I agree with this list.
>>
>>100012732
half of them are like 50/50 still.... how is it clear?
>>
>>100012864
>IRC
Shit, you ARE ridiculously new.
>>
Clearly all this poll points out is that Megukafags are out having fun on Friday night while S;G faggots are shit posting on /a/
>>
File: 1370909162721.jpg (183.63 KB, 800x642)
183.63 KB
183.63 KB JPG
So what's this about a second bracket for Romance/Harem/SoL shows? I think comedy should be in there as well.

If we're doing that, I think Clannad ~AS~, Toradora, K-ON, X-monogatari (maybe, depends on what other people think since the genre is arguable), S&W, Sora no Woto, Nichijou, and maybe Oreimo (for popularity, anyway) should be possible contenders.

Anyone agree/disagree with any of these?
>>
Code Geass is winning now by quite a bit so it should have gone to next round but you don't hear anyone but madokafags complaining
>>
Even though it's already over, Geass has been rising really quickly in the old poll


Some late proxyvoting coming in I guess.
>>
File: 1359146661765.gif (510.14 KB, 500x281)
510.14 KB
510.14 KB GIF
>>100012806
Fuck off
>>
>>100012806
TYPE MOON FAGS GETTING BLOWN THE FUCK OUT
>>
>>100012864
>IRC
You're that new, huh?
>>
>>100012864
The IRC excuse is retarded. Don't use it.
>>
>>100012575
That gif is making my heart melt.
>>
File: 1361515447307.jpg (17.92 KB, 420x472)
17.92 KB
17.92 KB JPG
Hey Medokasses
Lets put this into context for you
>A simple race to the finish line
>Team A wins
>Team B runs past the finish line after A has won
>Team B spews about how they went past them thinking it means something
>>
>>100012930
No, fuck you.
>>
>>100012958
Fate/Zero anime fans are not TMfags.
>>
>>100012921
>>100012960
>>100012974
I say IRC because if you're rigging a vote, its not just 1 person. And if its not just 1 person, you're communicating somehow outside this thread.
>>
>>100013031
Stop embarrassing yourself already.
>>
>>100013005
But I read F/sn, Tsukihime, watched KnK, AND read the novel before the anime came out, and I loved it.
>>
>>100012938
Because Madoka is a genuinely good show that should not lose to a mediocre pandering piece of crap like Steins;Gate.
>>
>>100012927
because everyone complaining about the S;G vs Meguka bracket result isn't a Megukafag
>>
>>100013031
it's too late.
>>
>>100012986
desu yo!! XD!!
>>
File: 1373999512291.jpg (41.86 KB, 300x297)
41.86 KB
41.86 KB JPG
>geassfags still voting
give up guys
>>
File: 1385191799526.png (262.24 KB, 962x720)
262.24 KB
262.24 KB PNG
>>100012957
No you fuck off. Stop trying to start shit.

Do I need to get a trip?
>>
>>100013031
Just stop making me want to punch you in the face, fuck you are new.
>>
HAHA EAT SHIT MADOKA FAGS
>>
How abut a poll with option A and option B and only proxifags can vote on it, so we seee who has the best proxis.
>>
File: 1389296922645.jpg (54.23 KB, 180x284)
54.23 KB
54.23 KB JPG
>Madoka blown the fuck out
Something good came out of this.
>>
>>100013065
You are the mass minority.
>>
>>100013134
Nigga Madoka is winning
>>
This poll: "Where votes are made up and the points don't matter"
>>
>>100013139
The only way to truly decide is through this.
>>
>>100012930
Clannad (whole thing, not just AS)
Toradora
K-ON
NIchijou
Oreimo
Oregairu
Infinite Stratos
haruhi season 2
>>
>>100013065
You have exceptionally bad taste for a TM fan then.
>>
File: 1360125357132.gif (2.84 MB, 250x255)
2.84 MB
2.84 MB GIF
>>100013165
Is it beating Gurren Laggan?
The clear winner on both votes
>>
>>100012827
I haven't seen a gatcha thread since it stopped airing then again I only browse /a/ once every few days
>>
>>100013031
It's OK to be new. Everyone was new at some point. Just don't try to pretend you aren't, and don't try to make high profile threads.


Have fun.
>>
>>100013242
>KS

Kill yourself
>>
>>100012827
It wasn't that popular or good, SnK and KlK are at least popular.
>>
>>100013225
Clannad wipes the floor but placement for the rest would be interesting
>>
File: 65434r5t6yu.jpg (46.25 KB, 640x480)
46.25 KB
46.25 KB JPG
>>100013065

Not reading KT for the Len. You make me sad.
>>
File: 1375043574302.gif (970 KB, 500x333)
970 KB
970 KB GIF
>>100013129
Have you really never been in a steam chat/skype chat/IRC chat with other people who are on 4chan? Have you never even seen screenshots of the stupid pointless shit they giggle over?

Are you really unaware that this kind of thing happens? It does, I can promise you that.

>>100013204
Now you're getting it.
>>
>>100013229
Why? The adaptation was done a lot better than most adaptations. The music was great, the animation was great (inb4 waah filters), the pacing was great, and the only thing that I didn't really like was Kirei vs Kerry at the end.
>>
>>100003477


It's just unfair putting fate zero x code geass
>>
File: images.jpg (7.05 KB, 259x194)
7.05 KB
7.05 KB JPG
>>100013295
>Madaoka
Kill YOURself
>>
Post the finals strawpoll already things aren't going to magically turn around for SnK or S;G
>>
>>100013225
Infinite Stratos > Haruhi S2 > shit > everything else
>>
File: 1389065031553.jpg (167.57 KB, 548x618)
167.57 KB
167.57 KB JPG
Why do people like ttgl so much? I've watched at least a few hundred shows but god damn I couldn't stomach that crap. I've tried numerous times and can't force myself past the 4th episode.
>>
>>100013225
>Oregairu

Nah, that doesn't really deserve to be there. But Clannad would win for sure as it should be.
>>
>>100013339
You are so stupid it's not even fun anymore, have fun with your shit poll newfag.
>>
>>100012986
Kind of off there.
>OP, who is clearly biased for Team B only posts a loose definition of where the race ends
>OP injects steroids into Team B the entire race
>Despite that, Team A about to pass Team B
>OP places the finish line right in front of Team B at that exact moment, milliseconds before Team A passes Team B so that Team B wins anyway
>>
>>100013425
I dropped this show twice before watching it past episode 5 but finish it and you will understand
>>
>>100013295

Is it still cool to hate KS? I want to fit in too.
>>
>>100013473
>projecting
>no proof at all
>ass blasted
>>
TTGL > SAO > Kill la Kill = Madoka = F/Z = Code Geass = Steins;Gate > shit > SnK
>>
>>100013425

You're fucking stupid.
>>
SnK would have won if everyone was being truthful
And you all know it in your hearts
>>
>>100013470
>I'm going to keep calling you stupid and new

Wow I'm so convinced, I can't believe I could make such an error.
>>
Quick someone proxy F/Z, I'll go to sleep if you do!
>>
>>100013537
>SAO better than KlK, Madoka, F/Z, Code Geass, S;G

Jesus Christ, off yourself.
>>
>implying madoka waifu shit can be compared to F/Z, Code Geass and Steins;Gate
>>
>>100013339

Excellent baiting, gent. 8/10.
>>
>>100013537
>SAO 2nd spot
Holy shit, are you fucking serious?
>>
>>100013346
I didn't think the music was Kajiura's best work and the source material wasn't very good. Urobuchi and the Nasuverse don't mix well, it's not dark and gritty enough for him.
>>
>>100013537
No
>>
>>100013537
>SAO
>better than anything
All the shows are at least decent if not good, but SAO is just bad.
>>
>>100013526

Go discuss it with your faggy friends on /v/ or /b/
>>
OP here with a trip. Btw I didn't rigged it.
>>
>>100013537
letrollface.jpg
>>
File: Pizza.jpg (52.05 KB, 605x641)
52.05 KB
52.05 KB JPG
>>100013473
So your saying OP Picked 500 votes to win while he Skyped all his buddies to vote for S;G and put a big wall around where all the Madoka fags were until the race ended then let them in?
>>
>>100013537
not bad but you should have made TTGL = SAO
>>
File: fornever.jpg (192.30 KB, 500x375)
192.30 KB
192.30 KB JPG
>>100013537
SnK>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>SAO
>>
>>100013607
>Nasuverse
>not dark and gritty enough for Urobuchi
Nigger what
Have you even read any of the VNs? Did you even go down to the basement of the church?
>>
>>100013537


le bait
>>
>>100013592
>madoka waifu shit

I don't get it? Im sure a lot of people have Saber,Kurisu and Lelouch as waifu
>>
>>100013574
Except you have a whole thread full of people telling you you're new.
That should tell you something
Or maybe you're not new. Maybe you're just extremely clueless, one of those guys who actually falls for the IRC thing.

In either case, you should probably just back off gracefully before you embarrass yourself further.
>>
>>100013527
Read the thread. Op is posting mostly Steins;Gate images. And that one guy pointed out how spamming at the very beginning of a poll is an indication of the creator rigging it himself. And he's right. I've made a few polls on /a/. Every single time I personally spammed them to get a head start on everyone else.
>>
>>100013607
I didn't think it was her best work either. That spot belongs to Madoka or KnK. I did like the overall feel and dark tone of it, so I suppose that's just >opinions.
>>
can we get the final round already i'm waiting for my precious upset
>>
>>100013681
Some people are just stupid.
>>
File: 1367701375175.jpg (143.92 KB, 936x1200)
143.92 KB
143.92 KB JPG
So we are at almost 100 votes here with no signs of it speeding up.

Would you like to stop now?
>>
File: Simon the Drilger.png (205.36 KB, 326x395)
205.36 KB
205.36 KB PNG
>Madoka thinks it can beat Gurren Lagann
>>
>>100013759

No. S;G isn't winning yet.
>>
Should have been Madoka vs Fate/Zero

>both written by butcher
>both composed by Yuki
>>
>>100013750
Agreed, Madoka's OST was godlike. I haven't seen any of the KnK movies though/
>>
>>100013686
>>100013664
>>100013657
>>100013649
>>100013625
>>100013613
>>100013599
>>100013586
>Being this asshurt towards one man's opinion

Yep, I'm on /a/.
>>
>>100013759
the final poll is here

>>100012806
>>
>>100013738
That wasn't the OP I am, he is just trying to make me look bias and dumb.
>>
>>100013810
Good god you people are mad.
This is just some internet poll, calm down.
>>
>>100013883
>post retard opinions
>get called out
>YOU GUYS ARE JUST B-BUTTHURT

Yeah.
>>
I think it's safe to say this poll is dead and gone before it even started, nothing to see here.

>>100013883
>Accepting shit taste
You're just an inferior human being from an inferior board, which you should remain on.
>>>/out/
>>>/v/
>>>/b/
>>
>>100013900
Anime is our life anon.
>>
>>100013681
In Nasu VNs you have a few scenes like that and then it's back to slice of life and cooking. In Urobuchi's the grittiness never stops.
>>
this thread is cancer
>>
>>100013930

Real final poll is here. http://strawpoll.me/1002262
>>
>>100010292
same here
>>
Since there's so much butthurt over Madoka, I'm thinking of making a Madoka tournament, where Madoka faces off against every other anime in this thread's tournament. Thoughts?
>>
>>100013738
No, I'm going to keep going, as I've actually been in IRC and steam chatrooms where retards were attempting to coordinate shitposting because "its funny".

Granted its not the illuminati like /a/ seems to make it out to be, but it does happen.

So please, tell me where I slipped up /a/-sama.

If anything, I think you're the one who's new, because you seem to think IRC is not a thing that existed before it became a maymay on /a/ last year
>>
>>100014019
Madoka is objectively better than everything in this, and I'm a TMfag.
>>
File: 1350806307487.jpg (225.31 KB, 517x817)
225.31 KB
225.31 KB JPG
Fuck it Gurren Lagann wins!!
>>
>>100014019
Don't do it faggot it's just gonna be a nightmare
>>
File: 1380681107850.gif (980.86 KB, 450x480)
980.86 KB
980.86 KB GIF
>>100013851
Watch 'em, nigga. It's seven movies of godly ufotable animation and Kajiura music.

Plus you get to see proto-Shirou poke some dude's eye out with his thumb.
>>
File: I hardly ever use this.jpg (9.12 KB, 225x225)
9.12 KB
9.12 KB JPG
>>100014084
Seeing Madoka even considering using Giga Drill breaker makes me litterally ill
>>
>>100014090
Isn't that the point?
>>
>>100013999
looks like it might be a tie
>>
>>100014142
As opposed to figuratively ill?
>>
>>100013980
And in case you feel like nitpicking, I mentioned cooking because we were discussing Fate.
>>
>>100014182
Yes, I just gagged
>>
>>100014080
>Madoka is objectively better than everything in this
>objectively
Fuck off faggot.
>>
File: 1382914658988.gif (949.37 KB, 200x182)
949.37 KB
949.37 KB GIF
>>100013999
SG is winning!!!
>>
>>100003477
Kill la Kill vs Gurren Lagann is just not right. KlK is not yet finished
>>
>>100014164
Steins;Gate is winning by a landslide.
>>
File: shaft head tilt.png (52.91 KB, 234x240)
52.91 KB
52.91 KB PNG
>>100014164
>there are people in this thread that actually voted for S;G over S;G
>>
>>100014269
Can't handle the truth? It far surpasses everything listed in every aspect: animation, story, dialogue, characters, ost, artwork, action, just fucking name it. Madoka is the Evangelion of our time.
>>
File: 1383485265430.jpg (435.75 KB, 900x624)
435.75 KB
435.75 KB JPG
can't we all just get along
>>
Here you go!

http://strawpoll.me/1002282
>>
>>100014473
Gurren Lagann is slapping the shit out of both those piece of shits you posted.
>>
File: 1388741906228.jpg (78.16 KB, 630x623)
78.16 KB
78.16 KB JPG
>>100014450
>thinking Madoka is better than TTGL
>>
File: meguca-versus-the-world.png (31.12 KB, 2632x1152)
31.12 KB
31.12 KB PNG
>>100014019
here have a shitty bracket
>>
>>100003477
How come Eva is not here?
>>
File: 1388092643062.jpg (52.94 KB, 347x433)
52.94 KB
52.94 KB JPG
>>100014556
>thinking TTGL is anything but above better than average
>>
Steins;Gate vs Madoka.
You're kidding right? Steins;Gate was decent but at least it was better than that moe trash Madoka.

That 50/50 is only there cuz the madoka fanbase is shit and they'll know they will lose, so they vote multiple times.
>>
>>100014532
>oh my god is it over yet I don't even care anymore
Of course you don't care. People called you out on your proxyspamming so you couldn't rig the poll for Shits;Gay anymore.
>>
>>100014635
go back to /m/ or /b/
>>
File: 1382711815908.jpg (74.88 KB, 1280x720)
74.88 KB
74.88 KB JPG
>>100014600
10/10

I'm inspired

>>100014635
because asuka is a bitch
>>
>>100014650
>moe trash
>cuz
There is that word again.
>>
>>100014650
Did you even watch madoka?
>>
File: 1387865456190.jpg (187 KB, 999x999)
187 KB
187 KB JPG
>S;G vs Madoka
>mfw I had to vote between my favorite anime and my second favorite anime
I voted fro S;G
>>
>>100014532
The girls in Fate/Zero are a lot more fuggable than in TTGL.
>>
>>100014709
yea, i did. Waiting for the movie fad to pass over so the shitposting can stop
>>
>>100003477
Fuck your tournament-based polls.

http://strawpoll.me/1002293
>>
>>100014762
I haven't seen a madoka movie thread since December.
>>
>>100014762
Too bad, the movie BDs are coming soon.
>>
File: 1386794524-ttgl-bait.jpg (106.55 KB, 625x626)
106.55 KB
106.55 KB JPG
>>100014642

>Not thinking TTGL is a masterpiece
>>
Lol Madoka didn't win?

Wtf I thought /a/ loved Madoka.

>>100014726

Die heathen.
>>
File: 1389389674201.png (60.77 KB, 141x188)
60.77 KB
60.77 KB PNG
>>100014650
>Shits;Gay
>Better than Madoka
>>
>>100014859
It's rigged.
>>
File: homumado nuzzling.gif (415.74 KB, 417x250)
415.74 KB
415.74 KB GIF
>>100014658
The funny part is I would rather proxyspam for Gurren Lagann, but I did neither, because I don't care about "having my favorites win". I'm interested in finding what other people want to win, which was the whole point of this thread, because I was curious.
>>
File: Sayaka20.jpg (180.57 KB, 537x759)
180.57 KB
180.57 KB JPG
>>100014894

Must be.
>>
>>100014868
Your shit taste is showing
>>
>>100014868
1/11
>>
ITT wahh madoka is so good why is it not #1 animes. poll must be rig waahhh
>>
>Madoka ruins another simple thing
>>
>>100015046
But it is.
>>
Madoka a shit.
>>
File: 1388869680935.jpg (184.81 KB, 496x749)
184.81 KB
184.81 KB JPG
>>100014642
I haven't even watched Madoka yet, I just really like TTGL
>yfw I'm a huge faggot
>>
The one thing we can take away from this cancer is that SAO a shit
>>
>>100015163
Don't tell MAL kiddies.
>>
File: 1388122608979.jpg (21.33 KB, 274x386)
21.33 KB
21.33 KB JPG
>>100015010
>>100015029

Buttblasted Shits;Gay fags detected
>>
>>100015153
TTGL > Madoka
>>
File: laughing man.jpg (18.73 KB, 432x352)
18.73 KB
18.73 KB JPG
>>100015229
I loved them both, but I liked S;G a bit more.

>mfw you're still 13
>>
File: 1389226901856.gif (1.75 MB, 193x109)
1.75 MB
1.75 MB GIF
>>100015229
you mad nigga
>>
>>100015153
/v/ pls go and stay go
>>
>>100014853
It isn't. The characters were done developing by the end of the first season, the action scenes are intentionally meat headed and simplistic, the "inspirational dialogue" is mostly meaningless gobbelygook, and the second season is generally shit. Fate/Zero is much better.
>>
>>100015571


Bla bla bla unargumented bullshit and wrong affirmations.
>>
>>100015315
TTGL is probably my favorite anime right now we'll see if that changes when I watch Madoka, but I seriously doubt it
>>
>>100015555
>someone hasn't watched my favorite animu?! They must be from /v/!
Never change /a/
>>
>>100015912
>hasn't watched the most iconic anime of the last 5 years
Probably new
>posted a /v/ image
Probably /v/
>>
>>100015765

Madoka was inanely good m8.

It blew me away. And I hate moeshit and SoLshit.
>>
>>100016087
that's because Madoka was neither of those, you shitter
I bet you have a 45% winrate in dota 2
>>
>>100016028
Not the anon you're replying to, but you do realize that the majority of /a/ are people from /v/, Thus the madoka shitposts

>>100015765
TTGL will always be better than moeshit

>>100016087
thnx for the laugh m8
>>
>>100016087
Man, did you even fucking watching Madoka?
>>
File: 1381622497485.gif (304.51 KB, 400x280)
304.51 KB
304.51 KB GIF
>>100016144
>I bet you have a 45% winrate in dota 2
What the fuck? Why this so suddenly?
>>
>>100016183
>the majority of /a/ are people from /v/
I do not care where people come from as long as they don't make it blindingly obvious that they haven't lurked enough
>>
>>100016028
>most iconic anime of the last 5 years
Do people actually believe this?
I mean, I thought it was funny that hardly anyone was watching Madoka, threads from episode 1 and 2 404 really fast, but then Urobutcher decided to kill Mami and then suddenly it's the best anime of all time.
>>
>>100016300
yes yes
>>
>>100016300
lurk more, faget
>>
So the crossboarders still haven't left from the GET yet?
>>
Here's the Madoka tournament:
>>100016366
>>
File: oreki what.jpg (41.15 KB, 390x478)
41.15 KB
41.15 KB JPG
>>100016357
>hardly anyone was watching Madoka
>>
File: Spoiler Image (93.09 KB, 216x212)
93.09 KB
93.09 KB PNG
>>100016144

I know but looking at it with no knowledge of the series it could appear to be.


I haven't played much dota2 but I'm pretty sure I'm positive.
>>
>>100016452
Reported
>>
>>100015571
Some of the dialogue isn't that bad, but I pretty much agree about the other stuff. Shame it'll probably win anyways.
>>
Madoka Magika
435 votes (51%)
Stein's;Gate
426 votes (49%)
861 total votes

The fuck, /a/? Where my homus at.
>>
>>100016785

The votes for the first round are already over
>>
Oh shit i went full retard

>>100016478
hi VENUMB
>>
Whare is FMA:B?



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.